Morality Meets Risk: Excuse-Driven Risk Preference Predictions and Gender Stereotypes
How to cite
DONG, Wanxin; Zheng, Jiakun. 2024. "Morality Meets Risk: Excuse-Driven Risk Preference Predictions and Gender Stereotypes." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012685. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12685-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Recent research suggests that individuals often justify egoistic behavior by leveraging uncertainties, resulting in excuse-driven risk preferences. However, it remains unclear whether individuals can recognize the excuse-driven behaviors of others. This research investigates the ability of individuals to predict others' behaviors in risky decision-making scenarios and examines the influence of gender stereotypes on their predictions. In our laboratory experiment, participants will complete a decision task and a prediction task. The decision task aims to assess participants’ excuse-driven risk preferences, while the prediction task focuses on their predictions about others’ behaviors in similar risk scenarios. In each task, participants evaluate risky payoffs and certain amounts for themselves or their partners with or without interpersonal trade-offs. We hypothesize that individuals can anticipate others’ excuse-driven behaviors. When predicting the degree of others' excuses, the respondents may rely on a combination of their excuse-driven risk preferences and gender stereotypes.
Intervention
The experiment consists of two parts and adopts a within-subject design. The first part is a decision task for subjects to elicit their excuse-driven risk preferences. Participants first complete a normalization price list including 16 binary decisions between 30 yuan for themselves and some amounts for their partners. Participants then make binary decisions between riskless amounts and risky lotteries for themselves or their partners in 12 price lists. Across the 12 price lists, participants will encounter two types of lotteries (self-lotteries and others-lotteries), two types of valuations (self-valuations and others-valuations), and 3 different probabilities, i.e. {75%, 50%, 25%}. Price lists will be presented in a random order for each participant.
The second part is a prediction task to investigate participants’ predictions of others’ excuse-driven behavior under the same risk scenarios. Participants will predict which choice they think their prediction target may make if their target is either male or female. The gender is randomly selected but remains the same for participants after randomization.
The decision and prediction tasks are presented in random order at the individual level.
Experimental design
Building upon the work of Dong and Zheng (2023), we will conduct a laboratory experiment consisting of two main parts: a decision task and a prediction task. The decision task will assess the excuse-driven risk preferences of subjects, while the prediction task will evaluate their predictions of others’ excuse-driven behavior under the same risk scenarios. In the decision task, participants first complete a normalization price list including 16 binary decisions between 30 yuan for themselves and some amounts for their partners. Participants then complete binary decisions between riskless amounts and risky lotteries for themselves or their partners in 12 price lists. We can estimate their certainty equivalences of different lotteries based on their responses to risk, which reflect their excuse-driven risk preferences. In the prediction task, participants face the same decision tasks as in the decision task. Instead of making decisions for themselves, participants predict the responses to these tasks by other participants in their session. Their prediction target may be male or female, determined randomly. We will also collect subjects' genders to investigate the gender differences in predicting others’ behaviors.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.