Enhancing transparency in school management to develop collaboration between school and local community: Evidence from Madagascar
How to cite
Maruyama, Takao; Igei, Kengo. 2024. "Enhancing transparency in school management to develop collaboration between school and local community: Evidence from Madagascar." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012922. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12922-1.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
While the international community strives to improve access, quality, and equity of basic education, community participation has a great potential to realize and sustain educational development, especially in the countries where the administration capacity is weak. In sub-Saharan Africa, the school management committee (SMC) has been introduced as an institution to invite parents and local community members to school management since the mid-1990s. While the introduction of the SMCs aimed to realize educational development with the participation of the local community, the functionality of SMCs remained low for various reasons, including the elite capture of the organization and the lack of transparency in school management.
In Madagascar, the SMC was introduced in 2002 and the school grant has been annually distributed to the SMCs from the government to support the operation of schools; however, the transparency of the resource use of the SMC remained low and the SMCs did not gain a trust from the local community. In 2015, the government revised the institutional framework of SMC to promote the participation of the local community in school management. To operationalize the SMC reform, the Ministry of Education developed a package of interventions to improve the functionality of SMC with technical cooperation from the Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA).
This study sheds light on the transparency in school management to develop collaboration between the school and the local community. Specifically, this study mainly examines the following questions using a Randomized Controlled Trial (RCT).
- Does the package of interventions developed in Madagascar enhance the transparency in the decision-making in the school management? Does the package of interventions enhance the collaboration between the school and the local community?
- Does the package of the interventions enhance the transparency in the management of school resources, such as the school grant? Does the package of interventions reduce the misuse of the school resources?
- Does the package of interventions develop the trust between school and local community?
Intervention
The package of interventions in Madagascar comprises three sessions of training: (a) training for school principal on the democratic establishment of SMC by secret ballot election, (b) training for democratically-elected executive members of SMC on the participatory development of the school action plan cycle, and (c) training for the SMC executive members on the resource management, including external resources such as school grant. The school action plan includes a list of activities using voluntary contributions from parents and local community members as well as external resources, including a school grant. The secret ballot election aims to (re-)establish SMC with leadership for educational development, incorporating existing organizations such as a parent association.
The democratically-elected SMC bureau is trained to develop a school action plan through information-sharing and discussions at the community general assembly. In the package of interventions developed in Madagascar, the community general assemblies are organized by the democratically-established SMC stepwise to implement the school action plan cycle: (i) information-sharing on the local education and discussion on the school action plan, (ii) adoption of the school action plan, and (iii) mid-term and annual reviews of the school action plan. In the general assemblies, everyone in the school and the local community can participate, and the SMC bureau facilitates information-sharing and discussions to develop the collaboration between the school and the local community.
The third session of training in the package aims to strengthen the capacity of the SMC bureau in the two aspects: (a) to manage resources and keep accounting book, and (b) to share the information on the use of mobilized resources and the results in the community general assemblies. Regarding the external resource such as school grant, the SMC bureau is trained to conduct the information-sharing stepwise: (a) pre-announcement of the amount of upcoming external resources and the schedule, (b) announcement of the received amount of the resources, (c) discussion on how to use the resources, (d) announcement of the purchase using the resources by showing the purchased materials, and (e) reporting the results of the activities using the purchased materials. The information-sharing process is integrated into the action plan cycle and is called “community audit.”
Experimental design
The experiment in this study simply sets two arms: treatment and control groups. Half of the schools are randomly assigned to the treatment group, and the rest are the control group. The schools in the treatment group receive the package of interventions. Regarding the interventions for the control group, there are two possible options: (a) no interventions are provided, or (b) only the first (or first and second) session(s) of training are provided. Alternative design would divide the surveyed schools into three groups: treatment group A (receiving the whole sessions of training), treatment group B (receiving only the first or the first and second sessions of training), and the control group (receiving no interventions). The number of arms and the arrangement of treatment will be fixed after the baseline survey, considering the budgetary constraint of this study.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.