(Follow Up) Can a Shared National Identity Trump Ethnic Identity? Evidence from a Field Experiment in Singapore (with RCT ID AEARCTR-0007559)

How to cite

RIAMBAU, Guillem; Toha, Risa. 2024. "(Follow Up) Can a Shared National Identity Trump Ethnic Identity? Evidence from a Field Experiment in Singapore (with RCT ID AEARCTR-0007559)." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013154. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13154-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Guillem RIAMBAU* , Risa Toha

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013154
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13154-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-03-20 – 2024-08-31
Countries
Singapore (South East Asia)
JEL codes
D91; J15.
Secondary IDs
AEARCTR-0007559
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13154

Abstract

(This PAP is for a follow up study on the previously conducted experiment pre-registered as AEARCTR-0007559)

Based on our early analysis of the data we have collected, we note that there are a few plausible reasons why we find the patterns we observe in the data. First, different groups of people exhibit altruism towards co-ethnics, while others exhibit more altruism towards non-coethnics. The precise mechanism/reason this diverging patterns across different groups, however, remains unclear. Second, our earlier survey instruments do not provide us with a sufficiently direct measure of Singaporeans’ attitudes/views about their groups. To test the specific mechanisms behind the patterns we examine in our previously collected data, we aim to collect new data and test additional hypotheses. Therefore, we run a new online survey of Singapore residents (adult Singapore citizens and Permanent Residents) with 1,300 participants.

In particular, we aim to examine whether (a) People are more likely to exhibit altruism towards those they think deserve their help; (b) examine whether people are more likely to exhibit altruism to their co-ethnics by means of a survey experiment with donations.

We are also interested in understanding how Singaporeans view their government and representatives, and how this may be correlated with other attitudes.

Intervention

The new intervention will be an online survey on 1,300 participants, adults residing in Singapore. The survey will ask a bunch of attitudinal and socioeconomic questions. Beyond that, we will carry out a conjoint experiment, a supermarket voucher experiment, and a donations experiment. All details in the box below.

The individual characteristics we will collect are are ethnicity, marital status, language spoken at home, monthly income, occupation, place of birth, legal status (born Singaporean/became Singaporean/permanent resident), year start residing in Singapore, apartment size, apartment tenure, number of people living in the apartment, education, religion, religiosity, strength of ethnic and national identification, views on national identity, views on inter-ethnic relations, perceptions on ethnic stereotypes (heard of them or not & agreeable or not), experience of ethnic discrimination, experience of stereotyping, political interest, political preferences, sources for political information, level of degree of satisfaction with different public services (public schools, government hospitals, access to electricity, access to water/sanitation, overall safety and security), views on what the state should do to provide for the needy,

Experimental design

There will be three experiments:

1. Conjoint experiment: The primary goal is to allow us to tease out whether people are more likely to exhibit altruism towards those they think deserve their help.

2. Donations experiment: To examine whether people are more likely to exhibit altruism to their co-ethnics, we will ask participants to choose a local NGO to make a $10 donation to. We will randomly select 100 participants and make (with our funds) the donations according to their preferences. Participants will be reminded adequately that all donations will be made, that this is not a hypothetical scenario but a real one. The goal of this question is to examine whether on average participants prefer to donate to coethnic organizations, or organizations that cut across ethnic lines (like, for example, support for the disabled or the arts). The exact wording of this question in the questionnaire is given below.

3. Supermarket voucher experiment: The primary goal of this is to examine whether residents are more likely to disregard free vouchers from a particular supermarket than from other ones.

Design details

Randomization method
All randomizations will be done algorithmically by the survey company provider: Qualtrics.
Randomization unit
Only one level of randomization for both interventions: Individual
Clusters
1,300 individuals
Observations
1,300 individuals
Arms
For conjoint experiment, all randomizations will be given equal probability. For the donations experiment, all individuals whose choices are effectively donated will be selected with equal probability (although this will be done ex post, so it should not alter the results in any way). For the voucher experiment, all participants will be randomly allocated with equal probabilities (one third) to each of the groups: Sheng Siong, NTUC, Fair Price
Primary outcomes
See all details below. For intervention 1: Characteristics of recipient associated to higher levels of altruism. These are five characteristics: ethnicity, household size, socioeconomic status, occupation status, nationality. For intervention 2: Rates of donations to the different NGOs For intervention 3: Rates of keeping the voucher for the different supermarkets.
Secondary outcomes
All details provided in the word document attached under "analysis plan"

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords