Understanding discrimination on Facebook Marketplace: A field experiment
How to cite
Jensen, Nicholas. 2024. "Understanding discrimination on Facebook Marketplace: A field experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013094. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13094-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Facebook Marketplace was created in 2016 to compete with Craigslist in the market for in-person sales of used goods. Within two years, Facebook Marketplace had over 800 million active users worldwide. One of the main advantages of Marketplace over Craigslist is that buyers can attempt to infer product quality and safety of in-person meetings from sellers' Facebook profiles. Pictures, gender, age, race, marriage status, among others can be seen or inferred from the profile of sellers. This information can be used when deciding to buy and negotiate for a product. This research examines the extent, and potential causes, of discrimination on Marketplace via a field experiment. We build fictitious Facebook profiles that are identical except for race, gender, or age. We then make offers for a set of commonly sold products through these profiles and compare the effect of both sellers' and buyers' demographic characteristics on the number and size of offers.
Experimental design
We collect data on the responses of sellers to prospective buyers' profiles, to measure differences in sellers' responses based on race, sex, and education, among other demographic characteristics. For each profile we create, we assign an identifiable race, sex, and age in their profile photos, along with information on their education level.
We collect data on the responses of sellers to prospective buyers' profiles, in order to measure differences in sellers' responses based on race, sex and education, among other demographic characteristics. For each profile we create, we assign an identifiable race, sex, and age in their profile photos, along with information on their education level. Each profile's inquiry is systematically varied and matched with another profile whose race is different. We vary race across two main categories - white and black - across the categories of buyer profiles. Similarly, we vary their sex between male and female profiles, and education varies between college and no college education across profiles. For each marketplace ad each buyer profile responds to, we plan to collect and report available data on:
1) the type of product
2) product's listed price
3) seller's listed location (individuals' information is not publicly shared)
4) item's condition
5) willingness to haggle for a lower price
6) whether the seller responded to the initial inquiry about the Facebook marketplace advertisement
7) the gender, age category, and perceived race of the seller
8) the type of exchange arrangement listed in the sellers' listing. For instance, whether the item is pickup only, dropoff only, shipping only, et cetera.
9) Whether sellers responded within 24 hours to the message.
10) The generated names of the generated profiles used for the experiment.
11) The age of the advertisement, by category listed on Facebook Marketplace. These include the options of below 24 hours, or the number of days if less than seven. We do not collect observations that were older than a week at the time of first inquiry.
We plan to use some of the additional information provided in our regression analysis to control for both individual sellers' characteristics and the characteristics of the advertisement. Our ability to implement these controls partially depends on the completeness of buyers' information, information on the listing itself, the location of the product listing, and the type of product in question. Consequently, the sample size for some regression forms included in our primary outcomes may be smaller when some of these model specifications have covariates with missing values.
Name Choice Methodology information:
For first names, we used the 13 most popular boys and girls names given to babies in the 1990s (as reported by the Social Security Administration), after excluding any names (e.g., Emily) that appear in the list from Gaddis (2017) of distinctively Black or White names commonly used in audit studies.
For last names, we used the top 26 last names from the 2000 Census (from Crabtree et al. (2023) and posted on GitHub here), after excluding any names (e.g., Hernandez and Lee) that were more than 10% Hispanic/Latino, 10% Asian/Pacific Islander, or 10% American Indian/Native Alaskan. I also decided to exclude the last name “White” to prevent mixed signals from names.
[ Reference information for above:
Crabtree, C., Kim, J. Y., Gaddis, S. M., Holbein, J. B., Guage, C., & Marx, W. W. (2023). Validated names for experimental studies on race and ethnicity. Scientific Data, 10(1), 130.
Gaddis, S. M. (2017). How black are Lakisha and Jamal? Racial perceptions from names used in correspondence audit studies. Sociological Science, 4, 469-489.]
The full information on the names used for the study will be provided in a subsequent document. In addition, the random names for buyers we chose will be provided in the final version of the experiment's results.
Education Methodology:
In constructing our education variable, we create a list of names of universities that approximate the 'average' public university education. For school choice for postsecondary education, we exclude schools associated with religious or Ivy League affiliations, and limit our choice of public universities and colleges to those near the median in terms of tuition and national rankings. A full description of the school name sample selection process will be available upon request in supplemental files upon completion of the experiment. We derive our initial selection of university names from the U.S. News & World Report's 2017 National Universities Rankings, a comprehensive dataset of over 1,800 schools across the United States, which provides data on admissions criteria, cost of tuition and fees, enrollment numbers, and overall rankings.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.