Signaling to increase adoption of agroecological integrated pest management (IPM): a field experiment among maize farmers in Uganda

How to cite

Haar, Lotte van der; Muriithi, Beatrice; Ochatum, Nathan; Kassie, Menale; Abro, Zewdu Ayalew; Bulte, Erwin; Mulungu, Kelvin. 2024. "Signaling to increase adoption of agroecological integrated pest management (IPM): a field experiment among maize farmers in Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012857. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12857-5.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Lotte van der Haar* , Beatrice Muriithi , Nathan Ochatum , Menale Kassie , Zewdu Ayalew Abro , Erwin Bulte , Kelvin Mulungu

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012857
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12857-5.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-09-01 – 2025-01-01
Countries
Uganda (Soroti District )
JEL codes
D9 Micro-Based Behavioral Economics, Q5 Environmental Economics
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12857

Abstract

The fall-army worm (FAW) increases food insecurity and income uncertainty in Uganda due to its sizeable negative effect on maize yield. Agroecological Integrated Pest Management (IPM) provides a promising approach to mitigate maize damages while minimizing environmental harm from control methods. However, agroecological IPM is also costly for farmers in terms of initial investments and maintenance (labor) costs. This study evaluates whether signaling opportunities at different costs may help overcome these costs and impact adoption decisions of an agroecological IPM package. We also compare the effect of signaling to the effect of loss/gain framing for a material incentive. In addition, we determine the effectiveness of an agroecological IPM approach on agricultural outcomes. The study aims to evaluate these questions using empirical evidence from a field experiment in 140 villages with 2240 farmers in Soroti District, Uganda.

Experimental design

The design of this study is a randomized controlled trial with 6 village-level treatment arms and one individual-level treatment arm and one individual-level control arm. Farmers assigned to individual-level treatment within all 6 village-level treatment arms will be provided the option to adopt an IPM package (including push-pull technology (PPT)), developed by ICIPE, free of charge. Two village-level treatment arms will receive the option to adopt the IPM package and receive a signal t-shirt (a t-shirt through which they can signal to others that they adopted the IPM package). Four village-level treatment arms will receive the option to adopt the IPM package and receive a neutral t-shirt (without the signal). We vary the cost (the area that needs to be dedicated to PPT) required to receive a signaling or neutral t-shirt. We also cross-randomize a loss/gain framing among the neutral t-shirt treatment arms. The individual-level treatment/control assignment thus determines whether an individual farmer will be offered the IPM package.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was done in STATA
Randomization unit
The project uses a two-stage randomization process. In the first step (village-level treatment assignment), sampled villages (and sampled replacement villages) are randomly assigned to one of the six treatment groups. In the second step (individual treatment assignment), we assign whether individual farmers within these villages receive the IPM package in the upcoming season (IPM treatment) or not (IPM control). From the total list of farmers (across villages) that have shown interest in the program during the information meeting, we randomly selected 1120 farmers to receive the IPM package in the upcoming season (IPM treatment) and 1120 farmers to not receive the IPM package in the upcoming season (the control group).
Clusters
140 schools
Observations
2240 farmers
Arms
- 20 villages in low-cost neutral t-shirt group with loss framing, 20 villages in low-cost neutral t-shirt group with gain framing, 30 villages in low-cost signal group, 20 villages in high-cost neutral t-shirt group with loss framing, 20 villages in high-cost neutral t-shirt group with gain framing, 30 villages in high-cost signal t-shirt group. - 1120 farmers assigned to IPM treatment, 1120 farmers assigned to control
Primary outcomes
IPM Adoption (push-pull technology (PPT) implementation and PPT implementation area, willingness-to-pay for future PPT) Signaling value (willingness-to-accept for t-shirt) Knowledge diffusion effort (trained/shared info with other farmers) Agricultural outcomes (maize yield/maize production costs)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords