Impacts of sharing research findings with study participants: Evidence from a field experiment
How to cite
Duong, Tien Ha My; Rieger, Matthias; Pham, Khanh Nam; Nguyen, Thi Tam Hien.
2023. "Impacts of sharing research findings with study participants: Evidence from a field experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012658.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12658-1.2
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
Tien Ha My Duong*
, Matthias Rieger
, Khanh Nam Pham
, Thi Tam Hien Nguyen
While research dissemination traditionally focuses on other academics, policymakers, and the public, social scientists increasingly recognize the obligation of sharing results with research participants. When research findings are shared, impacts are typically assessed qualitatively rather than quantitatively. In the context of a study on health- and diet-related beliefs and knowledge among parents and children in urban Vietnam, we aim to explore the relationship between the delivery of research findings to study participants and their health perceptions, diet perceptions, and research acceptance.
Intervention
Participants will be randomly assigned to one of three groups: 1. Control group involves those who receive general public information on weight and nutrition; 2. Treatment group 1 involves those who receive research findings from the broadly defined scientific literature and from the baseline survey data to which they contributed; and 3. Treatment group 2 involves those who receive research findings from the broadly defined scientific literature and from the baseline survey data to which they contributed, as well as child-specific comparisons with baseline survey summary findings.
Experimental design
Participants will be randomly assigned to one of three groups and will complete two surveys at home (the baseline survey and the follow-up survey): - In the baseline survey, all participants will answer the same questions. - After about 2-3 weeks after the intervention, they will conduct a follow-up survey.
We will also qualitatively interview a small subset of parents from all three groups about 2 months after the follow-up survey to explore their experience with the study and better understand potential effects.
Design details
Randomization method
Subjects will be randomly assigned to three groups. Randomization is conducted using STATA.
We will check randomization by testing for balance on outcomes at baseline as well as basic socio-demographics.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
6 schools with treated and control groups in each.
Observations
We will survey a total of 1500 primary schoolchildren in control and treatment units from 6 schools in HCMC at baseline and then again after about 2-3 weeks after the intervention.
Arms
There are three experimental groups, each group includes 500 parents/children from 6 schools.
Primary outcomes
Please see details in the attached file.
Expected Effects of the Treatments in the Longer Term
The longer-term impacts of the treatments on all primary outcomes are expected to be statistically weaker and quantitatively smaller than those in the short-term because respondents will likely not remember all the information they received. Related to this, we will explore if there are differences in self-reported participation rates in activities and we will also compare participation rates in the first and second follow-up surveys. Further, consistent with what we found in the first follow-up survey, we expect that improvements in health/weight perceptions (if any) will be lower than those in dietary behavior/perceptions and physical activity behavior/perceptions (if any).
Specifically for the weight perception variables, we will collect updated school-measured height/weight data. We will use these data to explore whether there is any improvement in a child’s BMI one year after the intervention. Moreover, we will compare parents’ assessments of their child’s weight status with assessments based on updated school-measured data to determine whether changes in weight perception are maintained over time. A priori we do not expect to detect an effect of the treatments on child’s BMI unless we find strong persistence of the treatment effects on our primary outcomes in the longer term.
We also predict that parental donations will differ less across groups. There will be less intense contact with respondents in the second follow-up survey relative to last year (when we conducted the baseline survey, the intervention, and the first follow-up survey). Therefore, social desirability in the parental donation response will likely be muted. We will replicate only one of the two dictator frames due to a limited budget, namely the one that asks “Out of the 100,000 VND you receive, how much do you want to donate to conduct a similar study?”.
Secondary outcomes
Please see details in the attached file.
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.