The Analysis of Social Pressure via Text Message Campaigns on Prosocial Behaviors: Evidence from a Field Experiment on Iranian Blood Donation Behavior

How to cite

Valashani, Ali Amini. 2023. "The Analysis of Social Pressure via Text Message Campaigns on Prosocial Behaviors: Evidence from a Field Experiment on Iranian Blood Donation Behavior." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012648. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12648-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ali Amini Valashani*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012648
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12648-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2023-12-01 – 2023-12-15
Countries
Iran (Islamic Republic of) (Tehran)
JEL codes
C93, D64, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12648

Abstract

Blood has no other synthetic alternative. Therefore, the only way to supply it is by donation, which requires motivation. Based on the literature, social pressure is one of those incentives that proved to be effective. However, this comes at the cost of disutility for donors and hiring solicitors. Text message campaigns, on the other hand, are fast, less costly, and more inclusive. Since the pressure exerted is indirect, it raises questions about its effectiveness. So, we have designed a field experiment to evaluate whether exerting social pressure via text message campaigns can motivate significantly more people to donate blood or not.

Intervention

Sending text messages to the treatment group.

Experimental design

The sample of the experiment consists of 4,876 Tehran residents who are stratified by their observable characteristics available in the data set, including gender and education. In addition, those with an age out of the standard age bracket – 18 to 60 – of blood donation are omitted. Members of each stratum are then randomly assigned to one of the three groups as follows: First, subjects in the control group receive no text messages. However, their blood donation behavior is monitored during the experiment. Second, the treatment group is split into two separate groups. One-half receive the regular text message sent already by IBTO – we call this group "regular treatment" – while the other half receive a text message exerting pressure on them to donate blood – this group is called "pressure treatment."

The two treatment groups are employed to check, first, whether the text message campaign is capable of persuading people to donate blood in general or not. Furthermore, to assess the hypothesis that more people contribute under pressure. One might ask how to be sure if the text message is actually putting people under pressure. Taking that concern into consideration, we are going to survey a randomly selected class of graduate students to opt for the best alternative among three suggested text messages implying social pressure. Consequently, the text message with the most votes is designated to be sent. Since we surmise that the vast majority of graduate students at Sharif University of Technology have the potential to think critically, the pressure induced by the text could be as maximal as possible.

After the most suitable text is chosen, we will only send that to the subjects in the "pressure treatment" group. The subjects in the "regular treatment" group are to receive the routine IBTO text. In order to make sure the three groups of this experiment are not significantly different from each other in terms of observable characteristics and, thus, causing selection bias, we stratify them based on gender and education. One reason to use gender is the low blood donation rate among women in Iran; Only 5 percent of blood donors are women in Iran, so having a group with a female majority would likely distort the results. Besides, since education plays an essential role in blood donation and our sample is not so diverse, with more than half of the subjects holding Bachelor's degrees, the chances of one group involving only Bachelor's holders are high. As a result, stratification is essential.

Design details

Randomization method
By computer, We stratified subjects by their observable characteristics available in the data set, including gender and education. Then, one-third of the subjects in each stratum are randomly allocated to every group.
Randomization unit
We stratified subjects by their observable characteristics available in the data set, including gender and education. Then, one-third of the subjects in each stratum are randomly allocated to every group.
Clusters
1 city
Observations
4,876 individuals
Arms
1625 individuals in the "regular treatment" group, 1625 individuals in the "Pressure treatment" group
Primary outcomes
The blood donation status of the subjects

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords