What’s in for us? Promoting support for energy transition policies through co-benefit narratives and moral universalism
How to cite
Thiel, Zarah; Gonzalez-Gordon, Ivan; Loeschel, Andreas. 2024. "What’s in for us? Promoting support for energy transition policies through co-benefit narratives and moral universalism." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012860. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12860-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Addressing climate change requires international cooperation, widespread adoption of renewable energy (RE), and public support for the energy transition. While climate change mitigation is a global public good, investing in RE often yields local co-benefits like job creation, clean air, and enhanced energy security. Presently, developed countries account for a large share of global RE demand and technological knowledge, while many developing countries have favorable technical conditions for scaling RE.
Competing (economic) narratives exist on how to address global challenges like climate change, with varying perspectives on cooperation versus competition with other nations. This conceptually links to moral universalism in altruism: the extent to which people exhibit the same level of altruism towards strangers as towards in-group members, such as fellow citizens. Namely, altruism towards citizens from their own country vs. other countries (out-group) may be an important explanatory and moderator variable for the support of domestically vs. foreign-orientated RE policies.
This study bridges two recent strings of literature by jointly exploring the role of narratives and moral universalism in promoting policy support. Our information experiment with German and Spanish households investigates the effect of energy transition narratives, that vary the location of (domestic versus foreign) (i) RE investment and (ii) co-benefits, on the desired public spending for domestic and foreign RE policies. By further exploring heterogeneity by moral universalism, we contribute to the literature which suggests that narratives shape economic beliefs, actions and policy views, but cannot fully explain why some narratives have a stronger effect than others. Our study also provides the first experimental evidence of the role of causal narratives on policy support for climate change mitigation.
Intervention
Participants are randomly assigned to one out of five experimental groups, four of which are treatment variations and one is a control condition. Respondents in all conditions receive contextual information on the need to expand renewable energy to fight climate change. The control group receives no additional information. The four treatment groups are each provided with a different written energy transition narrative. These narratives are based on a 2x2 design (see experimental design). We apply lever narratives (Eliaz and Spiegler 2020; Kendall and Charles 2022), which include intermediate variables (mediators) in a causal story about how the respective investment decision translates to the co-benefit via these lever mechanisms.
Each narrative text is structured as follows:
-Headline with take-home message
-Overarching co-benefit (improved renewable energy supply)
-Mediators (scaling and learning effects)
-Paraphrased take-home message
Experimental design
The transition narratives are based on a 2x2 factorial design which varies the level (own country versus developing country) of (i) required renewable energy investment and (ii) co-benefits resulting from the investment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.