Gender Bias in Career Advice
How to cite
Arslan, Cansın; Hauser, Oliver; Smith, Sarah. 2023. "Gender Bias in Career Advice." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012717. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12717-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Women are underrepresented in many technical and scientific subjects at university including Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics (STEM) and Economics. In the United Kingdom, women account for only 32% of Economics undergraduate students. Preferences for fields of study are largely formed before university and, among many others, stereotypes formed or reinforced before enrolment are important. One factor that likely influences subject choices is recommendations that students receive from career advisers about university subjects. However, we know little about to what extent career advice is potentially (gender) biased. If such biases exist, one way to reduce them is through training and informing career advisers about those pitfalls. This project aims to fill this gap in knowledge by shedding light on the university subject recommendations made by career advisers to secondary school students leading up to their decision of what subject to study at university.
This project seeks to understand to what extent career advisers are potentially (gender) biased in their recommendations, such that they might be more likely to recommend gender-stereotypical subjects to students. We intend to have a better understanding of the subject recommendations that career advisers make to secondary school students and explore if information provision about gender bias in Economics can reduce gender-stereotypical recommendations. To this end, we will first collect recommendations from career advisers and ask them to complete an Implicit Association Test (IAT) focusing on bias related to subjects through an online survey. Next, we will run an online workshop for career advisers and inform them about (gender bias in) Economics and reveal their IAT results. We aim to evaluate the effects of this workshop on recommendations in a follow-up survey.
Intervention
The intervention is the variation in content of a workshop aimed at improving career advice delivered through Zoom. All workshop participants (careers advisers) complete a baseline survey as part of the registration form for the workshop. Registered participants are then randomly assigned to either a treatment or a control group.
Careers advisers in the treatment group complete an Implicit-Association Test (IAT) on gender-science during the baseline survey and are subsequently invited to a workshop, in which they are informed about Economics as a subject in general and then about gender discrepancies in Economics and the potential role of bias (of career advisers, among others) that could facilitate such segregation by subject areas at university level. Careers advisers will then receive personalized feedback (e.g. potential implicit bias) from the Gender-Science IAT.
In contrast, careers advisers in the control group complete an alternative IAT on US presidents during the baseline survey and are subsequently invited to a workshop, in which they do not receive information about gender bias but instead they are informed about stereotypes about subjects and Economics as a subject in general (similar information to the treatment group). Control group participants will be informed about the results from the Presidents IAT.
The length of the two workshops across treatments will be roughly equal, so that the only difference between the two conditions is the type of IAT (gender-science versus presidents) and the content of the workshop (a focus on gender differences and the role of gender bias in the treatment versus the role of stereotypes about university subjects in the control).
As part of the follow-up survey, the treatment will then be evaluated in how it affects careers advisers’ university subject recommendations based on (real) student profiles that are shown to participants are the end of the workshop. Student profiles include students’ A-level subjects, grades, and sector and work preferences and career interests.
Experimental design
We will randomly assign male and female fake names to each student profile to which careers advisers will make recommendations. Careers advisers will be presented with the names and avatars (only varying the gender) of the students along with A-level subjects, grades, and sector and work interests. It will be common knowledge that the profile names were changed to protect anonymity of students. We aim to assign 10 female and 10 male students (20 students in total) to each adviser.
We will collect baseline recommendations for 10 students and also ask advisers if they are willing to revise their decisions in the follow-up survey. We will also ask them to make recommendations for 10 new students. In total we will analyze recommendations made to 20 students per adviser. In the initial trial, we randomly assign 120 careers advisers into a treatment and a control group (60 each). The intervention follows the setup outlined under Interventions above. The outcomes will be as described in the Primary and Secondary Outcomes above.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.