Greenwashing and enforcement

How to cite

Dini, Giorgio. 2024. "Greenwashing and enforcement." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012770. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12770-2.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Giorgio Dini*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012770
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12770-2.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-10-24 – 2024-06-30
Countries
Italy (Bologna)
JEL codes
D12, D82, K42
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12770

Abstract

Despite being regulated by truth-in-advertising laws, greenwashing continues to be a significant issue, posing challenges to consumer protection and fair competition. Even with these regulations, difficulties in detection and inconsistent enforcement impede a solution to the
problem. This paper explores greenwashing through a variation of a sender-receiver game, incorporating a random inspector responsible for detecting false claims. Using signalling theory, we predict the behaviour of sellers and buyers based on each other’s beliefs. We
then test these predictions in a laboratory setting with real products and consequential purchasing decisions, examining how different detection probabilities influence greenwashing as well as consumption behaviour and beliefs. Not surprisingly, our findings indicate that enforcement primarily acts as a deterrent for sellers. Interestingly, buyers repeatedly purchase green products even when greenwashing is foreseen. Policymakers should address greenwashing differently depending on the weight they give to consumer surplus and environmental
concerns

Intervention

In this work, we investigate the role of different levels of enforcement, and specifically the probability of detection:
- in altering profitable conditions to do greenwashing and the consequent behaviour of sellers;
- in buyers' willingness-to-pay for products with green claims;
- in buyers' actual purchase actions.

Experimental design

The design is the reproduction of the theoretical model in practical terms. There are two types of players, a seller and a buyer. The seller sells a good with or without credence attributes. Product type g is a green good, namely a good with the green credence attribute while type c is a conventional good without that attributes. The other product characteristics are identical. Only the seller possesses the information about the environmental performance of the good. Buyers cannot obtain the information on their own through experience or search.
The seller can choose the claim and consequently, the price to send to the buyer. The set of possible prices is reduced to two levels for simplicity: the price for a good with green claim Pg and the price of a conventional good Pc. If the conventional good has a false claim, its price is Pg which is strictly greater than Pc. On top of this, the seller can signal the quality of the product with a claim about the product’s sustainability. Adopting a signal costs D which is small and which is identical both for truthful and false claims.
By adopting a false signal, the seller incurs in the probability of being caught by an authority which with ϵ probability verifies the signal truthfulness and applies a fine f of a fixed and known amount.

Game procedure
At the beginning of the study, once the instructions have been read, the seller is exogenously given a product which can have a 50% probability of being green and 50% probability of being conventional. The seller knows the actual characteristics of the product displayed on the screen. In the same page, the seller decides whether to adopt a sustainability claim and incur cost D or not. The choice of the signal influences the price at which the good is sold: a good with the green claim is sold at price Pg; a good with no claim at Pc. The seller with the conventional product
has a binary choice between “Claim A” and “Claim B” where “Claim B” is the green (false) option. The seller with the green product instead can only choose ”Claim B” which is, in practice, true. Once the seller has made the decisions the so-called “market authority” randomly checks some of the product types and the claims adopted. The probability differs across treatments (see section 3. The authority verifies automatically
the coincidence between the claim and the product type with ϵ probability and applies a fine f if a green claim has been adopted on a conventional product. Simultaneously, in the case that a false claim is detected, the authority restores the correct price of the good Pc.
In the last stage, the buyer receives the product on his/her screen and elicits two decisions. Firstly, the buyer sees only the claim after possible authority checks and elicits their willingness to pay for the product. Secondly, the buyer is informed about the products’ market prices and decides whether to purchase the product or not by paying the relative price.
Once the buyer has taken both decisions, pairs are randomly shuffled and participants are informed that they might be matched with another partner in the next round.
The actual verification is not public knowledge: sellers discover about the sanctions received only at the end of the study, while buyers never discover that.

Design details

Randomization method
Several randomization procedures are adopted. Here is the description: Participants are randomly allocated to the seats (or to turned-away reserves) through a visible random draw when they enter the laboratory. The software oTree randomly assigns participants to a participant number independently of the seat number they are working. The software randomly assigns the roles of sellers and buyers. The first product is fixed for econometrics considerations, while from round 2 participants receive a product assigned to that participant number. In every session, the product-participant assignment varies randomly. The product assigned to sellers can be green or conventional, and this is the result of a random draw. The prices contained in the envelope are randomly drawn before each session starts through Microsoft Excel to facilitate the envelope procedures. Each buyer can receive a different product, which is randomly drawn before the session starts. The software Excel draws a product for each participant number. This is chosen to reduce the number of products brought to the laboratory for every session. The sellers' two valid rounds are drawn within the software oTree during the session, and they are different for each participant.
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
Individual clusters: 120-160 participants per treatment meaning 60-80 per type.
Observations
Minimum: 2 treatments only, 120 participants each, 7 observations per participant: Planned number of observations: 1680 Maximum: 3 treatments, 160 participants each, 7 observations per participant: Planned number of observations: 3360
Arms
120-160 participants per treatment arm. Plus 85 participants from the BDM auction already deployed.
Primary outcomes
The outcomes are divided into two groups depending on whether they refer to the sellers or the buyers. The main outcome variables to test sellers’ behaviour are: a) the choice to greenwash while possessing a conventional product; b) the stated expected demand for both conventional and green products. The first variable is obtained by looking at the variable greenwashing which is gathered directly through oTree (in Part A) when a player with a conventional product decides to opt for a green claim. The variable takes the value ”Yes”/”No” which can be easily re-constructed as a dummy taking value 1 if there is greenwashing and 0 otherwise. The second main variable is the expected demand which is generated in Part C of the experimental procedure. Sellers are asked with an economic incentive to reveal what they think is the demand for both green and conventional versions of each product. The choice is among a set of 10 alternatives with ranges of 10% (0-10%,11%-20%,...,91%- 100%), meaning that participants have to pick the range within which they think the demand for that specific product lies. Buyers’ main outcome variables are the willingness to pay for each product displayed and the actual choice to purchase or not the green product. Both variables are gathered through oTree in Part A. The WTP and choice are filtered through the variable final claim which reports the claim (potentially) after authority intervention. Their nature is very straightforward as is displayed in the summary table 4. Additionally, buyers reveal what they think is the behaviour of sellers holding a conventional when facing the choice to/not to greenwash. This choice is expressed in Part C and has two outcomes "Yes”/”No” for each product which can be easily converted into a dummy taking value 1 if they believe that a conventional seller does greenwashing in such conditions or 0 otherwise.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcomes are: - the risk aversion index from the Bomb Risk Elicitation Task (BRET) - interest and experience in purchasing products - a series of variables about environmentalism and climate activism - trust in green advertising - trust in institutions regulating misleading advertising - beliefs about greenwashing and its enforcement in real life - demographics (age, gender, job, field of study, sustenance, income)
Sponsors
Name: Small Grants Rebalancing Public & Private Interests Location: Sector Plan - Erasmus School of Law - Rotterdam Url: https://www.eur.nl/en/esl/research/our-research/rebalancing-public-private-interests/impact/small-grants

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords