Buy Now Pay Later (BNPL) recently has become one of the popular innovations in the Fintech payment sector which allows consumers to spread the cost of a product over a number of months, generally, without interest. While this payment feature offers flexibility to a number of consumers, there is a growing concern on some consumers taking up more debt than they can afford to repay coupled with lack of understanding of related terms and conditions, resulting in financial adversity. Through an online trial, we intend to study the causal effect of BNPL on consumer spending patterns, disentangling the selection and treatment effects of BNPL. Additionally, we test for effective ways to improve consumer comprehension of BNPL products and their terms and conditions.
Experimental design
The survey will take approximately 20 minutes to complete. At the beginning of the experiment, participants will be screened based whether they are online shoppers. Participants will then be asked questions related to financial services usage (including credit cards and overdrafts), socio-demographic characteristics, financial literacy, delayed gratification, financial distress, financial efficacy, and attention. Then, participants will proceed to the online shopping task where they will be randomly assigned to one of four treatment arms or a control group, varying in payment option (Debit Card, BNPL) and BNPL disclosures. The shopping task involves choosing between a generic and a luxury version of a product during three separate rounds of shopping, with each participant given a notional budget constraint of €1000. While the three rounds of shopping task requires participants to buy either the luxury version or the generic version of the product using the available payment option, there will be a fourth round of shopping where participants can choose whether to buy an additional discretionary product, and if so, whether they want to use debit card or BNPL for payment. After completing the shopping task, participants will be asked about BNPL comprehension, recall of prices, and their checkout experience.
Design details
Randomization method
Participants are randomised to either a control group or one of the four treatment groups based on randomisation done by the Gorilla experiment builder tool.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomisation is at individual level
Clusters
No clusters
Observations
3000 nationally representative individuals
Arms
600 in each of the experimental arms
Primary outcomes
1. Amount of money spent - Total amount spent by participant during the shopping exercise
2. Purchase of an additional discretionary product - Binary Variable (0/1) indicating if the participant chooses to buy an additional discretionary product at the end of the shopping exercise.
3. BNPL Usage - 3.1. Binary Variable (0/1) indicating if the participant chooses BNPL during each round of shopping task, wherever BNPL is a payment option.
3.2. Number of times participant chooses BNPL in first three rounds of shopping task, wherever BNPL is a payment option.
3.3 Binary Variable (0/1) indicating if the participant chooses BNPL in fourth round of shopping if participant decides to purchase an additional discretionary product in round 4.
4. BNPL Comprehension - Correct answers to questions relating to the BNPL payment method measured as dichotomous variable and standardized score for the following questions:
• Is BNPL a credit product?
• What is the interest rate under BNPL?
• When is the second installment due for the purchase?
• Is late fee involved in case of late/non-repayment?
• What is the amount of late fee involved in case of late/non-repayment?
• Will the debt be transferred to debt collection agencies in case of late/non-repayment?
Secondary outcomes
1. Recall of cost of each item purchased - Dichotomous variable indicating if the participant correctly recalls the price of each item purchased.
2. Recall of total amount spent - Dichotomous variable indicating if the participant correctly recall amount spent during the shopping.
3. Recall of future commitments amount - Dichotomous variable indicating if the participant correctly recall amount they have to pay in future as part of the shopping.
4. Estimation of probability of higher spending during shopping - Correctly estimating the probability of overspending (defined as spending over 50th percentile) during shopping
5. Estimation of probability of using short-term credit during shopping Correctly estimating the probability of using BNPL during shopping in any of the four shopping rounds.
6. Likelihood of future use - Variable measuring the likelihood that participant will use BNPL in future (not at all likely, moderately likely, and extremely likely).
7. Recommend to others - Variable measuring the likelihood that participant will recommend BNPL to a friend or family member (not at all likely, moderately likely, and extremely likely).
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.