Agricultural adaptation: Scaling-up the adoption of rainwater harvesting techniques

How to cite

Jack, B. Kelsey; Aker, Jenny; Maigari, Malam Assane. 2023. "Agricultural adaptation: Scaling-up the adoption of rainwater harvesting techniques." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012707. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12707-4.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

B. Kelsey Jack* , Jenny Aker , Malam Assane Maigari

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012707
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12707-4.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-01-01 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Niger ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12707

Abstract

In situ rainwater-harvesting (RWH) techniques have the potential to increase agricultural yields in the face of low and erratic rainfall, reversing land degradation and combatting desertification. We propose to study the scale-up of an intervention that has been shown to increase the adoption of RWH techniques in Niger, with relevance for most degraded land in the Sahel. A randomized control trial (RCT) conducted in Niger between 2018 and 2021 found that training alone was highly effective at increasing adoption. This, in turn, led to increases in agricultural revenue of around 0.14 s.d. up to three years after the initial training. This project will build upon the completed RCT to scale the adoption of RWH techniques in Niger, with three distinct contributions relative to the completed work. First, it will focus on expanding the adoption of two techniques (demi-lunes and zai) that are appropriate for severely degraded soils in Niger. Second, it will assess the relative costs and benefits of using in-person versus remote sensing to monitor initial and sustained adoption. Third, it will investigate whether larger trainings, which are cheaper to implement, deliver similar adoption impacts.

Intervention

The basic intervention follows the training program described in Aker and Jack (2023), which involved training farmers on a specific rainwater harvesting technique (demi-lunes) and collected data on adoption outcomes using in person measurement. This trial introduces village-level variation in training and monitoring protocols as described below. The overarching study objective is to refine the training design to facilitate further scale up by the Ministry of Environment.

Experimental design

Villages were assigned to a control group or one of the treatment arms. Three main cross cutting treatments are assigned at the village level.

1) Rainwater harvesting technique:

Farmers are trained on where and how to construct rainwater harvesting techniques. Specifically, villages are trained on (a) demi-lunes, (b) zai or (c) both. The training order was randomized among villages trained in both techniques.

2) Monitoring approach

Villages were assigned to receive either prior information about monitoring or not. We originally intended to assign households to receive in-person monitoring or not (with all households being monitored remotely), but, based upon prior remote sensing models, we realized that this was not feasible. As a result, all households will receive in-person monitoring, and the monitoring will either be being announced or not. All households in will be visited by an enumerator and Ministry staff to record adoption in May-June 2024, just before planting. The monitors will visit fields where adoption occurred and count the number and spatial extent (i.e., perimeter) of adoption. Villages assigned to “informed” monitoring are informed of the monitoring protocol at the time of the training. This announcement was made during the end-of-training survey, rather than as a public and village-level announcement.

All treatment villages are monitored remotely, by satellite. Additional detail on satellite-based monitoring is discussed below. Villages assigned to “unannounced” monitoring were not informed about this type of monitoring (as satellite data collection is not at the discretion of the research team), nor were they informed that they would receiving a monitoring visit later in the year.

3) Training size

In small-training villages, only the sampled 16 households are invited to attend the training. In large-training villages, the sample 16 households are invited to attend the training, as well as all households interested. In both cases, invitations are done by the village chief.

4) Goal setting

In addition to the village-level treatment variation, one additional treatment is introduced as part of the training. Randomly-selected households are asked to set a goal for adoption as part of a brief survey administered during the training.

A) Goal – self-select: Households are asked if they would like to set a goal of how much land to cover in demi-lunes or zai or both. The decision to set a goal and the goal are recorded by the enumerator.

B) Goal – requested: Households were asked how many demi-lunes or zai they would like to adopt. This is recorded by the enumerator.

C) Goal – control: No goal set and recorded by enumerator.

In villages where monitoring was announced in advance, the timing of the goal setting treatments are varied to either before or after the in person monitoring is announced.

5) Call-In Hotline

In an effort to determine if and how agricultural extension can assist farmers with adoption, in the second year, we will randomly assign a free, call-in hotline for farmers. Villages will be stratified by geography and treatment status and randomly assigned to the hotline (100 villages) or none (306 villages).

Design details

Randomization method
Treatments were assigned within geographic strata (department) using the randtreat command in stata and assigning misfits independently across strata using treatment weights (wstrata). All village level treatments were block randomized, for a fully saturated design.
Randomization unit
Village
Clusters
The sample consists of 406 villages in the Maradi and Zinder regions of Niger. The village sample was constructed during a listing visit starting in December 2022. To be eligible for the study, villages needed to simply have severely degraded land.
Observations
Within each eligible village, we conducted a census of all households with severely degraded land (which was self-reported). Amongst eligible households, we then randomly selected 16 households. The baseline survey was conducted immediately after the random sampling, whereby households were asked a number of questions. In addition, the team visited the household’s most severely degraded plot of land and took the GPS coordinates of the perimeter. Some villages did not have 16 households with severely degraded land; as a result, some villages had fewer respondents. Thus, the intended sample was 6,406 respondents, with a final sample of 6,403 respondents. A spillover sample of 6 additional households was also selected from the randomly ordered list of eligible households. The spillover households were not part of the baseline survey.
Arms
Number of clusters by treatment: (Note: "remote" means that households were not informed of monitoring in advance, whereas "in-person" means that households were informed of in-person monitoring in advance). Control, remote sensing 21 Control, in-person 21 DL, Remote, 16 30 DL, Remote, All 30 DL, In-person, 16 29 DL, In-person, All 32 Zai, Remote, 16 30 Zai, Remote, All 31 Zai, In-person, 16 29 Zai, In-person, All 31 Both, Remote, 16 30 Both, Remote, All 32 Both, In-person, 16 29 Both, In-person, All 31 Total 406
Primary outcomes
Rainwater harvesting adoption, measured in two ways as described below
Secondary outcomes
Agricultural productivity Land degradation, soil type and soil quality Climate resilience

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords