Learning is in the Air: Clean Air as an Experience Good

How to cite

Sun, Yixin; Sorin, Jeanne; Budy. 2024. "Learning is in the Air: Clean Air as an Experience Good." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013110. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13110-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yixin Sun* , Jeanne Sorin , Budy

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013110
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13110-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-04-01 – 2024-11-18
Countries
Indonesia ()
JEL codes
D12; I15; O12; O13; Q53
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13110

Abstract

Despite the enormous health costs of air pollution, willingness-to-pay (WTP) for clean air in highly polluted developing contexts remains very low. We posit that one significant and understudied reason is that clean air is an experience good, whose value is revealed after consumption. We employ a cluster-randomized trial to test this hypothesis. We seek to document the existence of an ``experience wedge", i.e. a difference between anticipated and realized utility of consuming a good. To do this, we deploy a novel experienced-based intervention, air quality monitors and purifiers, which may provide a more salient treatment than traditional information mediums, such as pamphlets or videos. To explore the mechanisms behind the experience wedge, we implement a purifier-only treatment arm to experimentally distinguish between (1) knowledge about objective pollution exposure and (2) the sensory experience of breathing in polluted air. This will be the first experimental evidence demonstrating how experience can shift demand for clean air, offering insights for public health policy and environmental awareness campaigns, while also highlighting the implications for using WTP estimates in economic evaluations.

Intervention

We will provide (1) air quality monitor and purifier and (2) purifier-only to two treatment groups. Our control group will receive a fan that looks identical to a purifier.

Experimental design

We randomly sort participant households into three groups: a control group, a comprehensive experience treatment, and a sensory-based treatment. Our main treatment is the comprehensive experience treatment, where households receive an air purifier and air quality monitor for three months. This treatment targets two sources fueling the experience wedge: (1) \exposure wedge, or lack of knowledge on own objective exposure to pollution and (2) sensory wedge, lack of sensory experience with clean air and accompanying health and productivity benefits, leading to misperceptions of the marginal utility of clean indoor air.

Households in a secondary treatment receive only an air purifier but not the visible measurements provided by the monitor. This sensory-based treatment arm will dig into the mechanisms behind the experience wedge, with the aim of experimentally differentiating between the exposure wedge and the sensory wedge

Design details

Randomization method
Our sample will be parents of elementary school children. Our cluster-randomization will be at the school-level. We stratify randomization on the baseline average monthly expenditure and pollution of the area that the school is in. Randomization will be done by our research partner, SMERU, by a computer, before baseline.
Randomization unit
Our cluster-randomization will be at the school-level.
Clusters
180 schools
Observations
950 households
Arms
60 schools for control and the two treatments.
Primary outcomes
Indoor PM2.5 levels. Demand for clean air, measured by (1) WTP for an air purifier rental, (2) pollution avoidance behavior index, (3) time spent indoors in purifier space, (4) demand for public action on clean air. Beliefs: accuracy of perceived indoor and outdoor air pollution levels; beliefs about impact of air pollution on own and child's health; perceived effectiveness of air purifiers; Health: biometrics (blood pressure and blood oxygen), self-reported measures of physical health, cognitive ability, sleep quality, and mental health.
Secondary outcomes
Knowledge index

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords