Drivers of of High-skill Emigration during a Crisis: Experimental evidence from graduates in Myanmar

How to cite

Ghorpade, Yashodhan; Imtiaz, Muhammad Saad; Han, Theingie. 2024. "Drivers of of High-skill Emigration during a Crisis: Experimental evidence from graduates in Myanmar." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012883. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12883-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yashodhan Ghorpade* , Muhammad Saad Imtiaz , Theingie Han

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012883
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12883-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2024-02-01 – 2024-04-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
F22, J01, J08, D74, D81, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12883

Abstract

While international migration typically accompanies the development process, resulting in net gains for both sending and receiving countries especially in the medium- to long-term, a sudden and large-scale immigration of high-skilled workers can result in critical shortages of qualified workers in key sectors of economic activity in the sending country. When emigration is undertaken under duress, induced by economic and/ or political instability, such detrimental effects may be more pronounced. When migration is motivated by a need to escape duress at home, prospective emigrants may be willing to accept lower wages to move abroad, than under more normal circumstances. They may also be more willing to take up work that they are overqualified for. Both such choices represent a potential misallocation of labour, provoked by the difficult circumstances faced by potential emigrants at home. Our study seeks to understand the extent to which (i) political instability (resulting in civil conflict) and (ii) economic uncertainty drive the willingness of high-skilled youth in Myanmar to migrate aborad, the threshold wage differential at which they become indifferent between migrating and remaining at home, and the extent to which they may be amendable to undertake work for which they are overqualified. We examine these questions in the context of the military takeover of government in Myanmar since 2021, followed by high levels of violent conflict and economic collapse. As young people in Myanmar face diminished economic prospects, the appeal of emigrating abroad may increase, the reservation wage for work abroad may fall, and the hesitation to perform work they are overqualified for may reduce. Does the willingness of high-skilled youth to emigrate respond more to political or to economic prospects and expectations? We examine these questions through the use of a randomized questionnaire module in which respondents will be randomly assigned one of three hypothetical scenarios representing (i) an improvement in the political situation including the cessation of violent conflict, (ii) an improvement in the economic situation including currency and price stabilization, and (iii) a neutral scenario representing things as they are at present. Under each of these scenarios we estimate (i) the wage premium/ discount that would make high skilled youth indifferent between migrating and staying on in Myanmar, (ii) a similar wage premium/ discount but for taking on less skilled work abroad. In a second, linked survey experiment, we will also attempt to understand what level of wage premium/ discount would make Myanmar nationals living abroad indifferent between returning to Myanmar and staying on in their countries of residence under randomly assigned scenarios of political and economic improvements in Myanmar.

Intervention

Our study consists of a randomized questionnaire module that will be implemented as part of a large representative survey. Our experiment measures the valuation of emigration opportunities among high-skilled youth (in terms of the rate of wage premium or discount at which the individual is indifferent between staying and migrating) and how this is affected by alternative scenarios of improvements in the political and economic situation of the area of origin, using a randomized survey experiment that assigns alternate scenarios to respondents. Specifically, we examine the value attached to migrating abroad among (i) high-skilled workers in Myanmar when offered a similar job abroad as what they currently are engaged in, and (ii) high-skilled workers in Myanmar when offered a lower-skilled job abroad than what they currently are engaged in – both under alternate scenarios representing the status quo, political stabilization, and economic stabilization. We also propose to measure the value attached to returning to the home country (Myanmar) among Myanmar nationals living abroad when offered a similar job as what they are currently doing abroad, again under alternate scenarios representing the status quo, political stabilization, and economic stabilization, respectively.

Experimental design

Our experiment measures the valuation of emigration opportunities among high-skilled youth (in terms of the rate of wage premium or discount at which the individual is indifferent between staying and migrating) and how this is affected by alternative scenarios of improvements in the political and economic situation of the area of origin, using a randomized survey experiment that assigns alternate scenarios (political stabilization, economic stabilization, status quo) to respondents.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-based during the survey
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
1,600
Observations
1,600 The experiment is part of a CATI survey administer using random digit dialling and using screening filters to ensure that respondents meet the sample criteria: high-skilled, between the ages of 18 and 45, and currently or recently employed full-time. The survey will be nationally representative of the target population (high-skilled recently/ currently employed youth) and will be roughly equally allocated across provinces and by gender. The survey includes other modules on individual and household demographic, labor market and wealth characteristics, the ability to migrate, skills, risk appetite, recent shocks and coping strategies, and migration intentions and hypothesis. As we interview only one member household who meets the target criteria, we do not cluster our standard errors at the household level and avoid any spillover effects. In an ideal scenario, the number of experimental observations will match the number of individuals in the sample.
Arms
For Survey 1 of high-skilled youth in Myanmar, the whole sample is split into 3 equal treatment arms. When disregarding attrition and non-response, we expect to have at least 530 respondents per treatment arm among the target respondents in Myanmar. For the online survey (Survey 2) of the contacts of respondents of Survey 1 living abroad, we expect to have a minimum of 1 referred respondent living abroad per respondent and therefore a total sample of 1600 respondents. In case respondents of Survey 1 refer more than one respondent for Survey 2, we will cluster standard errors by the refereeing respondent from Survey 1; this can be done easily as we plan to send unique survey links to each Survey 1 respondent through which we can track the refereeing respondent in Survey 1 for each completed online survey in Survey 2.
Primary outcomes
Our primary measures of interest are: (1) The (binary) willingness to migrate abroad holding the level of earnings constant (2) The wage premium (discount) at which the individual becomes indifferent between migrating abroad and staying on (for diaspora respondents in survey C – between returning to Myanmar and staying on in their country of residence).
Secondary outcomes
Similar to the primary outcomes but for (1) in Survey 1 - the specification offering a job abroad that the respondent is overqualified for, and (2) in Survey 2 - for Myanmar migrants living abroad to consider wage premia(discounts) that would induce them to return to Myanmar.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords