Closing the Innovator-Inventor Gap: Evidence from Proactive (Opt-Out) Outreach

How to cite

Grennan, Jillian; Chien, Colleen. 2024. "Closing the Innovator-Inventor Gap: Evidence from Proactive (Opt-Out) Outreach." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012897. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12897-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jillian Grennan* , Colleen Chien

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012897
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12897-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2010-01-01 – 2025-04-30
Countries
United States of America (CA)
JEL codes
J16, J24, M14, M54, O31, O32, O34
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12897

Abstract

While women comprise 35% of the STEM workforce, they make up only 13% of inventors; Black professionals represent 9% of STEM workers but only 1.2% of inventors (NCSES, 2023; Akcigit and Goldschlag, 2022). These discrepancies highlight a substantial “innovator-inventor gap,” or the reduced rate at which innovators from underrepresented groups (URGs) become inventors on patents despite their presence in the
STEM workforce (Chien, 2024). Our proposed field experiment will investigate the influence that proactive outreach has on STEM professionals' engagement with the invention process at a collaborating high-tech firm. By randomly assigning those who have never submitted an inventive idea for patenting to treatment and control groups, we plan to examine how different framing (opt-in/opt-out) and highlighted factors (extrinsic rewards/intrinsic motives) influence engagement with the inventive process, which we will measure through participation rates in early stages of the process (e.g., attending a brainstorming event) and submitted inventive ideas. Then, we will evaluate whether opt-out framing reduces the innovator-inventor gap as well as STEM professionals' self-identity as inventors and their perceptions of the firm's innovation culture. Overall, this study will provide experimental evidence on the effectiveness of such interventions in closing gaps within firms and will augment quasi-experimental evidence from natural experiments at four other collaborating firms, which provide evidence consistent with opt-out framing attenuating the innovator-inventor gap.

Intervention

We will be studying the innovation engagement of technical and engineering staff at a Silicon Valley high-tech firm, who will receive targeted emails encouraging them to participate in innovation. We will work with the firm to randomly select a set of people from the technical and engineering staff who have never engaged or only engaged a limited amount in innovation practices such as invention disclosure, inventor training, and patent filing. In shorthand, we refer to these people as “never submitters.” The firm will then send one or more targeted emails to this randomly selected subset of "never submitters," inviting them to participate in the patenting process. This email outreach from the firm's patent office will include a link to a short video to help the "never submitter" get started on their innovation journey. Subsequently, the firm will follow business as usual, noting who participates in innovation according to their normal processes.

Experimental design

The population will be divided into control and 4 treatment arms. A description of the messages the groups will receive is included in our pre-analysis plan. The treatment arms include:

Control: A group of never-submitters who will not get additional emails through this experiment. They will, however, periodically receive neutral messages without any specific framing or motivational factors from the patent team that are part of the routine course of business.
Arm 1 (personalization + intrinsic motivation)
Arm 2 (personalization + extrinsic motivation)
Arm 3 (generic + intrinsic motivation)
Arm 4 (generic + extrinsic motivation)

Design details

Randomization method
The computer randomized the assignment into groups using the seed number "04232024" and a random uniform distribution. Before implementation, the control and treatment arms were assessed for their covariate balance. The treatment and control groups were statistically indistinguishable for gender, race, citizenship, geographic location, job title, and years working at the firm.
Randomization unit
Randomized at the individual level.
Clusters
No clusters
Observations
988 control never-submitters, and 3933 treated never-submitters.
Arms
The treated never-submitters are grouped into four treatment arms, each with 1002, 945, 1000, and 986 never-submitters, respectively.
Primary outcomes
Our primary endpoints are divided into four categories: initial reaction (e.g., email opened), participation in early-stage innovative activities (e.g., learning about the patent submission process through website, attending an IP training, attending a brainstorming session, requesting a meeting with a patent team member, reaching out on Slack, meeting with a patent ambassador (limited to offices with patent ambassadors), sought advice on an inventive idea (only survey), worked on projects likely to yield patentable inventions (only survey)), involvement in later-stage invention activities (e.g., submission of an inventive idea, that idea being filed as a patent application, that idea being abandoned, that idea receiving other IP protection, and the size of the team submitting the idea), and perceptions of self and workplace (e.g., identifying as an inventor, desire to work on tasks leading to being a named inventor, the extent to which teamwork and collaboration are part of the culture and norms are developed around it).
Partners
Name: Diversity Pilots Initiative Partner_type: none Url: https://www.diversitypilots.org Name: PURE Storage Partner_type: private_company Url: https://www.purestorage.com/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords