Enhancing Employment Outcomes of Vocational School Graduates: A Pilot Intervention with Counselling and Training

How to cite

Boeri, Tito; Monti, Paola; Pellizzari, Michele; Fabbri, Alessandro; Fasola, Marika. 2023. "Enhancing Employment Outcomes of Vocational School Graduates: A Pilot Intervention with Counselling and Training." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012568. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12568-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Tito Boeri* , Paola Monti , Michele Pellizzari , Alessandro Fabbri , Marika Fasola

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012568
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12568-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-09-01 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Italy ()
JEL codes
J64, J68
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12568

Abstract

Young people with low educational qualifications find it difficult to enter the labour market, especially in Italy. The problem of the transition from school to work is particularly serious for vocational school students, whose employment rates remain consistently lower than those of other school leavers.

The aim of this research is to test pilot interventions for vocational schools aimed at improving access to employment for young graduates. Specifically, the project aims at implement and evaluate the impact of two different activities: a job counselling program for students (Treatment A) and a training program for teachers (Treatment B), both provided by private employment agencies. Activities are designed for final-year vocational school students and their teachers.

Both of these proposed activities will include job search guidance, which will be delivered by specialized job coaches with expertise in supporting young job seekers and a deep understanding of the local labour markets. The professionals responsible for conducting the counselling and training sessions will be supplied by Adecco, a leading private employment agency in Italy.

During the proposed activities, job coaches – in collaboration with or through teachers – will provide practical information about the employment prospects of the students, the importance of specific skills, how to write an effective CV, how to search for a job, how to apply for a job and how to present themselves in a job interview.

We randomly select schools into participation in the project, and then into the two treatment and control group. Finally, among schools assigned to the student treatment we randomly select a school track out of the six eligible ones.

Intervention

The project aims to measure the impact of the two proposed interventions on the employment rates of students in the months following graduation, i.e. in the period of first entry in the labour market. To this end, a counterfactual evaluation of the programme will be implemented, involving a comparison between the students benefiting from counselling services or teacher training (treatment groups) and a
comparison group of students that did not participate in the intervention (control group). Students will be randomly assigned to the treatment arms and the control group.

Experimental design

The project aims to measure the impact of the two proposed interventions on the employment rates of students in the months following graduation, i.e. in the period of first entry in the labour market. To this end, a counterfactual evaluation of the programme will be implemented, involving a comparison between the students benefiting from counselling services or teacher training (treatment groups) and a
comparison group of students that did not participate in the intervention (control group). Students will be randomly assigned to the treatment arms and the control group.

More specifically, we plan to implement a three-armed RCT (Randomised Controlled Trial). This trial will involve comparing three groups: Treatment Arm A (providing counselling services for students), an inactive control, and an alternative Treatment Arm B (offering training for teachers).

Design details

Randomization method
Schools will be grouped into strata based on relevant characteristics, such as region, local labour market outcomes, school size. Within each stratum, we will randomly select a proportional number of schools to achieve a balanced representation in the final sample of approximately 120 schools. After this stratified selection, schools will be randomly divided into three equally-sized subgroups. We will review the characteristics of the selected schools within each subgroup to ensure balance. We will adjust the selection to minimize imbalances in relevant characteristics. Finally, each subgroup of schools will be randomly assigned to a treatment or control group. In schools assigned to the students Treatment, we will implement a random selection process to choose one of the eligible six vocational school tracks from the available options. Subsequently, we will implement job counselling services in a maximum of two final-year classes within that track. In other words, at least one of the selected classes will pertain to the chosen vocational school track. In schools assigned to the teacher Treatment, teachers will be invited to participate in an online training focusing on how to provide job counselling to their students. The training sessions will be primarily targeted to teachers in charge of orientation of final-year students, yet they may be open to other colleagues of the same school.
Randomization unit
We randomly select schools into participation in the project, and then into the two treatment and control group. Finally, among schools assigned to the student treatment we randomly select a school track out of the six eligible ones.
Clusters
120 schools
Observations
At least 700 students per group of schools.
Arms
40 schools Treatment A, 40 schools Treatment B, 40 schools Control group.
Primary outcomes
The expected result of the experiment is a better integration of young graduates from vocational schools into the labour market. The primary outcome of interest will be the employment rate and earnings. According to our evaluation design, we will be able to distinguish 3 groups of students. First, we will observe outcomes for students who will directly participate in counselling activities, i.e. in treated classes in schools where treatment A is implemented (group 1). Second, will observe outcomes for students whose teachers will be involved in training activities, i.e. in schools where treatment B is implemented (group 2). According to our research design, students in group 1 and group 2 do not overlap, as treatment A and B will be implemented in different schools. Third, we will observe outcomes for 'control' students who were randomly denied both treatments (group 3). Our design will allow us to assess the (possibly) different effects of the two interventions. For this purpose, all student groups involved in the experiment will be monitored throughout the duration of the program (to check participation and collect individual data) and in the months following their graduation, to track job search activities and employment outcomes. Information must be collected for both the treatment groups A and B, and for the control group. To this end, we plan to use different data sources. 1. Baseline and follow up surveys conducted with students We plan to conduct two surveys, one to be administered online to students before the start of the counselling programme (baseline survey) and one to be conducted a few months after graduation (follow up survey) via telephone and web interviews. The first survey will collect students’ sociodemographic information, as well as qualitative information on preferences and life plans. The follow-up survey will aim at monitoring employment and other relevant outcomes. The baseline survey will begin in January 2024 and will be administered to final-year students in both treated and control schools. By this time, all students will be over 18 years old. 2. Baseline and follow up surveys conducted with teachers In schools assigned to Treatment B, we plan to conduct a short baseline online survey among teachers who enroll in the training sessions. This survey will gather information about their demographics, subjects they teach, years of experience, any previous experience in field of labour market orientation, and the specific classes they are responsible for. This information will help us connect treated teachers and their respective students. Subsequently, a follow-up survey will be implemented at the end of the 2023/2024 school years. Its primary objective will be ascertain whether the teachers have effectively applied the knowledge and skills acquired during the training sessions. 3. Administrative data We also plan to rely on administrative registers that can provide information on the employment status of school graduates in our sample.
Secondary outcomes
Among other outcomes of interest are type of contract, sector of employment, type of occupation, job search effort, and enrolment in tertiary education.
Sponsors
Name: Unicredit Foundation Location: Italy Url: https://www.unicreditgroup.eu/en/unicreditfoundation/about-us.html
Partners
Name: ADECCO Partner_type: private_company Url: https://www.adecco.it/agenzia-del-lavoro

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords