Defaults and Sharing Personal Information about the COVID-19 infections

How to cite

Sasaki, Shusaku. 2024. "Defaults and Sharing Personal Information about the COVID-19 infections." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013191. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13191-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Shusaku Sasaki*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013191
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13191-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-03-15 – 2027-03-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13191

Abstract

This study experimentally examines how default settings influence individuals’ decision to share their personal information, such as the COVID-19 infection experiences and behavioral history, in the wake of a future pandemic. During the COVID-19 pandemic, scientific technologies for contact tracing were introduced to accurately identify signs of the spread of infection and take immediate actions. However, in many countries, the rate at which people accepted the technology and shared information about their infections and social contacts was low. For example, individuals were required to download a contact tracing application in order to accept the technology, and such the procedure possibly determined the rate. On the other hand, it has been discussed that, in order to increase the rate of information sharing, it is necessary to adopt a method in which information about people's infections and contacts is tracked by default and they are allowed to exit from the tracked condition through an additional procedure. In this study, we label the former as “pre-opt-in” and the latter as “post-opt-out.” This study creates the conditions of pre-opt-in and post-opt-out on an online survey. We ask those recently infected with COVID-19 questions about date of infection, vaccination status, heath status, smoking habits, alcohol consumption, height and weight, symptoms, and social contacts. However, since this is private information, respondents can choose not to provide it (the attendance fee does not change if they choose not to provide it). In the pre-opt-in condition, respondents are asked if they are willing to answer these questions before the questions are displayed. In the post-opt-out condition, respondents are asked if they are willing to provide response data for these questions after they have answered these questions. Using a randomized controlled trial, we evaluate how the difference between the pre-opt-in and post-opt-out conditions affects the rate of information sharing and the distribution of shared information.

Intervention

A) Pre-opt-in: Participants will be asked if they are willing to answer the questions about the COVID-19 infections and social contacts before the questions are displayed. Those who agree will proceed to the questions’ page and answer them.
B) Post-opt-out: Participants will be asked if they are willing to provide response data for the COVID-19 questions after they have answered the questions. The data of those who disagree will be deleted.
C) Control: Participants will not be given the option of not sharing information about their COVID-19 infections and social contacts, while being offered additional rewards.

D) Pre-opt-in + Opt-in-communication: Participants will be asked if they are willing to answer the questions about the COVID-19 infections and social contacts before the questions are displayed. Those who agree will proceed to the questions’ page and answer them. Here, in the question asking whether or not to answer, the “yes” option is selected by default.
E) Pre-opt-in + Opt-out-communication: Participants will be asked if they are willing to answer the questions about the COVID-19 infections and social contacts before the questions are displayed. Those who agree will proceed to the questions’ page and answer them. Here, in the question asking whether or not to answer, the “no” option is selected by default.
F) Post-opt-out + Opt-in-communication: Participants will be asked if they are willing to provide response data for the COVID-19 questions after they have answered the questions. The data of those who disagree will be deleted. Here, in the question asking whether or not to provide, the “yes” option is selected by default.
G) Post-opt-out + Opt-out-communication: Participants will be asked if they are willing to provide response data for the COVID-19 questions after they have answered the questions. The data of those who disagree will be deleted. Here, in the question asking whether or not to provide, the “no” option is selected by default.

H) WTA: Participants will be asked, in a financially incentivized format, about their willingness to accept (WTA) for sharing the information about their COVID-19 infections and social contacts.

Experimental design

In this experiment, we randomly assign respondents to one of the eight groups:

A) Pre-opt-in: Participants will be asked if they are willing to answer the questions about the COVID-19 infections and social contacts before the questions are displayed. Those who agree will proceed to the questions’ page and answer them.
B) Post-opt-out: Participants will be asked if they are willing to provide response data for the COVID-19 questions after they have answered the questions. The data of those who disagree will be deleted.
C) Control: Participants will not be given the option of not sharing information about their COVID-19 infections and social contacts, while being offered additional rewards.

D) Pre-opt-in + Opt-in-communication: Participants will be asked if they are willing to answer the questions about the COVID-19 infections and social contacts before the questions are displayed. Those who agree will proceed to the questions’ page and answer them. Here, in the question asking whether or not to answer, the “yes” option is selected by default.
E) Pre-opt-in + Opt-out-communication: Participants will be asked if they are willing to answer the questions about the COVID-19 infections and social contacts before the questions are displayed. Those who agree will proceed to the questions’ page and answer them. Here, in the question asking whether or not to answer, the “no” option is selected by default.
F) Post-opt-out + Opt-in-communication: Participants will be asked if they are willing to provide response data for the COVID-19 questions after they have answered the questions. The data of those who disagree will be deleted. Here, in the question asking whether or not to provide, the “yes” option is selected by default.
G) Post-opt-out + Opt-out-communication: Participants will be asked if they are willing to provide response data for the COVID-19 questions after they have answered the questions. The data of those who disagree will be deleted. Here, in the question asking whether or not to provide, the “no” option is selected by default.

H) WTA: Participants will be asked, in a financially incentivized format, about their willingness to accept (WTA) for sharing the information about their COVID-19 infections and social contacts.

Design details

Randomization method
Stratified randomization by a survey company. The strata are based on sex (male/female), age (20-39/40-49/50-59/60-79), and region (urban/rural).
Randomization unit
Individuals
Clusters
N/A
Observations
8,000 individuals
Arms
1,000 individuals
Primary outcomes
Whether or not respondents share the information about their COVID-19 infections and social contacts (1/0)
Secondary outcomes
- The distributions of shared information (date of infection, vaccination status, health status, smoking habits, alcohol consumption, height and weight, symptoms, and social contacts) - Autonomy and emotional burden (1) Did you want to share the information voluntarily?, (2) Did you think you were being forced to share the information?, (3) Did you feel distressed when you read the explanation, and (4) Did you feel that the explanation needed to be improved?

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords