Resilience to climate change: diversification strategies and correlation neglect

How to cite

Paschoaleto, Rafael Duarte Lisboa; Ibanez, Marcela; Rincón, Ferley. 2024. "Resilience to climate change: diversification strategies and correlation neglect." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013177. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13177-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Rafael Duarte Lisboa Paschoaleto* , Marcela Ibanez , Ferley Rincón

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013177
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13177-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-03-04 – 2024-07-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13177

Abstract

As the frequency and severity of extreme weather events increase, smallholder farmers face growing vulnerability. Crop diversification can act as insurance against climate variability, but the presence of correlation neglect in farmers' decision making could lead to suboptimal risk management. Our study examines the relationship between income diversification and correlation neglect among smallholder farmers. Firstly, we assess the extent of correlation neglect and its effects on investments and land use decisions. Next, we examine methods for reducing correlation neglect by comparing different ways of presenting historical information on the profitability of two crops. We propose that integrating information, such as presenting the returns of both crops together, may facilitate the comparison of investment options and reduce cognitive limitations that contribute to correlation neglect. To test this hypothesis, we assess investment decisions based on different information-providing treatments in a framed field experiment with farmers in rural Brazil. Moreover, we investigate whether the treatments improve the accuracy of beliefs about the returns of the two crops. We contribute to the empirical literature on correlation neglect by applying the framework to the specific context of agricultural decision-making in a developing country and by investigating a potential mechanism to reduce this bias.

Intervention

The intervention is situated in Assis, Brazil, a region heavily reliant on agricultural activities. Our study employs a well-structured lab in the field experiment framed with real economic incentives, complemented by survey data. Participants will engage with a questionnaire in loco, individually, electronically, and with an anticipated completion time ranging from 90 to 120 minutes.
Our primary objective is to examine the presence of correlation neglect in the participants decisions, gauging not only its presence, but also the extent to which it manifests. In particular, we aim at understanding how correlation neglect relates with both the degree of correlation across decision problems and the individual degree of risk aversion among participants.
Next, we intend to evaluate the impact of integrated information provision on mitigating correlation neglect and/or fostering increased crop diversification. To discern such effects, participants will be randomly assigned to either the integrated or segregated information treatments. While the informational content remains consistent across both groups, the representation of assets’ returns differs—presented either jointly in a single graph or distinctly in two separate graphs.
As a secondary objective, we investigate whether the participants’ beliefs about the distribution of returns is more accurate when the information is provided jointly. For this reason, we include belief elicitation questions following the allocation decision problems.

Experimental design

We use a between-within-subjects experimental design, wherein participants answer a questionnaire delivered in loco via tablets. Each participant is tasked with making a series of investment decisions involving varying degrees of correlation among asset returns, i.e., negative correlation, no correlation and positive correlation. In addition, participants are randomly assigned to one of two treatments:
• Integrated Information: assets returns' distribution data is presented jointly.
• Segregated Information: assets returns' distribution data is presented separately.
Randomization will be made at the individual level upon start of the questionnaire and it is computer-based, i.e., calculated by the experiment programming tool oTree (Holzmeister, 2017). The experiment has six parts.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be made at the individual level at the beginning of the questionnaire. The randomization is computer-based and will be calculated using the experiment programming tool, oTree.
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
None.
Observations
200 farmers from the region of Assis, Brazil.
Arms
100 farmers will be assigned to the integrated treatment, and 100 to the segregated treatment.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are the measures of correlation neglect. We use two different measures; (i) the share allocated to the dominated asset, and (ii) the distance between the theoretical optimal and the actual allocation to the dominated asset.
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcome is a measure of belief about the returns of the investment options. We use an instrument that comprises three different belief elicitation questions.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords