Using Religion to Influence Female Labor Force Participation in Pakistan

How to cite

Makino, Momoe; Umer, Hamza. 2024. "Using Religion to Influence Female Labor Force Participation in Pakistan." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013074. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13074-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Momoe Makino* , Hamza Umer

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013074
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13074-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2024-01-19 – 2026-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D83, D91, J16, J29, O53, Z12, Z13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13074

Abstract

Female labor force participation (FLFP) rate is very low in Middle Eastern and South Asian countries while it is considered crucial in poverty alleviation and women’s empowerment. These countries are characterized by Islam and the strong patriarchal social norm against women’s working outside the home. Despite the general public image that Islam restricts women’s behavior, the association between Islam and low FLFP rate shown by the macro-level data provides divergent conclusions. The micro-level empirical studies concerning the impact of religion in general and Islam in specific, on preventing FLFP are scarce despite the apparent close relationship between the religious and social norms. We empirically investigate whether religious information, both positive and negative one, about FLFP affects FLFP by conducting the light-touch randomized controlled trial in Pakistan. Pakistan is one of the lowest FLFP rate countries, and has the second largest Muslim population as 96% of the population are Muslim. We aim to obtain an important policy implication to enhance FLFP in these countries.

Intervention

The intervention aims at exogenously influencing the fathers’ (or any male decision-maker of the household) religiosity. The intervention is simple, providing religious information concerning positive attitude toward FLFP to arm1, that concerning potentially negative attitude toward FLFP to arm2, and no information to arm3. The religious information provided will follow the consultation by the religious scholar.

Experimental design

1. Conduct the baseline survey to the eligible household. Eligibility requires that the household has at least one girl who should be unmarried, completed 14 years of education, and is not currently working for pay outside the home. The sampling is based on convenience sampling and details are provided below.

Baseline questionnaire consists of 6 sections: Section 1 (household roster), Section 2 (income), Section 3 (assets), Section 4 (attitudes toward FLFP and gender), Section 5 (religiosity), Section 6 (questions to daughters). Sections 1 to 5 should be responded by male household members (fathers or any male decision makers such as elder brother, uncle, or grandfather) who has a decision-making power. Section 6 is the questionnaire to eligible daughters.

Conduct the baseline questions up to the section 5 to the male household member, followed by the section 6 to the daughter.

2. Randomization of treatment assignment
33% probability for each treatment arm.

3. Detach the intervention and follow-up questions from the baseline survey, and conduct the intervention and follow-up questions independently from the baseline survey.

4. Proceed the donation game (the instruction will be given in the protocol).

5. Right after the donation game, conduct the follow-up survey to the male respondent.

6. (Around 6 months after the intervention) Conduct the endline survey which includes the same questions in the baseline survey Section 2 (income), Section 4 (attitudes toward FLFP and gender), Section 5 (religiosity), and Section 6 (questions to daughters)

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-based randomization across three arms.
Randomization unit
Household
Clusters
63 union councils in 4 tehsils: Lahore Cantt, Lahore City, Model Town, Shalimar Town
Observations
500 households. Eligible households are those with at least one unmarried daughter who completed 14 years of education and were not currently work full time.
Arms
167 households (1/3 of 500 households)
Primary outcomes
We have two data points, (i) right after the intervention (donation game response and follow-up survey response), (ii) endline survey (6 months after the intervention). We interpret that the "End Points" means (ii), however, for the sake of completeness, we describe key outcome variables at both (i) and (ii). Additionally, we will conduct the supplementary phone-based follow-up survey between October and December 2025. In the endline survey, we did not systematically collect information on current enrollment status for respondents aged above 16, although many of the girls appear to still be enrolled (see the attached structural questionnaire). We will also ask about the girls’ employment status one and a half years after the intervention. Please note that we expect a relatively high attrition rate, as this phone-based survey was not planned originally. Since it is uncertain whether quantitative analysis will be feasible based on this follow-up survey---and we may use the data primarily for qualitative analysis---we consider this survey to be supplementary. (i) Parental religious knowledge (survey response), Parental attitude toward FLFP (donation game outcome) (ii) Young women's participation in work outside the home
Secondary outcomes
Parental attitude toward FLFP (based on the subjective questions), Girls' empowerment, Girls' attitude toward FLFP

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords