Is intent to migrate irregularly responsive to recent German policy adjustments?

How to cite

Ebert, Cara; Beber, Bernd; Sievert, Maximiliane. 2023. "Is intent to migrate irregularly responsive to recent German policy adjustments?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012573. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12573-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Cara Ebert* , Bernd Beber , Maximiliane Sievert

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012573
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12573-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-11-26 – 2024-06-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O15, F22, K37
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12573

Abstract

In the face of an increasing stock of refugees and irregular migrants in Germany, state governments together with the federal government have agreed on policies to reduce the financial and logistic costs associated with providing accommodation and other social welfare benefits to asylum seekers. In this project, we study the impact of the policy measures described in the agreement on the intent to migrate irregularly from Senegal. As the German political debate often revolves around the avoidance of irregular migration that is motivated by economic reasons, our study contributes to our understanding of whether the discussed and agreed policy measures can have such an impact on irregular migration. The asylum acceptance rate of Senegalese people in Germany was well below 10% in 2022, suggesting that many migrate who are not in search of refuge.

Intervention

We conduct a single choice experiment in which participants are presented with 3 migration policy profiles, containing 5 attributes---asylum chances, waiting time until asylum decision, application location, payment mode of government transfers during the application process, and waiting time until receipt of government benefits equivalent to those received by locals---each with two randomly varying values. The 5 attributes and 2 values result in 32 hypothetical combinations of policy profiles.

The participant is presented with a profile of randomly selected policy values and then asked to state their intent to migrate given the policy profile. In total, the participant is presented with three profiles. For a better understanding of the policy profiles they are visualized through icons shown on enumerators' tablets and on printouts. After the choices were made participants receive a short debrief. The procedure is:

(1) Introduction: "We will now show you three sets of policies that this European country could have in place. Given each set of policies, please indicate, how interested you would be in trying to migrate irregularly (traveling without prior approval) to this country? [0 = Not at all. 10 = Very.]"
(2) Profile 1, then: "Given this set of policies, how interested would you be in trying to migrate irregularly to this country? [0 = Not at all. 10 = Very.]''
(3) Profile 2, then: "Given this set of policies, how interested would you be in trying to migrate irregularly to this country? [0 = Not at all. 10 = Very.]"
(4) Profile 3, then: "Given this set of policies, how interested would you be in trying to migrate irregularly to this country? [0 = Not at all. 10 = Very.]"
(5) Debrief: "The scenarios presented are hypothetical and are based on current political measures and discussions in Europe. We recommend that you carefully inform yourself about the actual numbers and processes if you consider migrating."

Experimental design

The study is conducted with a total sample size of 1000 individuals in four cities of Senegal: Dakar, Kaolack, St.Louis and Ziguinchor. In Dakar, St. Louis and Ziguinchor male participants aged 18 to 40 of a previous data collection in these locations conducted in 2022 are followed up, with 334, 222 and 222 individuals respectively. These individuals were randomly sampled, within a random selection of quartiers/neighborhoods as primary sampling units. In Kaoloack a new sample of 222 males aged 18 to 40 will be created using a random walk selection procedure. Again, quartiers/neighborhoods serve as primary sampling units, within which a randomly selected set of individuals will be approached and asked for their participation. We focus on men aged 18--40 because this constitutes the demographic group in Senegal most likely to migrate, and we focus on these four cities because they are national and regional centers of migration.

See "Intervention" for details on the choice experiment. See "Randomization" for the choice experiments random assignment to attribute values.

Design details

Randomization method
We randomly assign three treatment profiles to each individual, with each profile consisting of five attributes that take on one of two possible values. Assignment is stratified by city. We use a re-randomization algorithm to ensure balance in subjects' age across all treatment profiles. Random assignment of the fully articulated set of treatment profiles ensures random assignment of values for a particular attribute that is exactly balanced across all other attributes, i.e., the randomly assigned values are uncorrelated across attributes. Each treatment profile is assigned at most once to each individual, i.e., subjects do not encounter the exact same profile multiple times. Overall and across subjects, each of the 32 treatment profiles is assigned the same (or nearly the same) number of times. This also means that each attribute value appears with the same frequency.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
1000 individuals.
Observations
Each of the 1000 participants is presented with three profiles, which means our sample for analysis consists of 3000 observations.
Arms
500 observations.
Primary outcomes
Intent to migrate irregularly

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords