How personal exposure affects the support for carbon pricing
How to cite
Korsinnek, Maike; Behringer, Jan; Endres, Lukas. 2024. "How personal exposure affects the support for carbon pricing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012808. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12808-1.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In 2021, a carbon price was implemented in Germany, targeting emissions in the building and transport sectors to encourage the adoption of low-carbon alternatives. The German government announced using revenues to compensate households via a climate rebate. Previous research suggests that knowledge about financial implications from and acceptance of carbon pricing and rebate schemes remain limited among the general public. In this project, we investigate whether policy acceptance can be improved by providing personalized information regarding costs or rebate amounts.
We conduct a survey experiment with a representative sample of the German population. We randomly assign participants to variants of our experiment that provide them with personalized information either regarding their households’ costs from carbon pricing or rebate amounts.
In the first experiment, we start by eliciting participants’ acceptance of carbon pricing. Next, we ask participants to state their household's additional annual costs for a given carbon price as well as their uncertainty regarding their estimation. A randomly selected treatment group receives quantitative information on their household’s actual costs from carbon pricing, calculated based on previously stated vehicle and energy usage. The remaining participants act as a control group with no further information. The experiment concludes by eliciting all participants’ posterior acceptance of carbon pricing.
Our second experiment starts by providing participants with the personalized cost information when inquiring about their prior acceptance of carbon pricing. Next, we suggest a lump-sum climate rebate of total revenues from carbon pricing, asking participants to state the expected annual payout to their household and their level of uncertainty regarding this estimation. Afterward, participants are randomly selected to receive information on the actual rebate amount for their household given this policy design. The control group receives no additional information. Again, we conclude by eliciting all participants' posterior acceptance of carbon pricing.
We conduct both experiments for the current price of 45€/t CO2 and a projected price of 200€/t CO2 in 2027. Our experiment is followed by additional questions on participants' trust in the government's climate policy decisions and their preferences regarding revenue use of the carbon price.
Our experimental design allows us to identify the causal effect of personalized information provision regarding costs and rebate amounts on policy acceptance of carbon pricing and to investigate how respondents differentially incorporate quantitative information based on their initial misperceptions and uncertainty.
Experimental design
We conduct a survey experiment among approximately 9600 participants representative of the German population. Prior to our experiment, we ask all participants on a four-point Likert scale how well informed they feel about carbon pricing in Germany and measure their carbon price literacy based on three questions on the policy instrument. We collect additional information about participants’ household size, homeowner status, the size of their dwelling, energy consumption for heating purposes, their household’s vehicle fleet and annual vehicle usage.
We randomly assign participants to variants of our experiment which provide them with personalized information about either their household’s costs from carbon pricing or dividends received from a climate rebate program that pays out carbon pricing revenues on a per capita basis. Both variants are conducted for the current price of 45 €/t of CO2 and a projected price of 200 €/t of CO2 in 2027. Consequently, we have four segments, each including a treatment and a control group of 1200 participants.
The first experiment begins by briefly informing participants about carbon pricing in the building and transport sectors in Germany and eliciting their prior acceptance of carbon pricing on a five-point Likert scale. Next, we ask participants to estimate their household’s additional annual costs from carbon pricing at a given price level and to express their uncertainty regarding their estimation on a five-point Likert scale. 50% of participants are then randomly assigned to receive quantitative information on their household’s actual costs from carbon pricing. Additional heating costs are calculated using the previously collected information on household's annual energy consumption. Additional transportation expenses are inferred from the household's distance traveled and the average fuel consumption of their vehicle fleet. The remaining 50% of participants act as a control group and receive no further information. The experiment concludes by eliciting all participants’ posterior acceptance of carbon pricing on a five-point Likert scale.
The second experiment begins by providing participants with brief information about carbon pricing in the building and transport sectors and personalized information on their household’s additional costs from carbon pricing at a given price level, before eliciting their acceptance of carbon pricing on a five-point Likert scale. Next, we ask them to estimate the dividend received by their household, granted by a lump-sum climate rebate program that pays out all carbon pricing revenues on a per capita basis. We also ask participants to indicate their level of uncertainty regarding this estimation on a five-point Likert scale. 50% of participants are then randomly selected to receive quantitative information on their households’ actual rebate amount. Per capita dividends are calculated based on the latest wave of the German sample survey of income and expenditure which contains information regarding private households’ total consumption of fossil fuels in the building and transport sectors. We redistribute total revenues from carbon pricing on a per capita basis to derive rebate amounts, which are then multiplied with our respondents’ household size. The control group receives no additional information. As in the first experiment, we conclude by eliciting all participants’ posterior acceptance of carbon pricing on a five-point Likert scale.
Both experiments are succeeded by a question about participants’ trust in the government's climate policy on a five-point Likert scale. We also elicit participants’ preferences regarding the use of the carbon pricing revenues by asking them to allocate total revenues from carbon pricing to different categories, including transfers to households, public spending, or tax reductions.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.