Perceived labor market competition and out-group prejudice: Experimental evidence from refugee and host populations in Malaysia

How to cite

Ghorpade, Yashodhan; Gasten, Anna; Maystadt, Jean-François; Jasmin, Alyssa. 2023. "Perceived labor market competition and out-group prejudice: Experimental evidence from refugee and host populations in Malaysia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012624. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12624-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yashodhan Ghorpade* , Anna Gasten , Jean-François Maystadt , Alyssa Jasmin

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012624
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12624-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-11-08 – 2024-03-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
J6, C93, D91, O15, J01
Secondary IDs
NA
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12624

Abstract

The process of refugees achieving labor market integration is a crucial step in their path towards self-sufficiency and assimilation within the local community. Nonetheless, this integration can encounter significant challenges, particularly in countries such as Malaysia, which have not ratified the 1951 Refugee Convention. In Malaysia, refugees and asylum seekers lack legal rights to formal employment. The official stance of the Malaysian Government categorizes UNHCR registered refugees and asylum seekers as 'illegal' or 'undocumented migrants'. Such an environment can fuel resentment, mistrust, and discrimination between refugees and the host population, especially when it may incorrectly portray refugees as competitors for employment and economic resources. This context may also lead refugees to compete with each other and hold differentiated attitudes even among refugee groups.
Our study aims to assess the impact of perceptions of labor market competition on out-group attitudes. To do this, we employ a randomized questionnaire module, which presents survey respondents with narratives about a fictitious individual. This individual can either belong to the in-group or different out-groups, and we randomly highlight differences or commonalities in labor market characteristics between the respondent and the fictitious individual.

Intervention

Our study consists of a randomized questionnaire module that will be implemented as part of a large representative survey. The questionnaire will be conducted with registered refugees and their neighboring host communities across four states in Malaysia, exploring facets such as living conditions, labor market characteristics, and interactions between refugees and hosts.
We are targeting refugee populations and host community members living in close proximity to each other in the regions of Kuala Lumpur, Selangor, Penang and Johor in Malaysia.

Our survey sample will cover approximately 2,800 refugee households (including 1,000 Rohingya refugee households, 1,000 non-Rohingya refugee households from Myanmar, 800 refugee households from other countries) and around 1,400 host community households across 34 mukims (districts) in 4 states of Malaysia.

As part of this survey, respondents will be randomly exposed to different narrative vignettes about a fictitious member of the in-group or two different out-groups with identical or different labor characteristics.

In the case where participants are assigned to an out-group narrative, we distinguish between "close" and "distant" out-groups. For respondents in the refugee group, they are presented with narratives featuring either a refugee from the same identity (in-group), a refugee from a different identity (out-group A, close), or a Malaysian individual (out-group B, distant). Conversely, respondents in the Malaysian (local hosts) group will encounter narratives about a fictitious individual who is either another Malaysian (in-group), a refugee born in Malaysia (out-group A, close), or a refugee born in another country (out-group B, distant). This grouping approach allows us to delve into a unique aspect of the Malaysian context. Given the protracted refugee situation without easy pathways to legal residency or employment rights in Malaysia, there exists a notable number of individuals who were born in Malaysia but still carry a "refugee" status as second- or third-generation refugees. For refugees, our focus lies in investigating biases within the diverse refugee community and gaining insights into their perceptions of individuals who, like them, possess refugee status but belong to different nationalities.
The second dimension of randomization within the vignette relates to the fictitious character’s labor market characteristics, such as their occupation. Our experiment randomly varies this information across respondents so that the occupation either matches or is different from the main occupation exerted by the respondent’s household.

The study evaluates the interplay between perceived labor market competition and out-group discrimination. Based on the outcomes of our experiment, we aim to analyze the prevalent attitudes towards the out-group among hosts and refugees in Malaysia, and assess the extent to which these attitudes are influenced by different concepts of the “out-group”. Moreover, we will ask whether perceived labor market competition is an important driver of discriminatory attitudes towards the out-group.

The intervention in Malaysia is planned to start on November, 8th 2023 and end on March, 31st 2024.

Experimental design

Our experimental intervention is embedded in a survey questionnaire focused on labor market outcomes and interactions between refugees and host communities in Malaysia.

As part of this experiment, respondents are randomly assigned to six equally sized treatment groups. Each respondent will listen to a single narrative about a fictitious individual who is either from the in-group or the out-group (out-group A (close); or out-group B (distant)) and sharing or not the main occupation exerted by the respondent’s household.
T1: In-group; same labor market characteristics (17%)
T2: In-group; different labor market characteristics (17%)
T3: Out-group A; same labor market characteristics (17%)
T4: Out-group A; different labor market characteristics (17%)
T5: Out-group B; same labor market characteristics (17%)
T6: Out-group B; different labor market characteristics (17%)

The experiment (module 11) is implemented towards the end of the survey. Its content is based on information from the labor market module (module 8) as well as the group membership of the respondent, which is gathered in the initial interview questions (S0.3). The experiment is directly preceded by a module on refugee-host relations (module 10), which serves as a balance check of the randomization process and provides a range of heterogeneous dimensions for descriptively testing the contact hypothesis within the experiment.

After the vignette is read out loud to the respondents, they are asked to respond to questions about the fictitious individual, notably concerning perceived labor market competition and general attitudes (prejudice, discrimination).

The purpose of our study is to better understand discriminatory attitudes towards the out- and in-group and to gauge the extent to which negative/positive perceptions of refugees among host communities as well as obstacles/drivers to integration among refugees are driven by the perception that both groups are competing or not in the labor market.

Design details

Randomization method
Computer-based during the survey
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
34 mukims in 4 Malaysian states. The choice is based on random sampling involving Probability proportionate to size.
Observations
2800 refugee households and 1400 host community households The experiment is part of a large household survey. While the initial sections on socio-demographics and labor market characteristics collect information for all or at least several randomly chosen individuals (answered by a single respondent on behalf of the other members), the experimental module is administered with a single respondent per household. Consequently, we do not have to cluster our standard errors at the household level and we are avoiding spillover effects. In an ideal scenario, the number of experimental observations will match the number of households in the sample. We are however expecting a certain attrition and non-response rate given the refugee-host context. Since randomization is implemented at the beginning of the experimental module and the sensitivity of the experimental content is generally low and comparable across all six treatment groups, we expect attrition to be random, and proportionally distributed across treatment groups. Another correction we will make to our sample for relevance is that part of our main analysis (Hypothesis 3, 4 and 5) can exclusively rely on individuals whose household is currently working. For these regression analyses, we are excluding households for which all members are out of the labor force, since the aim of triggering different degrees of perceived labor market competition with the vignette is not viable for them. Consequently, the sample size for which we will be able to run this analysis is likely to reduce slightly, especially among the refugee population who is more likely to be out of the labor force.
Arms
The whole sample is split into 6 treatment arms. When disregarding attrition and non-response, as well as individuals whose household is out-of-the-labor-force, we are left with 700 respondents per treatment arm. To account for the distinct perspectives of refugees and hosts, our final analysis will be conducted separately for these two groups, yielding approximately 230 host respondents per treatment group and 470 refugee respondents per treatment group.
Primary outcomes
Our primary measures of interest are: (1) Measures of prejudice towards the fictitious individual (based on a prejudice index that can be split into three dimensions: private, social, and work-related interactions) (2) Behavioral stakes, such as the willingness to actually share the phone number and interact with the character described in the vignette (3) Discriminatory attitudes with respect to labor market participation of the fictitious individual
Secondary outcomes
We will examine the vignette's impact on increased perceptions of competition, when it features a character with the same occupation. We will additionally analyze heterogeneous effects based on (1) Socio-demographic characteristics of the respondent (gender, employment status, income level etc.) (2) Measures of past interactions (friendship, trust, economic and exchange networks) with the in- and out-group (3) Experienced ethnic discrimination by the respondent (4) Local characteristics, such as the density of refugees in the area and local labor market characteristics, which can serve as a measure of “actual” competition

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords