Is no news good news? Corruption enforcement and corruption perceptions in Ukraine
How to cite
Lehne, Jonathan; Fedyk, Yuri; Gorodnichenko, Yuriy; Sologoub, Ilona; Spagnolo, Giancarlo. 2024. "Is no news good news? Corruption enforcement and corruption perceptions in Ukraine." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013089. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13089-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study evaluates how individuals update their perceptions of corruption in response to new information about corruption enforcement. Theoretically, information about judicial investigations or convictions may simultaneously provide a negative signal about the extent of corruption and a positive signal about the level of enforcement. Our survey experiment is designed to measure these two effects and the net effect on corruption perceptions. It consists of an online survey of 7000 respondents in Ukraine, in which randomly selected sub-samples are exposed to information about corruption cases.
Intervention
Corruption is – like most illegal transactions – hard to observe and quantify systematically. Given that the ‘true’ level of corruption is unobservable, corruption perceptions are widely used as a substitute in research and policy discussions. Perceptions have been shown to be biased measures of corruption (Olken 2009, Gutmann et al. 2020) but they matter in their own right. Domestic corruption perceptions may sway the outcome of elections while international corruption perceptions may, in the case of Ukraine, affect willingness to supply aid, foreign direct investment, reconstruction funding and the prospects of EU accession.
Over the past decade, Ukraine has implemented a range of reforms intended to combat corruption, including the creation of new, independent agencies tasked with anti-corruption enforcement. One consequence of their activities has been a steady stream of news about the discovery and investigation of corruption cases. The publication of news about prosecutions and convictions is an important component of law enforcement because it is a prerequisite for deterrence. News about corruption cases may, however, also affect corruption perceptions. Individuals who learn about a new corruption case may focus on the details of the crime and their perception of corruption in the country may worsen. Others may focus on the fact that it has been detected and is being prosecuted, causing their perceptions to improve. Our study aims to evaluate these responses empirically and in particular, to measure the net effect of news about enforcement on corruption perceptions.
Information about corruption cases can be delivered in different forms. Individuals may be most frequently exposed to news stories about a single corruption case. Such news reports may have a different effect from aggregate statistical information about the total number of prosecutions or convictions. For example, news stories about individual cases may encourage a focus on the crime while statistical information may be viewed through the lens of enforcement. Our study includes treatment arms that provide both kinds of information in order to evaluate whether the nature of the news affects the response.
Experimental design
Our survey will have a sample of approximately 7000 respondents. It is conducted online, in Ukrainian, by the survey company Info Sapiens. The sample is drawn from a larger panel designed to be representative of the Ukrainian population as of early 2022. Respondents are divided randomly into 5 groups of 1400 respondents each. One of these groups is a control group. The other four groups will receive information about corruption prevalence, corruption enforcement, or both.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.