How does the communication of scientific uncertainty in times of changing evidence affect people's trust over time?
How to cite
Steinert, Janina; Sudharsanan, Nikkil; Sternberg, Henrike. 2024. "How does the communication of scientific uncertainty in times of changing evidence affect people's trust over time?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012927. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12927-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Uncertainty is an inherent part of scientific knowledge and evidence remains “tentative forever” (Popper 1961, p. 280). However, it is unclear how the public responds to transparent communication of scientific uncertainty. Communicating uncertainty becomes even more challenging in the context of emerging crises such as pandemics, economic downturns or climate risks, which often require immediate changes or adaptations in people's behaviour. Scientific findings and related evidence-based recommendations are likely to change during the (early) phases of these crises and may contribute to the public's perception that expert recommendations and claims of facts are not credible or even reflect elite attempts to advance their own agenda. A more thorough understanding of how the communication of scientific uncertainty in the context of crises and changing evidence affects people's trust is thus urgently needed. We will conduct survey experiments across three countries to assess how the explicit communication of scientific uncertainty in the context of public health recommendations in a hypothetical pandemic scenario affects participants' trust in sciences, trust in the communicator of the messages and trust in the behavioral recommendations.
Intervention
The survey experiment will be set up as follows: First, all participants will receive the following introductory information:
"Suppose that it is the year 2030 and the world is faced with a new global pandemic that poses significant health risks to those infected with the virus. In the early phase of this new pandemic, the World Health Organization issues the following information:"
Participants will then be randomised into one of two health messages, one not acknowledging scientific certainty and one explicitly acknowledging scientific uncertainty.
Group 1 - Not acknowledging uncertainty: "The World Health Organization currently recommends that everyone should only drink bottled water or boil tap water for at least one minute to make it safe to drink. Sticking to these drinking water guidelines can best protect you from infection with the new virus, which transmits primarily through contaminated water."
Group 2 - Acknowledging uncertainty: "The World Health Organization currently recommends that everyone should only drink bottled water or boil tap water for at least one minute to make it safe to drink. Sticking to these drinking water guidelines can best protect you from infection with the new virus, which transmits primarily through contaminated water.\\\\It is possible that this recommendation may change because we are learning about the new pandemic in real time. This is expected since science is all about discovery, testing, learning, and adapting. We will do our best to update you with emerging evidence and what the new information means for you."
In the next step of the experiment, participants first receive the following information:
"Three months after this first recommendation, the spread of the virus is still not contained. At this point, the World Health Organization issues a new recommendation."
Following this information, we will show a second health message but with behavioural recommendations that are different from those outlined in the first health message. Again, the updated information will either not acknowledge or acknowledge scientific uncertainty. Specifically, participants will be randomised into seeing one of the following two messages:
Group 1 - Not acknowledging uncertainty: "The World Health Organization has updated their previous recommendation and currently recommends that people should wash their hands with soap and water for at least 20 seconds and use hand sanitisers that contain at least 60% of alcohol. We also recommend sanitising high-touch surfaces such as doorknobs and handrails. Practicing hand and surface hygiene can best protect you from infection with the new virus, which transmits primarily via direct contact from hands to a person’s nose or mouth and not via contaminated water."
Group 2 - Acknowledging uncertainty: "The World Health Organization has updated their previous recommendation and currently recommends that people should wash their hands with soap and water for at least 20 seconds and use hand sanitisers that contain at least 60% of alcohol. We also recommend sanitising high-touch surfaces such as doorknobs and handrails. Practicing hand and surface hygiene can best protect you from infection with the new virus. This change was due to new scientific evidence showing that the virus transmits primarily via direct contact from hands to a person’s nose or mouth and not via contaminated water. It is possible that this recommendation may change as we learn about the pandemic in real time. We will do our best to let you know if new information comes along that may lead us to change our recommendation and what the change means for you."
For each of the messages, the survey will be programmed so that participants will be unable to progress to the next screen for twenty seconds to ensure they take sufficient time to read through and process the presented information.
Experimental design
In the first stage of the experiment, we will randomise 2/3rds of the participants into the certainty communication arm and 1/3rds into the uncertainty communication arm. In the second stage, we will randomise those who initially received the certainty communication into either updated certainty communication or updated uncertainty communication in a 1:1 ratio. Those who initially received the uncertainty communication will all receive the updated uncertainty communication in the second stage. This leads to three experimental groups in a 1:1:1 ratio: (i) certainty in the first and certainty in the second message (the reference group), (ii) uncertainty in the first and uncertainty in the second message, and (iii) certainty in the first and uncertainty in the second message.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.