Between trust and trade: on informal credit networks in India
How to cite
Srivastava, Kartik; Sungu, Alp; Alhorr, Layane. 2024. "Between trust and trade: on informal credit networks in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012890. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12890-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Buying consumer goods on deferred payment, or on store credit, is one of the most common credit instruments in large parts of the developing world. While store credit could increase businesses’ market access by expanding reach to liquidity-constrained customers, its availability might be limited due to the costs of learning customer type and risk. In this paper, we investigate the tradeoffs of such informal buy now pay later credit within a network of informal groceries in a low-income Indian settlement. To do so, we will randomize customers to receive store credit, a price discount, or a business-as-usual control. We aim to test the assignment’s implications on customer repayment, future purchases, loyalty, and overall business operations and profits. In a smaller experiment, we will test whether the offer of credit or discounts drives customers to increase their search radius and deviate from existing relationships with store owners. Finally, we will also test whether store-owners expand the number and type of customers they lend to following experimentation through insured lending from the intervention.
Experimental design
First stage experiment:
T1 - Text message with store credit offer (33% of the sample): a third of customers will get a text message informing them to go to a store that is not their most commonly visited store, where they may have the opportunity to receive goods on credit. More specifically:
- We will determine which store each customer goes to most frequently; we will assume that this is the customer’s location
- We will calculate the distance between the most visited store and all other stores
- We will divide stores into different quantiles of distance to the most visited store
- We will randomly select 1 store from each quantile to include in the text message and encourage people to go to. This selection allows us to understand how distance impacts demand
- We will exclude the store most visited by the customer from the list of stores where they are eligible to get store credit
T2 - Text message with discount offer (33% of the sample): a third of customers will get a text message informing them to go to a store that is not their most commonly visited store, where they may have the opportunity to receive goods on discount.
- The selection of stores to include in the message will follow the same procedure as above
- Control group (33% of the sample): the last third of customers will not receive any text messages
Second stage experiment:
Store-level randomization
We will randomly allocate stores to one of the below conditions:
- Store Credit (8 stores): we will offer store credit to a random subset of these stores’ customers
- Discount (8 stores): we will offer price discounts to a random subset of these stores’ customers
- Store Credit and Discount (4 stores): we will offer either store credit or price discounts to random subsets of these stores’ customers
- Pure control (4 stores): we will not intervene in these stores
Individual-level randomization
Additionally, we will randomize customers into one of the conditions below:
- Within Credit stores (N=8): 50% of customers will be randomized to receive store credit
- Randomization will take place at the time of billing through an online app (Knack), after customers choose their basket
- The store credit offer will cover the entire customer basket up to a maximum of INR 100
- The store credit offer will follow usual terms of store credit repayment in these contexts (e.g., no-interest loans; repayment period is decided by the business owner )
- Store owners will be informed prior to the intervention that the research team is underwriting these loans and that they will be responsible for the recollection. The store owners will keep the full amount of the repayments and can choose to lend it again
- Within discount stores (N=8): 50% customers will be randomized to receive discount
Randomization will take place at the time of billing through an online app (Knack), after customers choose their basket
The discount amount will depend on the basket value. We will round the basket value to its floor, divisible by 5
- For example, if basket value is 28, the customer will pay 25 INR; if basket value if 32 the customer will pay 30
Within credit + discount stores (N=4): customers will be randomly assigned to receive credit, discount, or nothing with equal probability (~33%).
- Within control stores (N=4): customers will not be offered any discount / store credit
These interventions will last for 8 weeks, subject to us meeting the expected sample size listed below.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.