Impact evaluation of an entrepreneurship program (cash and training) and of remote discussion groups for micro business owners.
How to cite
Rochambeau, Golvine de; Agarwal, Anubhav; Bono, Mitja Del. 2023. "Impact evaluation of an entrepreneurship program (cash and training) and of remote discussion groups for micro business owners.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012751. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12751-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Programs targeted at relaxing financial constraints of small and medium enterprises (SMEs) or at enhancing their business practices have shown strong potential for increasing firm growth and employment (de Mel et al. 2008, McKenzie and Woodruff 2008, or Bloom et al. 2013 among others). These programs are thought to foster inclusive growth through their immediate impact on the businesses they target. While impact evaluations of these programs show a positive impact on the firms that are part of the program, these measured effects may happen at the expense of other firms (Cai and Szeidl 2022). This can happen if, for example, these firms compete for the same customers or the same labor force. If so, the welfare implications—the overall economic impact in terms of revenue or employment—of such programs are ambiguous. If firms in the program benefit at the expense of other firms, then total growth generated depends on the relative growth potential of firms in the intervention’s selected group, compared to the firms they are taking resources away from. The program improves welfare only in cases where the firms supported by the intervention generate higher growth than the counterfactual firms who would have gotten these resources had the program not been implemented. Welfare implications are less clear when the firms supported by the program are low-growth-potential firms and capture resources away from high-growth-potential firms.
This project aims at measuring two key aspects that will help address welfare implications of such a program. First, through a clustered randomization design, we will be able to measure whether a grant-awarding program benefits firms at the expense of other similar and geographically close firms. The grant treatment comes packaged with a training treatment but, as we expect the grant to drive most of the effect of the grant and training treatment, the latter is simply referred to as “the grant” in the remainder of this document. The second aspect of this project is a business connectivity intervention similar to Cai and Szeidl 2016, where entrepreneurs are invited to meet weekly over a call in a focus group setting (5 to 6 entrepreneurs per group and 1 moderator to facilitate the discussion) and exchange on business-related issues, and share potential ideas. Allowing firms to communicate with one another might alleviate the information frictions they are facing and attenuate the negative externalities of a grant-awarding program. This project will allow us to measure what is the effect of relaxing these frictions, but also, thanks to a cross-randomization of the grant and the business connectivity intervention, we will be able to understand how solving information frictions interacts with relaxing financial constraints, and in particular whether this combination changes the welfare implications.
This project will, therefore, help answer the following key questions:
1. Do interventions financially supporting small firms help create net jobs, generate negative spillover, and/or improve overall welfare?
2. Can small firms benefit from an exchange of business-related information with other fellow entrepreneurs?
3. Does connecting small firms to one another improve the overall economic effect of financially supporting small firms?
This project is part of a World Bank funded project implemented in Liberia called REALISE (Recovery of Economic Activity for Liberian Informal Sector Employment Project). In collaboration with the Liberian government, the research team is evaluating the first component of this project.
Experimental design
The COVID-19 pandemic posed a major threat to the Liberian economy and its people, in particular urban informal non-farming firms, which saw large revenue losses, with the risk of closing due to limited access to formal credit. The World Bank-financed Recovery of Economic Activity for Liberian Informal Sector Employment (REALISE) Project aims to increase access to income earning opportunities for the vulnerable in the informal sector in response to the COVID-19 crisis in Liberia. Under the Project, the Small Business Support (SSB) program targets up to 4,000 households operating Non-Farming Enterprises (NFEs) in urban areas, with a specific focus on Greater Monrovia in Montserrado County. These businesses, typically engaged in the informal sector, often face difficulties in sustaining their economic activities and overcoming the impact of shocks. The SSB program aims to address these challenges by offering grants, training and the piloting of an add-on business connectivity intervention to support existing businesses and establish new businesses.
The program employs a geographical targeting method to select project communities based on factors such as poverty status, access to basic services, population density, living conditions (e.g., slum communities), and proximity to major commercial areas. The selection process utilizes national census data and consultations to identify eligible communities, ensuring an inclusive approach. Overall, the SSB program is implemented in 20 community clusters within the Greater Monrovia area. An on-demand targeting mechanism is then utilized within each community cluster, providing interested individuals the opportunity to participate in the recruitment process. Both community-based and individual-based targeting processes are led by the Liberia Agency for Community Empowerment (LACE), with support from the Ministry of Youth and Sports (MYS), other stakeholders and partners.
Beneficiaries selected for the SSB program gain access to business grants to revive or initiate new businesses. The grants, disbursed through mobile money accounts, are intended for investment in inputs, productive assets, and other essential business expenses. The first tranche of the grant amounts to US$600, and the second tranche, totaling US$300, is disbursed upon justifying the utilization of the initial tranche for business investments. To enhance business management skills and practices of vulnerable households operating NFEs, the SSB program offers comprehensive training. Beneficiaries with existing businesses participate in a 5-day Business Management and Financial Literacy training, while those establishing new businesses undergo a 15-day training program. These sessions are designed to develop effective business plans, improve record-keeping capabilities, promote savings practices, and enhance customer service skills. Moreover, the training curriculum includes personal initiative and growth mind-set sessions, leveraging role models, and cost-effective coaching/mentoring involving peers from the local community. Beneficiaries also benefited from enrollment in the National ID Registry (NIR) and received National Identification Numbers (NIN) and NIR ID cards, which facilitate their registration for Mobile Money accounts. In conclusion, upon successful completion of the subproject activities, beneficiaries will receive a certificate of participation issued by the Liberia Agency for Community Empowerment (LACE).
The focus of this study is the first round of SSB implementation, which focuses on supporting existing businesses, targeting 1,200 beneficiaries from 15 selected community clusters in Greater Monrovia. The targeting process for Round 1 involves identifying one representative from each household to participate in the program. Individuals representing the households must be at least 18 years old and willing to engage in all program activities. They must reside in a participating community and should not be enrolled in any social assistance program similar to the benefits provided by the REALISE project. Furthermore, they, nor a member of their household, must not hold public office or have any form of employment with a monthly income exceeding US$250. In addition, eligibility requires prior experience in operating a small business before March 30, 2021. To promote gender inclusion and ensure female participation, the representative of the household must be female for at least 50 percent of the households selected.
In addition to the grant, a random selection of applicants (beneficiaries or non-beneficiaries) within participating communities takes part in a Business Connectivity Intervention (BCI). The purpose of the BCI is to improve business outcomes by addressing information frictions that small firms face through a low-cost information sharing activity. In particular, BCI takes place at the community level. Randomly selected participants from 8 different (also randomly selected) communities are invited to an in-person meeting at a convenient location within their community where they are split into groups of about 5 members each. Transportation and food expenses are paid for. Each group, under the guidance of a moderator who asks questions and encourages participants to share information, meets for an hour to discuss business challenges. The group continues to meet in the presence of the same moderator once per week over the five following weeks, but this time through a conference call. Discussion topics include sales strategies and business growth amongst others. Finally, participants who attend all the sessions are awarded with an incentive of USD 1 in the form of mobile money.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.