Two-sided Subsidies to Support Biofortified Crop Adoption in Guatemala

How to cite

Rudder, Jess; Macours, Karen; Mallia, Paola. 2024. "Two-sided Subsidies to Support Biofortified Crop Adoption in Guatemala." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013101. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13101-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jess Rudder* , Karen Macours , Paola Mallia

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013101
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13101-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-02-26 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Guatemala ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13101

Abstract

As new climate-smart farming technologies become available, it will be necessary to learn which market mechanisms are effective at increasing access for rural farmers. If higher quality seeds are under-adopted due to information, behavioral, and/or financial frictions, it justifies subsidizing their distribution. This research considers two ways to subsidize seed dissemination - using demand-side subsidies to encourage farmers to try improved seeds and supply-side subsidies for agrodealers to promote and stock improved seeds. Subsidizing agrodealers is a potentially appealing and scalable policy option because they face market incentives. We study the effect of subsidizing both sides of the market to learn how subsidies affect uptake among inexperienced and experienced hybrid seed farmers.

Intervention

Our partner organization works with a network of agricultural input sellers to sell climate-resilient, biofortified seeds. Expanding the biofortified agrodealer network provides an opportunity to study how to structure seed subsidies so that they are willing to stock and promote climate-resilient, biofortified seeds. Most agrodealers are small businesses with few employees. It can be risky for them to stock new seed varieties when they are not familiar with how seeds perform in their local market. In Guatemala, many farmers grow landrace varieties of maize. However, even among landrace growers, it is common to purchase fertilizer and/or herbicides each year. Agrodealers provide a touchpoint to expand adoption on the intensive margin (farmers who switch hybrid varieties) and extensive margin (increasing first-time hybrid adoption).

We will implement a listing procedure to identify 3-4 communities near agrodealers, targeting communities with growers who typically plant non-hybrid varieties. We will randomly assign communities to one of three treatment arms, 1. listing only (control), 2. seed information session, 3. information session plus coupon distribution. The information session will be led by our partner organization and will train farmers on hybrid seed planting and describe the nutrition benefits of biofortified varieties. The information session plus coupon group will receive a coupon with random discount levels to encourage adoption. To incentivize input sellers to promote biofortified seeds to new farmers, we will randomly offer half of the agrodealers a subsidy for each client that buys biofortified seed.

Experimental design

For the 2024 pilot, we start with a list of 70 agrodealers with ties to our partner organization. We select a subset of agrodealers that meet the following criteria: only one establishment per owner, primarily sells to end consumers, balanced across regions. From a final list of 14, we randomly assign 7 to control, and 7 to the treatment group who receive an extra subsidy for sales of biofortified seeds. We run a listing procedure to identify 4 communities per agrodealer that meet the following criteria: primarily agricultural communities, presence of farmers that grow non-hybrid seeds, willing to participate, and reasonable distance to agrodealer location. We randomly assign 1/3 of communities to each treatment arm (control, information session, and information session plus coupon distribution). Community leaders help invite 20 farmers per community. Farmers located in communities drawn for coupon distribution will receive a scrach-off coupon that will reveal a discount level that varies between 26-77%.

Design details

Randomization method
Agrodealers and community assignment - in an office by computer. Farmer coupons randomization will be scratch-off coupons distributed publicly.
Randomization unit
Two levels of clusters - agrodealers and villages and one level of individual randomization (farmer-level for communities selected for coupon distribution).
Clusters
pilot: 14 agrodealers, 42 communities.
Observations
840 farmers.
Arms
7 agrodealers control, 7 agrodealers bonus incentive, 14 communities (280 farmers) control, 14 communities (280 farmers) information session, and 14 communities information plus coupons (280 farmers).
Primary outcomes
Farmers: coupon redemption (take-up), adoption of biofortified seeds, complementary input use, agricultural productivity (yields, profits), consumption of bio-fortified maize. Agrodealers: biofortified seed sales (number of farmers, total volume)
Secondary outcomes
Sources of heterogeneity: Farmer type (hybrid grower, non-hybrid grower), socio-economic strata, indigenous versus non-indigenous; farmers with small children and pregnant mothers, past climate related losses (wind and/or drought), willingness-to-pay

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords