Climbing up the career ladder: An examination of gender differences in successive challenge seeking
How to cite
Kulle, Anna-Corinna; Schumacher, Stefanie. 2023. "Climbing up the career ladder: An examination of gender differences in successive challenge seeking." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012743. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12743-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
While many companies have achieved a close to 50:50 gender split in recruiting intake, the progression along the career path for women and men is different. Multiple studies show that both women’s promotion and retention rates are lower than men’s, resulting in a widening gender gap at higher career levels. Possible explanations may be related to discriminatory issues, differences in lifestyle choices, or differences in preferences. Well-documented preferences that may partially explain observed differences in economic outcomes include gender differences in competitiveness and challenge seeking. The aim of this study is to understand if women and men who self-select into working on a challenging task differ with respect to their challenge persistence. Do women who seek a challenge in the first place behave similarly to men if the difficulty level further increases that is, a second challenge is proposed? To answer this question, we conduct an online experiment on Prolific. The focus of this study is to observe the behavior of initial challenge seekers if they are confronted with a second subsequent challenge. In line with previous research, we also assess if gender differences exist at the initial challenge seeking decision point. We extend this field of research by analyzing if gender differences continue to persist among the original challenge seekers when they are confronted with a subsequent challenge. We also analyze if challenge seeking increases for participants who did not choose the challenge in stage 2, when they are given a second opportunity to enter the same challenge in stage 3.
Intervention
no interventions, see experimental design section
Experimental design
The experiment has three stages in which participants work on a real-effort task. They receive a base rate payment as well as a bonus payment for one of the three experimental stages. The stage for the bonus payment is randomly selected at the end of the experiment. The potentially paid-out bonus piece-rate remuneration at each stage is linked to each selected level of task difficulty and increases with increasing levels of difficulty.
In the first stage of the experiment, all participants work on easy tasks (difficulty level 1). After an initial working period (stage 1), they are offered to take a challenge and can decide whether they want to keep working on easy tasks or instead want to work on harder tasks (difficulty level 1 vs. 2) in the second stage 2. After stage 2, participants who chose to work on the hard task will be presented with the opportunity of a second challenge: For stage 3, they can select if they want to keep working on hard tasks or instead want to work on very hard tasks (difficulty level 2 vs. 3). Participants who decided against a challenge in the first choice (stage 2) will in stage 3 again be presented with the same challenge for a second time (difficulty level 1 vs 2). This design allows us to analyze continuous challenge seeking behavior for participants who chose a challenge for stage 2. It also allows us to analyze if challenge seeking increases for participants who chose no challenge in stage 2, when they are given a second opportunity to enter the challenge.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.