Gender Discrimination in (Online) Negotiations
How to cite
Adler, Katharina. 2023. "Gender Discrimination in (Online) Negotiations." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012633. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12633-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
I study gender discrimination in online negotiations. To do so, I post simple classified advertisements on the largest platform for such classifieds in Germany and collect offers. I then ask for a discount and randomly sign the replies with a male or a female name, respectively. In the negotiations, I try to isolate statistical discrimination by using two treatment arms. The first treatment consists of the name only, whereas the second one signals knowledgability with the topic and negotiation experience. I study how often potential partners send a lower second offer as a reaction to the initiation of a negotiation and, if they send one, how large the discount is. Since all communication takes place via chat, I can apply Natural Language Processing (NLP) methods and text analysis methods to study potentially different communication with women and men.
Intervention
I study gender discrimination in online negotiations on a classified ads platform. I post classified advertisements on the largest platform for such classifieds in Germany and collect offers. I then ask for a discount and randomly sign the replies with a male or a female
name, respectively. In the negotiations, I try to isolate statistical discrimination by using two treatment arms. The first treatment consists of the name only, whereas the second one signals knowledgability with the topic and negotiation experience. I study how often potential partners send a lower second offer as a reaction to the initiation of a negotiation and, if they send one, how large the discount is. Since all communication takes place via chat, I can apply Natural Language Processing (NLP) methods, text analysis methods, and potentially third-party ratings to study potentially different communication with women and men.
Experimental design
I post generic job advertisements on the largest online platform for classified advertisements in Germany. These ads usually describe small tasks to be done in someone's home. I will post a painting job for two rooms in an apartment. The ad does not contain information on the gender of the "employer'' posting it and asks potential contractual partners to send an offer. I will apply my treatment to all platform users who send an offer. If users send a first message that does not contain an offer, I ask them to send one (the message asking for an offer does not reveal the "employer's'' gender).
Respondents receive one out of two possible replies: 1) an inquiry for a discount or 2) an inquiry for a discount including a justification for the inquiry. I randomly vary the gender of the name with which I sign the inquiries (i.e., gender is the treatment). Given that potential respondents do not know the gender of the person who posted the ad until they communicate (i.e., until after they made an initial offer), I do not expect variation in initial offers conditional on treatment, as this only occurs at a later stage. Different reactions to negotiation attempts by gender might have two reasons: Discrimination could be taste-based, i.e., negotiation partners have a distaste against negotiations with a particular gender and thus refuse to accept a lower price suggested by, e.g., a woman. The other case in which the observed discrimination is statistical is if potential contractors believe women and men to have different degrees of knowledgeability about the posted task or different negotiation abilities. I tackle this question by sending out reply 2) which contains information about how well the person who posted the ad is informed about, e.g., the complexity of the task, how much it should cost to do the job, and the way negotiations take place on the platform.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.