Evaluating the impact of alternative interventions to improve adoption of digital innovations by smallholder farmers in Egypt.

How to cite

Abdelaziz, Fatma; Bulte, Erwin Hendricus; Abay, Kibrom. 2023. "Evaluating the impact of alternative interventions to improve adoption of digital innovations by smallholder farmers in Egypt.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012723. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12723-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Fatma Abdelaziz* , Erwin Hendricus Bulte , Kibrom Abay

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012723
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12723-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-07-01 – 2024-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12723

Abstract

Digital innovations could facilitate access to markets and smallholder commercialization through the following ways: (1) reduce communication and information costs; (2) improve farmers’ knowledge and know- how about market options and prices; (3) improve access to input and output markets; (4) enable and build social networks and connections; (5) facilitate the delivery of other services associated with agricultural markets such as credits and finance; (6) improve management of input and output supply chains; (7) increase communication linkages with other stakeholders involved in agricultural marketing. Despite these advantages that digital innovations could offer, their adoption remains low and heterogenous, especially in Africa, where agricultural markets remain underdeveloped (e.g., Abate et al., 2023; Aker and Cariolle, 2023). Despite the proliferation of digital tools targeting smallholder farmers in recent years in Africa, the vast majority of these remained at pilot stages, with limited evidence of successful scaling and limited impacts to transform agricultural markets.

There exists several demand and supply-side factors that may explain the low adoption of digital innovations and associated heterogeneities across smallholder farmers in Africa. From a supply perspective, this low adoption could be due to several factors, including but not limited to insufficient public and private investment in complementary infrastructure, unsustainable business models, and asynchronous pace of change (Abate et al., 2023). The demand side factors may include: lack of digital literacy, lack of context-specific needs assessment, and digital divide and more importantly accessibility and usability as well as user trust and confidence. However, we lack empirically grounded evidence on alternative and cost-effective interventions to improve adoption and scale-up of digital innovations in various settings. In particular, empirical evidence on most effective strategies to improve access and usability of digital agricultural innovations to smallholders with limited level of literacy remains scarce.

Taking Egypt as a case study, the Egyptian market has an array of innovative digital agricultural tools that offer different services to farmers such as sourcing inputs, providing post-harvest and logistical support, to accessing market information and selling crops online. However, the uptake of these technologies has been quite low, as Egyptian farmers lack the awareness of the benefits of digital tools and can easily get excluded from this agricultural digital revolution due to a lack of accessible training (OBG, 2022; AGBI, 2023). This project aims to test alternative interventions to promote the adoption of digital agricultural innovations in Egypt.

Intervention

The alternative interventions we launch and evaluate in this project are part of the German Corporation for International Cooperation (GIZ)’s Agricultural Innovation Project (AIP). The AIP seeks to promote the use of digital mobile apps to smallholder farmers to increase their incomes. Accordingly, the AIP project of GIZ designed various digital promotion strategies to promote the adoption of digital innovations. These interventions are meant to encourage and enable smallholder access and use of agricultural digital mobile applications. The AIP project and hence these interventions focused on two governorates in Egypt: Minya and Benisuef .
The International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) partnered with GIZ to redesign some of these digital promotion strategies and eventually evaluate them using rigorous impact evaluation methods.
1- Digital literacy training through Trainers of Trainees (TOT) sessions
2- Pre-recorded community play videos
3- Real Live Community Play

Experimental design

The intervention will follow a randomized control trial design. The randomization takes place at the farmer/ individual level. The invitation of eligible farmers to participate in different kinds of digital support schemes in each farmer organization will be led by the active 30 farmer organizations in Minya and Benisuef, that GIZ have partnered with under the GIZ AIP project.
Following the farmer data received from each FO, a baseline phone survey took place between July 1st-Sepetmeber 7th 2023, a total of 4000 surveys were covered in Minya and Beni Suef. After ruling out respondents that do not assume farming as their main occupation, we were left with a total of 3350 respondents; 2400 of which have access to smart phones and the remaining 950 do not.
For the 2400 farmers that own smart phones, they will be eligible to receive a package of interventions to encourage the use and uptake of existing digital tools. The 2400 farmers from the different farmer organizations will be randomly assigned into three treatment arms, based on the type of treatment/ type of digital promotional strategy they receive. These farmers will be interviewed at midline and endline. These interventions/ dissemination methods include:
 Control Group: no intervention.
 Group A: Digital App Literacy training sessions
 Group B: Pre-recorded community play videos + Digital App Literacy training sessions (Training sessions will be provided, but here trainees will see video of play before the training)
 Group C: Real Live Community Plays + Digital App Literacy training sessions (Training sessions will be provided, but here trainees will see the actual play before the training)

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization was done at the farmer level using the baseline data and after excluding those farmers without smartphone and those whose main occupation is not farming.
Randomization unit
Farmer
Clusters
Treatment was not clustered, but randomization was stratified. Number of clusters by treatment arm: Control: 573 Farmers T1 (Group A): 601 Farmers T2 (Group B): 578 Farmers T3 (Group C): 649 Farmers
Observations
2401 farmers (based on baseline survey data)
Arms
Number of clusters by treatment arm: Control: 573 Farmers T1 (Group A): 601 Farmers T2 (Group B): 578 Farmers T3 (Group C): 649 Farmers
Primary outcomes
1. Participation in digital literacy training 2. Awareness of digital agricultural tools 3. Uptake of digital tools 4. Digital literacy knowledge test scores 5. Adoption and utilization of digital agricultural tools for marketing purposes 6. Market participation and commercialization behavior and associated outcomes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords