Digital Credit and Borrowers’ Welfare in Ethiopia: A Pilot Random Control Trial Study

How to cite

Fetene, Gebeyehu Manie; Woldekidan, Hana; Tilahun, Solomon M.; Boka, Jonse; Belay, Dagim; Hailemikael, Tewelde G.. 2024. "Digital Credit and Borrowers’ Welfare in Ethiopia: A Pilot Random Control Trial Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013130. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13130-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Gebeyehu Manie Fetene* , Hana Woldekidan , Solomon M. Tilahun , Jonse Boka , Dagim Belay , Tewelde G. Hailemikael

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013130
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13130-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-03-15 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
E42, D14, I38, L25, O16
Secondary IDs
00011347
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13130

Abstract

In a unique experimental setting in digital credit for micro and small enterprises (MSEs), we will randomize eligible digital credit applicants into treatment and control groups (stratified by gender), where the former will receive digital credit while the control group will not get digital credit for at least four months. In addition, previous studies have also documented that MSEs face multiple constraints, including limited financial knowledge and skills, and addressing only a single credit constraint may not be enough to improve their performance. Therefore, we introduce a second treatment where we combine financial literacy training with digital credit access to explore whether providing financial literacy training could amplify the impacts of digital credit. We will investigate the impacts of digital credit on the welfare of borrowers. To guide the design of our interventions, we will leverage administrative data on existing borrowers of digital credit. The findings are expected to provide insight into policy formulation, product development and modification, customer protection, and default reduction mechanisms in Ethiopia, where digital credit is a new phenomenon, and beyond.

Experimental design

Sample draws from digital credit applicants who are eligible for credit and who are in the waiting list will be randomly assigned into treatment and control groups. The first treatment group will receive digital credit; the second treatment group will receive digital credit plus financial literacy training; while the control group will not receive any treatment for at least four months. The randomization unit will be at individual MSE level. The main potential identification challenge will be compliance problem from both the treatment and control groups. Analysis of administrative data from our partner bank show that, on average, 9% of the customers rejected the digital credit after being offered in the last 16 months of COOP’s digital service provision period, where the percentage of customers who rejected the credits remained fairly the same across time. Similarly, the control group whose application will be rejected may apply for credit somewhere else. These non-compliant customers may systematically differ with the customers who comply, causing potential bias. In this case, we propose three approaches. The first approach is to estimate intent-to-treat. The second approach is to consider the time period that the customers actually receive the credit as treatment indicator, particularly if the non-compliance rate will be very high. The third approach is to use propensity score matching technique and evaluate the impact only on customers who comply, for that we increased the sample size by about 20% as discussed below.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be done in office by a computer. Eligible SMEs will be divided in to three groups by generating a random number (Bernoulli distribution) corresponding to the list of SMEs.
Randomization unit
The randomization unit will be individual SMEs.
Clusters
1,980 small and medium sized formal business enterprises
Observations
1,980 small and medium sized formal business enterprises
Arms
The sample size will be equally divided in to two treatment arms and a control group, each treatment arm having 660 sample size. That is, 660 SMEs will receive digital credit, 660 will receive digital credit and training about financial literacy and the remaining 660 SMEs will not receive digital credit and finincial literacy training. We will stratify the sample by gender: 31% female and 65% male, implying a random sample of 614 female and 1366 males. The gender distribution of the sample is based on information from previous digital credit applicants administrative data.
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome variable is profitability of the digitl credit.
Secondary outcomes
Employment and household consumption.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords