Targeting welfare programs to construction workers
How to cite
Srivastava, Kartik; Ramachandran, Sabareesh. 2024. "Targeting welfare programs to construction workers." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013166. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13166-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study examines interventions to improve the delivery and targeting of welfare programs for construction workers in Odisha, India. Construction workers are a vulnerable population exposed to a high degree of physical and expropriation risk, and the state has designed a range of welfare programs intended specifically for them. Despite high awareness, enrollment is constrained by transaction costs and information barriers. Using a cluster-randomized design, we will compare two approaches: (1) reducing transaction costs via government-led onsite registration and (2) addressing information asymmetries through clear, actionable enrollment guidance. We will test treatment effects on a range of outcomes, including labor card enrollment, benefit access, costs of application, labor supply, and earnings. The study contributes to key questions in the public economics and development economics literatures by evaluating cost-effective mechanisms to improve program uptake and reduce exclusion errors in the implementation of welfare programs targeted at vulnerable populations.
Intervention
The intervention that we have designed targets construction workers in the state of Odisha, India. The Odisha Buildings & Other Construction Workers Welfare (OB & OCWW) Board issues “labor cards” to construction workers, which enable them to access several public welfare programs targeted specifically to them by occupation. In the status quo, workers face significant barriers to enrolling in these cards, including transaction costs and information constraints with respect to the processes involved. As a result, while awareness of these cards is high, enrollment rates are low. In this proposed project, we want to implement two interventions, designed to tackle both the transaction costs and information constraints.
The first intervention involves top down enrollment, where the focus is on reducing the transaction costs of applying for labor cards. As part of this intervention, government officials will conduct an on site registration drive to enrol workers for the cards. This will remove the travel costs, the opportunity cost of the workers’ time and any side payments that workers would have had to make to formal or informal intermediaries. The second intervention removes the information barriers faced by the applicant. We will share a flyer containing specific information about the application process, with directions for the workers that can be acted upon for them to independently enrol.
We will conduct two rounds of surveys with workers. First, we will conduct an in-person baseline with these workers prior to allocating them to one of the two interventions or a control arm. The intervention will be conducted approximately one week following the baseline. The second round will be an endline phone survey conducted 1 month after the baseline, and 2-3 weeks after the intervention. Lastly, we will also get administrative data on labor card registrations and access to benefits from the Labor Department.
Experimental design
Our intervention will be implemented at the level of worksites, which we have sampled based on a near-census of some neighborhood clusters in Bhubaneshwar and Cuttack, Odisha. Each worksite employs 2-10 workers on an active construction project. Worksites, and all their workers, will be sorted into one of three treatment arms. In the first arm, worksites are assigned to a top-down intervention where last-mile government agents visit the worksite and assist workers with in-person registrations. In the second arm, worksites are assigned to an intervention alleviating workers’ information constraints with respect to the enrollment process. In this arm, we will provide workers with information on where they can enroll in labor cards, without assisting with the actual registration process. The third arm will include control worksites, where we will deliver no intervention.
The randomization of worksites into treatment groups will be stratified at the level of the combination of neighborhood, number of workers, and the expected duration of the worksite. The neighborhood of the worksite will be approximated by drawing fixed gridlines around our study locations. For our surveys, we will attempt to cover the universe of all workers at each sampled worksite.
While we randomize worksites based on our census, it is possible that during our baseline some of these worksites no longer exist because the work was already completed. In these cases the enumerator will contact the corresponding contractor and include a different worksite they are working in then as a replacement. The replaced worksite will have the same treatment status as the original worksite. The enumerator will not be aware of the treatment status of the worksite while picking a replacement.
We anticipate some amount of churn in the workers working in the worksite between baseline and the intervention. In this case the workers benefitting from the intervention would be different from the workers enrolled in the experiment at baseline. Our main analysis will only include the workers enrolled at baseline. In exploratory analysis we will also analyse the impact considering the sample of workers at the intervention worksites to be those present on the day of the intervention (instead of those present during the baseline).
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.