Strengthening the Transfer Pathway: Addressing Uncertainty through Guaranteed College Admissions
How to cite
Shi, Lena. 2024. "Strengthening the Transfer Pathway: Addressing Uncertainty through Guaranteed College Admissions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012825. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12825-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Although 80 percent of entering and community college studies aspire to earn a bachelor's degree, most do not earn an associate degree or early transfer to a four-year college. The college application process, which can be complex, time-consuming, and uncertain, may contribute to the low transfer rates. Prior research suggests that reducing uncertainty using clear and guaranteed payoffs can encourage individuals to undertake high-effort and challenging behavior.
This study explores the impact of reducing uncertainty in college admissions, particularly for students who have less access to advising and support during the college application process. What is the impact of guaranteed admissions on community college students’ four-year transfer choices? Does the type of admissions guarantee matter? To answer these questions, I evaluate the impact of the Common Transfer Guarantee (CTG), an initiative in which four-year colleges admit community college transfer students based on college academic performance or the college they attended. The CTG, which was hosted by the Common App during the 2021-2022 application cycle, informed community college students who registered on their application portal about four-year colleges where they likely qualify for guaranteed admissions.
Intervention
This project examines the impact of guaranteed admissions through the Common App's Common Transfer Guarantee (CTG) initiative, which was implemented during the 2021-2022 application cycle. The intervention informs a randomized group of eligible applicants about up to 25 members that are four-year colleges, where the applicants qualify for guaranteed admissions based on their college grade point average (GPA), credits accumulated, community college attended, and degrees earned. Common App sends this email, which contains a list of the colleges, as well as a link to the members' college application and profile pages. The treated students receive two follow-up reminders containing information from the original email in the subsequent two months. The control group received none of this personalized information.
While the content of the intervention was substantively the same, there were two primary treatments. The first informs applicants about their guaranteed admissions eligibility based on academic progress. This eligibility pool consisted of community college students meeting certain GPA, credits completed, and degree completion thresholds for 16 4-year college and universities. The second informs applicants about their guaranteed admissions eligibility based on the degree and college attended. In this case, this eligibility pool consisted of community college students who would graduate from institutions that have articulation agreements with 9 4-year college and universities.
Experimental design
Assignment to treatment was randomized at the applicant level after identifying a set of eligible community college students. Due to organizational preferences and constraints, 85 percent of the final pool were randomly assigned to the treatment group while the remaining 15 percent were randomly assigned to the control group.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.