Balancing Global Climate Action and Local Rights: Survey Experimental Evidence on Public Support for Carbon Offsetting in Liberia

How to cite

Park, David Sungho; Lee, Dongil; Rhee, Inbok. 2024. "Balancing Global Climate Action and Local Rights: Survey Experimental Evidence on Public Support for Carbon Offsetting in Liberia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012752. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12752-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

David Sungho Park* , Dongil Lee , Inbok Rhee

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012752
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12752-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-12-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Liberia ()
JEL codes
O13, Q01, Q23, Q54, Q56
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12752

Abstract

When do citizens in developing countries support climate change action, such as carbon offsetting? Carbon offsetting, aimed at achieving a net zero carbon footprint through investments in renewable energy, forest conservation, or reforestation, is endorsed by many international organizations and climate agreements. Previous research has primarily centered on the effectiveness of carbon offsetting, including potential “license to pollute” issues. However, there are growing concerns about how this pursuit of a “just energy” transition can hurt the most vulnerable among host country nationals by affecting the local livelihoods reliant on forest resources. Using an original survey experiment in Liberia, this study examines the conditions under which host country citizens support carbon offsetting projects. Our findings reveal a general lack of support for carbon offsetting, even when explicitly informed of its potential benefits. Notably, when information about violations of local property rights or doubts about project effectiveness is presented, opposition intensifies--particularly among individuals connected to forestry industries. Our study highlights the need for a more nuanced understanding of local perspectives in implementing global climate strategies.

Intervention

The intervention in our experiment is a vignette embedded in a survey (i.e., information treatment) designed to gauge responses to different narratives about carbon offsetting projects in a developing country context. The survey includes a common narrative presented to all participants, followed by two distinct types of narratives – one highlighting the positive aspects and the other emphasizing the negative aspects of carbon offsetting projects. In order to help the understanding of the respondents and for ease of communication, the narratives were supplemented with single-page black and white cartoon visually depicting the narrative.

1. Positive Narrative: This survey component describes the beneficial impacts of carbon offsetting projects. It focuses on how such projects can introduce financial investment from abroad and promote the adoption of cleaner, more sustainable technologies in the host country.

2. Negative Narrative: This part of the survey outlines the potential drawbacks of carbon offsetting projects. It emphasizes concerns such as the potential for these projects to encroach on the land and rights of local communities and doubts about the actual effectiveness of these projects in achieving their intended environmental goals.

Experimental design

Our experiment employs a vignette-based survey design to examine the impact of different narratives on perceptions of carbon offsetting projects in a developing country. The design incorporates a common narrative given to all participants, supplemented by either a positive or negative narrative about carbon offsetting, or both. These narratives are cross-randomized into four distinct groups, with a total of 2,000 subjects equally distributed across these groups.

1. Group 1 (Control): Receives only the common narrative, serving as the baseline for comparison. This group does not receive any additional positive or negative information about carbon offsetting projects.

2. Group 2 (Positive Narrative): Receives the common narrative along with additional information highlighting the positive aspects of carbon offsetting projects, such as economic benefits and adoption of sustainable technologies.

3. Group 3 (Negative Narrative): Receives the common narrative and a narrative focusing on the potential negative impacts, like land appropriation concerns and effectiveness doubts.

4. Group 4 (Combined Narrative): Participants in this group are exposed to both the positive and negative narratives, in addition to the common narrative. This group is further split, with half of the subjects (250 out of 500) randomly selected to receive the positive narrative first, followed by the negative narrative, and the other half receiving these in the reverse order.

This design allows us to assess the individual and combined effects of positive and negative information on participants' perceptions, and the order effect in the group receiving both narratives.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization was conducted in the field using a random number generator feature within SurveyCTO, a data collection software utilized on Android tablets.
Randomization unit
Randomized at individual level
Clusters
2,000 individuals
Observations
2,000 individuals
Arms
500 individuals: Group 1 (Control) 500 individuals: Group 2 (Positive Narrative) 500 individuals: Group 3 (Negative Narrative) 500 individuals: Group 4 (Positive + Negative Narrative)
Primary outcomes
The key outcome variables in our experiment are structured into four primary outcome clusters/indices: 1. Government and Policy Perspectives Index 2. Environmental and Investment Perceptions Index 3. Social and Community Concerns Index 4. Global Climate Change Perspectives Index Each index represents a distinct thematic area, capturing attitudes and opinions across different dimensions related to carbon offsetting, environmental policies, and socio-economic impacts.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords