Correlation Neglect in Risky Choice
How to cite
Vitaku, Valon. 2024. "Correlation Neglect in Risky Choice." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012938. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12938-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study examines the effects of neglecting correlation in choice under risk. While alternative theories of choice under risk, such as regret aversion theory (Loomes and Sudgen, 1987) and salience theory (Bordalo, Gennaioli and Shleifer, 2012) suggest agents attend to the underlying correlation and derive utility from state contingencies, it remains an open question how people process these decisions. The repercussions of correlation neglect have paramount implications for the modern portfolio theory for risk-averse agents who seek to minimize variance for a given expected return (Markowitz, 1952). Relatedly, it may lead to missed hedging or arbitrage opportunities (Eyster and Weizsacker, 2016). How people process correlated risky choice in the evaluation of trade-offs between different options is largely endogenous though likely the decision process is influenced by the framing or presentation of lotteries. This experiment exogenously induces or suppresses subjects' focus towards the underlying correlation between lotteries through a dynamic display. The experiment will be augmented with eye-tracking measures to estimate the effects of decision heuristics on choices. While eye-tracking data are endogenous given that a subject elects how to disperse attention throughout the screen, the random treatment assignment will be used as an instrument to estimate the effects of these data given that they induce differential decision processes.
Intervention
The interventions I employ involve sequentially displaying the state space or lottery options when correlated. I compare these interventions to examine risk-taking behavior and decision-processes using eye-tracking techniques. This question is important as literature on insurance up-take has revealed people often and excessively over-insure. This experiment investigates one of the potential causes. Further it has significant implications in the division of consumer surplus and profits for insurance policymakers.
Experimental design
Individual subjects are randomly assigned to one of two treatments (sequential lotteries, or sequential states). Subjects are initially faced with two practice (unincentivized) binary lottery choices presented in a random order so they can understand that lotteries are correlated. I elected to present lotteries in wheels since sectors of a circle provide a straightforward illustration of the state space. After subjects select a lottery, the two wheels spin at the same rate and stop at the same angle. Following practice rounds, subjects are faced with a one-shot risky choice problem which determines their experimental earnings. This problem is randomly selected for each subject from a list which contains two different problems.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.