Information Nudge on Social vs. Private Benefit, and Impact on Adaptation

How to cite

Shu, Yunyu; Zhang, Jiayue; Li, Ming; Xiang, Jia. 2024. "Information Nudge on Social vs. Private Benefit, and Impact on Adaptation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013129. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13129-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yunyu Shu* , Jiayue Zhang , Ming Li , Jia Xiang

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013129
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13129-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-01-29 – 2025-06-15
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13129

Abstract

This study concerns the influence of information provision in boosting climate change adaptation behaviors. Specifically, we conduct a lab-in-the-field experiment among cocoa farmers in Ghana to compare the impact of different types and combinations of information regarding the benefits of shade trees on farmers’ shade management adoption decisions. We compare farmers’ responses to information on private benefits of shade trees with those to information emphasizing the social benefits; we explore whether providing social benefits in addition to private benefits can help or hurt tree planting based on farmers’ degree of altruism, intention of social signaling and free-riding incentives; we also ask whether providing private benefits on top of social benefits is valuable; lastly, we test whether cocoa farmers are more responsive when information includes both positive and downside aspects of growing shade trees, as opposed to cases where only the benefits of tree planting are highlighted. Our primary outcomes are farmers’ choice of the number of shade trees to grow on hypothetical lands in the game and sign-up decisions for free tree seedlings in the real Green Ghana Program.

Intervention

We conduct a lab-in-the-field experiment with hypothetical cocoa farming conditions. Farmers in the same treatment group and community are invited to participate in a lab session together. Each cocoa farmer will be invited to make tree-planting decisions in two games with initial token and harvest sales. Respondent compensation at the end of the lab depends on one of the two games’ remaining tokens, randomly selected.

The intervention is designed to investigate the impact of different types and combinations of information regarding the benefits of shade trees on farmers’ shade management adoption decisions. Farmers in each treatment group will receive different information delivered right before each game, in the form of pre-recorded videos. There are 5 treatment arms in total:

Control: Only information about climate change risks is offered. No additional information.

T1a: Additional information about the private benefit of shade trees and additional information about downside risks of too many shade trees before game 1; then information about the social benefit of shade trees before game 2.

T1b: Additional information about the private benefit of shade trees before game 1; then information about the social benefit of shade trees before game 2.

T2a: Additional information about the social benefit of shade trees before game 1; then information about the private benefit of shade trees and additional information about downside risks of too many shade trees before land game 2.

T2b: Additional information about the social benefit of shade trees before game 1; then information about the private benefit of shade trees and additional information before game 2.

In each community, We will hold 3 lab sessions (i.e., Control, T1, T2) with 10-16 participants each. We pool participants from T1a and T1b in the same lab session (T1) and those from T2a and T2b in the same lab session (T2). Participants will wear earphones when watching relevant information videos.

Experimental design

A baseline survey was conducted from end-Janurary to February 2024, right after the cocoa main harvest season. The interventions (described in the Intervention section) using a lab-in-the-field design will be rolled out in March - April 2024. A follow-up survey is planned. We will track attrition along the process and use Lee bounds if attrition is imbalanced across treatment groups.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer software and simple lotteries
Randomization unit
At the farmer level. We stratify our randomization by community, farmer age, education, and land size. There are 155 strata, as 5 cells are empty.
Clusters
788 farmers.
Observations
2 observations per farmer, 1576 observations at the land level in total
Arms
T1a: private +downside first, then social: 130 farmers T1b: private first, then social: 131 farmers T2a: social first, then private+downside: 139 farmers T2b: social first, then private: 127 farmers Control: 261 farmers
Primary outcomes
• number of shade trees (forest and fruit) planted in each of the two games • number of free shade tree seedlings signed up for in Green Ghana Program • belief in shade tree benefit on cocoa farms
Secondary outcomes
We are also interested in potential mechanisms driving farmers’ decisions in the game, such as • number of shade trees suggested to plant on a peer farmer’s land • belief in shade tree externality on peer farmer’s land

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords