The Dark Side of Digital -- Evidence from a Field Experiment

How to cite

Pinna, Lorenzo; Blasco, Andrea. 2025. "The Dark Side of Digital -- Evidence from a Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013182. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13182-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lorenzo Pinna* , Andrea Blasco

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013182
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13182-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2025-02-25 – 2025-05-15
Countries
Belgium (), Germany (), France (), Italy (), Sweden ()
JEL codes
C21, C83, C90, D12, D83, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13182

Abstract

We examine the impact of a social-norm intervention on healthy smartphone use and student well-being. We will recruit 12,000 students aged 18 and 30 across five European countries. Participants will be randomly assigned to a social-norm intervention, where they compare their smartphone use to their peers' median, or a self-reflection control that provides no comparison with peers. We will collect several measures on students' well-being and smartphone habits, including objective screen time statistics. Additionally, we will assess the effectiveness of a "nudge" intervention, where students receive tips for healthier smartphone use: setting time limits, a digital detox, keeping the phone outside the bedroom at night, or a control condition (no tips). This study builds on prior experimental research testing the effectiveness of social-norm interventions in various fields, extending their application to correcting misperceptions about smartphone use. Our findings will contribute to the literature on digital addiction and the risks of excessive use of social media, highlighting the role of social-norm misperceptions and informing the design of public policies to mitigate excessive social media consumption.

Intervention

The experiment will consist of two primary interventions: (1) a social norm intervention and (2) a nudge intervention to reduce students' screen time. A third ancillary intervention will consist of (3) making mandatory vs voluntary screenshot uploads of Screen Time statistics. This treatment is intended to ensure the accuracy of the data on students' screen time while, at the same time, reducing the burden on students completing the survey, minimising the risk of attrition.

Experimental design

The sample will be divided into eight treatment groups corresponding to all possible combinations for 2 (social norms) x 4 (nudges) treatments. The randomisation will be done at the individual level -- each student will be randomly assigned to one of the eight treatment cells. To ensure a balanced treatment assignment, we will use a stratified randomisation by country, gender, and age. Independently, about half of the students will be also randomly assigned to the mandatory vs non-mandatory screenshot upload group.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomisation will be prepared on a computer and saved on a spreadsheet file. The random assignment will be clustered by country, age, education, and gender and shared with the panel provider for implementation.
Randomization unit
Individual students who participate in the survey.
Clusters
The random assignment is clustered by country, age, gender, and education.
Observations
12,000 students from the first survey.
Arms
(12/8) ± 1500 per treatment arm;
Primary outcomes
Before the follow-up: 1. self-reported ideal screen time After the follow-up: 2. life satisfaction, happiness and loneliness scale (from the European Social Survey) 3. fear of missing out scale [@przybylski2013fear, 10 items] 4. smartphone addiction scale [@lopez2017short, 10 items] 5. active vs passive social media consumption scale 6. academic performance 7. change in screen time as measured by the phone's Screen Time statistics
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcome variables are individual attitudes towards smartphones overall and social media in particular, including attitudes towards different forms of regulation and whether social media companies are transparent and/or responsible for regulation. The variables are: 1. Perceived negative vs positive impact of social media on students 2. Perceived smartphone "make life better or worse" 3. Concerns about digital addiction risks for students of their age 4. Perceived transparency of social media companies 5. Whether the government should regulate smartphone use and what interventions.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords