Testing framing approaches for delivery of information about the impact of wood burning on air quality in Sandwell, UK
How to cite
Akesson, Jesper; Chappell, Hannah. 2024. "Testing framing approaches for delivery of information about the impact of wood burning on air quality in Sandwell, UK." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013153. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13153-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study focuses on testing approaches of framing information about the impact of indoor wood burning on air quality as well as information about the Smoke Control Area in Sandwell. As of 2024, the borough of Sandwell is now designated as a Smoke Control Area, which imposes restrictions on the type of fuels that can be burned and on types of domestic combustion appliances. The aims of this trial are to: 1) evaluate individuals' baseline knowledge of air quality, the impact of log burning on air quality, and the Smoke Control Area, and 2) assess the impact of delivering information on these topics through health-focused framing and compliance-focused framing.
Intervention
The interventions will be delivered in a survey experiment. Intervention 1 consists of presenting information about log burning and its impact on air quality through the context of health impacts. Intervention 2 consist of presenting information about log burning and its impact on air quality through the context of compliance with the Sandwell Smoke Control Area.
Experimental design
This trial relies on a survey experiment to evaluate the impact of the aforementioned interventions. The survey structure will be as follows: after seeing the survey introduction and consenting to the survey, participants will be asked a series of questions about their housing situation (e.g., do they live in a canal boat or in a house/flat), whether or not they are currently in possession of a log burner or open fireplace, and, if so, why they use this combustion device (e.g., as a primary or secondary heat source, for aesthetic reasons).
After completing the background questions, participants will be randomly allocated to the control condition (50%) to the treatment condition (50%). Those allocated to the treatment condition will then again be randomised to receive either Intervention 1 (health-framing) or Intervention 2 (Compliance framing). Participants in the treatment conditions are then presented with the intervention, which consists of information about log burning and its impact on air quality, recommendations for alternative fuel sources, and either a) information about the negative health consequences of wood burning on health or b) information about the legal repercussions for failing to comply with the Smoke Control Area.
All participants then are asked to complete a series of knowledge questions about log burning, air quality, and the Smoke Control Area (individuals allocated to the Control Condition proceed directly from the Background questions to this survey block).
Participants are then asked whether they would be willing to make a pledge to comply to the Smoke Control Area. Those who indicate that they are willing to make this commitment are provided with a commitment certificate.
Participants will be sent a follow up survey four weeks following the first survey. This second survey will repeat the knowledge questions asked in the first survey as well as questions that elicit self-report behaviours relating to air quality and wood burning.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.