Planning for Productive Migration

How to cite

Grossman, Allison; Christens, Darin; Grossman, Guy; Weinstein, Jeremy; Wolff, Jessica. 2024. "Planning for Productive Migration." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013065. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13065-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Allison Grossman* , Darin Christens , Guy Grossman , Jeremy Weinstein , Jessica Wolff

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013065
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13065-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-05-08 – 2025-05-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13065

Abstract

In many poor countries, youth in rural areas struggle to get jobs or start new businesses. Nevertheless, most economic development interventions prioritize “development in place,” rather than facilitating movement to places or sectors with greater opportunity. The Immigration Policy Lab at Stanford University, in collaboration with Mercy Corps, will evaluate an alternative approach, which helps young men living in rural and peri-urban Niger plan for migration to neighboring ECOWAS countries to find work. The Planning for Productive Migration (PPM) program informs young men about the opportunities and risks associated with migration to different destinations, facilitates conversations within families around migration, and provides a cash transfer to offset the costs of cross-border travel to stable ECOWAS countries. We benchmark this program against an unconditional cash transfer (UCT) and control condition.

Intervention

The PPM program facilitates safe, legal, and productive migration by relieving constraints that prevent young people from migrating to find higher paying work. These barriers include: lack of capital to finance the journey, missing legal documents that prevent exploitation, little experience planning and managing finances, opposition by family members concerned that migrants will not share benefits, and incomplete
information regarding the value and availability of economic opportunities in destinations. By relieving these constraints the project is intended to improve the economic, psychological, and social well-being of potential migrants and their families. The program is implemented by Mercy Corps (MC) and was designed in collaboration with faculty affiliates of the Immigration Policy Lab (IPL) at Stanford University.

The program’s theory of change is that we can increase the rates of and returns from migration through a set of complementary interventions: support considering opportunities and planning migration journeys, support accessing required travel documents and vaccinations, and facilitated household dialogues to help households collaboratively plan for migration. Upon completion of these activities, participants
receive a cash transfer calibrated to offset the costs of round-trip travel to popular locations within ECOWAS. By providing this support, the program should enable households to diversify their livelihoods through productive migration to desired locations and improve their economic and psycho-social wellbeing

Experimental design

The study’ includes ~3,000 households, which are drawn from 142 localities across 8 communes in Tahoua District, Niger.

We use a two-stage randomization. First, we randomize localities into Mercy Corps programming (MC) or pure control (PC). Treated locations receive programming, whereas pure control locations do not. The unit of randomization at this stage is the locality. This randomization is blocked on commune, with the probability of assignment to MC set to 60%. We sample ~30 households in localities assigned to MC and just 7 households in localities assigned to PC.

Second, within villages with Mercy Corps programing, we randomize households into three arms: PPM, UCT, and control (C). The unit of randomization at this second stage is the household. This randomization is blocked on village, and the probability of assignment to PPM is 0.36, and the probability of assignment to either UCT or C is 0.32

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization implemented in R.
Randomization unit
See response to experimental design.
Clusters
142
Observations
3000 households
Arms
The study’ includes ~3,000 households, which are drawn from 142 localities across 8 communes in Tahoua District, Niger. 89 clusters in program, 59 clusters in pure control.
Primary outcomes
We expect PPM to affect the outcomes described below. Outcomes are grouped by family and respondent type: prospective migrant (PM), household (HH), second household member (SHM), and woman household member (W). We conduct one-sided tests when we have strong priors about the direction of the treatment effects of PPM for an outcome. These outcomes are marked with a + sign, and we conduct two-sided tests for other outcomes. Greater detail about each outcome and index construction can be found in the attached PDF. Only the primary outcome families are listed here. Secondary outcome families can be found in the attached document. Primary outcomes grouped by family for the PM: *Manipulation Check* - Knowledge of regular migration + - Possession of travel documents + - Consultation with HH about migration + - Knowledge of soft skills + *Migration* - Intent to migrate+ - Preparation to migrate+ - Cross-border migration+ - Weeks spent abroad+ - ECOWAS migration+ - Domestic migration+ - Travel distance+ *Economic well-being* - Paid employment - Income - Savings - Consumption - Food insecurity - Economic precarity *Physical health and safety* - Absence of harassment and violence - Physical health *Mental health* - Emotional well-being - Stress: family - Stress: economic *Joint decisionmaking* - Consult with spouse - Consult with family on issues other than migration - Consult with family about migration+ *Attitudes and values* - Aspirations+ - Social liberalism: gender attitudes+ - Social liberalism: secularism + - Tolerance + - Cosmopolitanism + - Democracy+ Primary outcomes grouped by family: HoH *Economic wellbeing* - Agricultural income per capita (time:last season) - Livestock income per capita - Other income per capita - Business income per capita (time: last 3 months) - Remittance income: international - Remittance income: domestic - Savings per capita (net of debt) - Consumption per capita - Food insecurity: adults - Economic precarity (events) - Economic precarity (cost) *Investment* - Business investment (livestock purchase, business/land improvement) - Education (cost per child) - Education (number of children enrolled) - Assets (duable goods, livestock, home, land) Primary outcomes grouped by family: SHM *Physical health and safety* - Absence of harassment and violence - Physical health *Mental health* - Emotional well-being - Stress: family - Stress: economic *Joint decisionmaking* - Consult with spouse - Consult with family on issues other than migration - Consult with family about migration+
Secondary outcomes
Section 6.2 defines our secondary outcomes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords