Job referrals for minority workers: Impacts on a manufacturing firm in India
How to cite
Srivastava, Kartik. 2024. "Job referrals for minority workers: Impacts on a manufacturing firm in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013091. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13091-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Most manufacturing firms in the developing world rely on informally sourced referrals to recruit workers for entry-level jobs. Given homophilous networks, this practice may undermine diversity, and may contribute to occupational segregation. Does seeding more referrals amongst under-represented workers improve diversity, firm productivity, social cohesion within teams and worker retention? I study this in the context of India, where job search networks are concentrated by caste. I partner with a large manufacturing firm to experimentally vary their referral allocation process. In treatment teams, referrals are seeded disproportionately among incumbent lower caste workers. The study will focus on productivity, labor turnover, social cohesion and bargaining power as the key outcomes of interest.
Intervention
This study focuses on referral-based hiring at a manufacturing firm in India. The intervention disproportionately diverts referral opportunities to underrepresented incumbent workers belonging to lower caste groups, relative to a control group where referral opportunities are given to randomly picked workers, regardless of their caste. This intervention is conducted at the level of production teams inside the firm. A lab-in-field experiment is implemented as an extension, to test how this referral-based hiring policy compares with other commonly used hiring programs designed to improve diversity in teams.
Experimental design
The experiment involves randomizing teams at a manufacturing firm in India into one of two groups. In status quo, workers at this firm are primarily hired through referrals that are allocated to incumbent workers by team leaders based on their discretion. As part of this experiment, teams in the treatment group will have referral opportunities be given randomly within the set of lower caste incumbent workers, while teams in the control group will have referral opportunities be given to a randomly selected worker regardless of their caste. These teams are organized by task type within lines and shifts, and treatment status will be stratified by task type, team size, and baseline share of lower caste workers.
Edit: following the endline with the firm's workers, I conducted a lab-in-field experiment, wherein teams of workers were asked to work on a group task involving cutting strips of fabric that were then tied together to produce ropes. Each team had one lower caste and two upper caste workers. After one round of the task, the teams were allocated into three different groups that determined how the teams grew from three to four members. In the first group, mimicking the intervention in the firm, the fourth member was a referral of the incumbent lower caste worker on the team. In the second group, the fourth member was a referral of a randomly selected incumbent upper caste member of the team. In the third group, the fourth member was not a referral of any of the incumbent workers. This group was informed that the fourth worker is being added to balance the team by caste. Following this, the workers performed the same task in another session. At the end of the second session, the workers complete an endline survey and play a symbol matching game, designed to assess their coordination with each other.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.