Sticky Stereotypes: Inaccurate Beliefs and Observability
How to cite
Opoku-Agyeman, Anna; Rackstraw, Emma. 2024. "Sticky Stereotypes: Inaccurate Beliefs and Observability." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013111. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13111-1.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Our study explores the impact of a supervisor’s racial identity on how hiring managers utilize new information about racial groups to revise their beliefs regarding worker productivity. This proposed intervention is grounded in literature indicating that the identity of supervisors can influence employees’ behavior and alter their perception of their supervisor’s priorities (Jeanquart-Barone 1996; Roberts 2005; Bradley et al. 2018). Additionally, we examine whether sharing a supervisor’s racial identity shifts how hiring managers express their racial attitudes. To determine whether non-Bayesian updating among hiring managers depends on the supervisor’s racial identity, we will conduct an experiment using the Prolific survey platform. In this experiment, we will randomly present a photo of one of the supervising researchers of this study, along with a prompt. In doing so, we will leverage the racial diversity of the two researchers to assess whether belief updating about racial gaps in worker productivity and explicit racial attitudes change conditional on which researcher is shown.
Intervention
Hiring managers will be randomly assigned to see information about the race/ethnicity of the PI supervising their task.
Experimental design
Our experiment seeks to understand how hiring managers behave when the race of their supervisor is made known to them. We measure how the salience of a supervisor's racial identity impacts the belief-updating process and explicit racial attitudes of hiring managers. We first ask participants on Prolific participating in a hiring task to complete a hiring task on Prolific based on information gathered from 250 Amazon Mechanical Turk workers. Each participant, as part of the experiment, is a hiring manager that then is randomly assigned 8 worker resumes, constructed from demographic data collected about the pool of workers during the task they completed. After the first four resumes are reviewed, the “hiring managers” are told there is a supervisor of the study and are either shown the Black supervising researcher, White supervising research, or a prompt that says there is a supervising researcher. Then they are shown new accurate information about the demographic productivity differences within the broader worker pool, and are asked to review the remaining resumes and provide their thoughts on wage strategy, resume features, and racial attitudes.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.