Queuing Decisions

How to cite

Thami, Prakriti. 2024. "Queuing Decisions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0013064. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13064-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Prakriti Thami*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0013064
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.13064-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2024-03-11 – 2024-03-18
Countries
Sweden (Skane), United States of America ()
JEL codes
D47, D90
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/13064

Abstract

In queuing situations with prioritization based on self-reported need, the literature often turns to priority pricing as a method for aligning incentives properly. The approach for determining the optimal priority prices typically assumes that individuals will always lie if it will maximize their payoff. However, a recent meta-analysis of experiments on truth-telling reveals that people have an innate preference for being honest and for being seen as honest and, hence, tend to lie substantially less than expected. In light of the above, in this experiment I aim to test the behavioral responses to priority pricing and its effects on populations with differing underlying propensities for truth-telling.

Experimental design

Online Survey:

I will conduct an online survey using prolific to gather data on individual's decisions regarding the truthful disclosure of private information when queuing for an appointment under different conditions. Subjects will be randomly assigned to one of the four following groups:

1.) Control 1: No Fee - Honest Group
2.) Control 2: No Fee - Dishonest Group
3.) Treatment 1: Priority Fee - Honest Group
4.) Treatment 2: Priority Fee - Dishonest Group

The survey will consist of three sections, each requiring subjects to make two decisions. In each section, subjects will first learn about the setup of the interaction, the two possible types of individuals that they could be assigned as and the corresponding payoff for each type. Then, they will randomly be assigned a type and will have to choose whether to honestly disclose their assigned type. Subjects will be required to make a decision once as each type, with the order of type allocation being randomized. The specific instructions and questions presented to participants will differ according to the control or treatment groups to which they have been assigned. More specifically:

- In section 1, all subjects will be told that they will receive $1.50 for answering Type A and $0 for answering Type B. They will then be randomly assigned a type and asked what type they are. They will answer twice, once as each type.

- In section 2, all subjects are told that they will simulate a queuing scenario with another randomly selected participant on the survey in which they are both trying to get a doctors appointment . They will be told that there are two types:
--- Type N (Non-Urgent): with a low valuation for appointment. This type will receive $3 for first appointment and $1.50 for second (plus $7)
--- Type U (Urgent): with a high valuation for appointment. This type will receive $10 for the first appointment and $5 for the second
They are also told that the first appointment will be given to the 'urgent' case. If both cases are the same type, then the assignment is random. Further, the participants in the treatment groups are informed that if they answer that their case is 'urgent' they will have to pay a priority fee of $0.75. They will then be randomly assigned a type and asked whether they would like to tell the receptionist at the doctor's office that their case is 'urgent' or 'non-urgent'. They will answer once as each type.

- In section 3, all subjects will be presented with a modified scenario and asked to answer the questions from section 2 again. More specifically:
--- Subjects in Control 1 and Treatment 1 will be told that they have been randomly assigned to a group of 10 individuals and that the decisions they make in the section will give them extra payment only in the event that 9 out of the 10 subjects in their group had been truthful in their responses in Section 1.
--- Subjects in Control 2 and Treatment 2 will be told that they have been randomly assigned to a group of 10 individuals and that the decisions they make in the section will give them extra payment only in the event that 9 out of the 10 subjects in their group had not been truthful in their responses in Section 1.
The subjects will answer once as each type.

Queuing Game and Payment:

All subjects receive a fixed base payment of $2 for participating in the survey. Each subject will also receive additional payment for one of the first four decisions they make on the survey.

If one of the responses for section 1 get selected for compensation, the participants will receive $1.50 if they have answered Type A and $0 if they have answered Type B.

If one of the responses for section 2 get selected for compensation, subjects' payments are determined through a queuing game, where:
- Each subject is randomly paired with another subject from their assigned treatment or control group.
- The other subject's response as Type N is selected with 75% probability and Type U with 25% probability.
- If the subject has answered Type U while their partner has answered Type N, the subject is awarded the first appointment and the corresponding payment.
- Conversely, if the subject has answered Type N while their partner has answered Type U, the subject is awarded the second appointment and it's corresponding payment.
- If both participants have the same answer, the first appointment (and payment) is randomly assigned.

For section 3, subjects become eligible for additional payment only if they get assigned to a 10 subject group that meets specific eligibility criteria. Initially, participants will be randomly divided into groups of 10, each within their designated treatment or control group. The compensation rules from section 2 apply here as well. However, the key difference is that for this section, subjects will be paired exclusively with another subject from their own 10 subject group.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done by computer. Subjects are randomly allocated into the priority fee treatment group or the no fee control group at the end of section 1. Then at the end of section 2, the subjects in the no fee control groups are randomly allocated into either control group 1 or 2. Similarly, subjects in the priority fee treatment group are randomly allocated into either treatment group 1 or 2.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
700 subjects
Observations
700 subjects
Arms
The subjects will be divided equally across the four different groups (i.e. approximately 175 subjects in each treatment arm).
Primary outcomes
gamma_2, gamma_3
Secondary outcomes
gamma

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords