A 20-year Follow-Up to an Early Childhood Stimulation Program in Jamaica
How to cite
GERTLER, PAUL; Himes, John; Powell, Christine; Grantham-McGregor, Sally; Chang-Lopez, Susan; Walker, Susan; Vermeersch, Christel; Zanolini, Arianna; Pinto, Rodrigo; Heckman, James. 2017. "A 20-year Follow-Up to an Early Childhood Stimulation Program in Jamaica." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001284. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1284-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
A substantial literature shows that U.S. early childhood interventions have significant long-term economic benefits. There is little evidence on this question for developing countries. We report substantial effects on the earnings of participants in a randomized intervention conducted from 1987 - 1989 that gave psychosocial stimulation to growth-stunted Jamaican toddlers. The intervention consisted of weekly visits from community health workers over a 2-year period that taught parenting skills and encouraged mothers and children to interact in ways that develop cognitive and socio-emotional skills. The authors re-interviewed 105 out of 129 study participants 20 years later and found that the intervention increased earnings by 25%, enough for them to catch up to the earnings of a non-stunted comparison group identified at baseline (65 out of 84 participants).
Intervention
In 2007 and 2008, researchers conducted a follow-up evaluation to a 1991 Lancet paper on an early childhood intervention that took place from 1987-1989 in low-income neighborhoods in Kingston, Jamaica. The original early childhood development (ECD) program, which lasted two years, enrolled 129 stunted children aged 9-24 months. Researchers randomly assigned these children to one of four groups: a psychosocial stimulation intervention, a nutrition intervention, both interventions, or neither intervention (the comparison group). Researchers also collected data on 84 non-stunted children from the same neighborhoods to serve as an additional comparison group. The stimulation intervention included weekly home visits by trained community health workers, who encouraged and instructed mothers on how to play and interact with their children. For the nutrition intervention, health workers distributed weekly nutritional supplements to homes, as well as additional cornmeal and skimmed milk powder to discourage sharing of the supplement with other family members.
Twenty years after the end of the program, researchers followed up with the participants of the original ECD intervention, when they were about 22 years old, to measure the long-term impacts of the program. Researchers re-interviewed 105 individuals from the original cohort of stunted children, and 65 from the original comparison group of non-stunted children. Data was collected on education and labor market outcomes to identify how the program impacted adult education and earnings outcomes, as well as whether the program enabled stunted children to "catch up" with the non-stunted comparison group.
Experimental design
In 1986-1987, the Jamaican Study enrolled 129 stunted children age 9-24 months that lived in poor disadvantaged neighborhoods of Kingston, Jamaica. Stunting was defined as having a standardized height for age z-score less than -2. The children were stratified by age (above and below 16 months) and sex. Within each stratum, children were sequentially assigned to one of four groups using a randomly generated seed to begin the assignment. The four groups were (1) psychosocial stimulation (N=32), (2) nutritional supplementation (N=32), (3) both psychosocial stimulation and nutritional supplementation (N=32), and (4) a control group that received neither intervention (N=33). All children were given access to free health care regardless of the group to which they were assigned.
The stimulation intervention (comprising groups 1 and 3) consisted of two years of weekly one-hour play sessions at home with trained community health aides. The curriculum for the cognitive stimulation was based on Piagetian concepts. Mothers were encouraged to converse with their children, to label things and actions in their environments and to play educational games with their children. Particular emphasis was placed on language development, the use of praise, and on improving the self-esteem of both the child and of the mother. At age 24 months, the curriculum was enriched to include concepts such as size, shape, position, quantity, color, etc. based on the curriculum in Palmer.
The focus of the weekly play sessions was on improving the quality of the interaction between mother and child. Mothers were encouraged to continue practicing the activities and games learned during the visits on a continuing basis beyond the home visitation time. At every visit, homemade toys were brought to the home and left for the mother and child to use until the next visit when they were replaced with new ones. The intervention was innovative both for its focus on activities to promote cognitive and language development and for its emphasis on direct mother-child interactions. The nutritional intervention (comprising groups 2 and 3) was aimed at compensating for the nutritional deficiencies that may have caused stunting. The nutritional supplements were provided weekly for a two-year period. The supplements consisted of one kilogram of formula containing 66% of daily-recommended energy (calories), and 100% of daily-recommended protein. In addition, in an attempt to minimize sharing of the formula with other family members, the family also received 0.9 kilograms of cornmeal and skimmed milk powder. Despite this, sharing was common and uptake of the supplement decreased significantly during the intervention.
Of the 129 study participants, two of the participants dropped out before completion of the two-year program. The remaining 127 participants were surveyed at baseline, resurveyed immediately following the end of the two-year intervention, and again at ages 7, 11, and 18. Our analysis is based on a re-interview of the sample in 2007-08 when the participants were approximately 22 years old, some 20 years after the original intervention.
For comparison purposes, the study also enrolled a sample of non-stunted children from the same neighborhoods, where non-stunted was defined as having a height for age z-score greater than -1 standard deviations. At baseline, every fourth stunted child in the study was matched with one non-stunted child who lived nearby and was the same age (plus or minus 3 months) and sex. At age 7, this sample of 32 was supplemented with another 52 children who had been identified in the initial survey as being non-stunted and fulfilled all other inclusion criteria. While the non-stunted group was better off than the stunted group in terms of their personal development and their socioeconomic status, the non-stunted children were still living in the same economically and socially disadvantaged Kingston neighborhoods. Members of the non-stunted comparison group did not receive any of the interventions, but did receive the same free health care as those in the stunted experimental group. From age 7 onwards, this group was surveyed at the same time as the participants in the experiment. This sample is used to investigate the extent to which the early childhood stimulation intervention helped to compensate for initial disadvantage by comparing the stunted treatment group with the non-stunted external comparison group. We define complete catch-up as no difference between the treated stunted group and the non-stunted comparison group.
In order to better understand the external validity of the catch-up analysis we compare the non-stunted group to the general population using data from two surveys that are representative of urban Jamaica: (1) the 1992 Jamaican Survey of Living Conditions (JSLC) that was collected when the children were 7 years old and when most of the non-stunted sample was first surveyed, and (2) the 2008 Jamaica Labor Force (JLF) survey that was collected in the same year as the last follow-up. Unfortunately the labor supply and earnings questions in the JLF and in our survey were asked in different ways, and there was a 50% non-response rate in the JLF to the earnings questions among those who were employed. Only the education variables are directly comparable.
Design details
Materials
Papers from this trial
- Grantham-McGregor SM, Powell CA, Walker SP, Himes JH. (1991) Nutritional supplementation, psychosocial stimulation and development of stunted children: The Jamaican study. Lancet, 338, 1-5 http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/0140673691900016
- Walker, Susan, Susan M Chang, Marcos Vera-Hernandez, Sally Grantham-McGregor. 2011 Early childhood stimulation benefits adult competence and reduces violent behavior. Pediatrics 127: 849-857 http://pediatrics.org/cgi/doi/10.1542/peds.2010-2231
- Gertler, Paul, James Heckman, Rodrigo Pinto, Arianna Zanolini, Christel Vermeerch, Susan Walker, Susan M. Chang, and Sally Grantham-McGregor. "Labor Market Returns to Early Childhood Stimulation: a 20-year Followup to an Experimental Intervention in Jamaica." World Bank Policy Research Working Paper #6529, July 2013. https://www.povertyactionlab.org/sites/default/files/publications/653%20long%20term%20follow%20up%20Jamaica%20July2013.pdf
- Gertler, Paul, James Heckman, Rodrigo Pinto, Arianna Zanolini, Christel Vermeerch, Susan Walker, Susan Chang-Lopez, and Sally Grantham-McGregor. 2014. “Labor Market Returns to an Early Childhood Stimulation Intervention in Jamaica.” Science 344(6187): 998-1001. http://science.sciencemag.org/content/344/6187/998.full
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.