The Effect of Organizational Religiosity on Hiring: A Field Study
How to cite
Lief, Derek. 2023. "The Effect of Organizational Religiosity on Hiring: A Field Study." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012562. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12562-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The research question guiding this study is: how does a firm that emphasizes its religious identity in a job ad affect hiring in terms of number of applicants and the composition of those applicants. In an effort to answer this question, I conduct a field experiment in which I partner with a law firm (Simms Showers LLP) that explicitly identifies as religious. In particular, Simms Showers’ stated mission is to “integrate [their] faith into the practice of law and serve [their] clients with excellence.” I note that this firm does not emphasize its religious identity on its website and other public-facing communications.
In an effort to understand how emphasizing this identity affects hiring, I partnered with Simms’ Leesburg, Virginia office (its main office) that is looking to hire a paralegal. To answer my research question, I will first locate 1,000 candidates from ZipRecruiter in the greater Leesburg area who: 1) have relevant experience and 2) are searching for a new position. I will then purchase access to their details, including their resume and contact information. With this information, I will randomly assign one of two recruiting emails to these candidates – one in which I emphasize the religious identity of Simms Showers LLP and one in which I do not.
I have six main hypotheses that I will test in this experiment. First, I hypothesize that among the general population, Simms’ emphasizing its religious identity in recruiting emails will not lead to a greater number of applicants relative to those emails in which it does not emphasize its religious identity. Second, I hypothesize that when I interact individual religiosity of the candidates with the treatment, this will yield a greater number of candidates for Simms. In other words, more religious individuals are more likely to apply in the religious condition. I note that I will proxy for individual religiosity by the zip code provided on candidates’ resumes. I tie that to county level religious adherence as provided by the United States Religious Census. Third, I hypothesize that higher quality applicants will apply in the religious condition. Fourth, I hypothesize that women are more likely to apply in the religious condition, whether I or not I control for individual religiosity. Fifth, I hypothesize that non-whites are more likely to apply in the religious condition, whether or not I control for individual religiosity. Finally, I hypothesize that those individuals who apply to the religious condition are more pro-social than those that apply to the control condition.
Intervention
I will randomly assign (and send) recruitment emails to potential applicants for a paralegal position at Simms Showers LLP. The treatment will emphasize Simms Showers’ religious identity and the control will not.
Experimental design
I will randomly assign (and send) recruiting emails from a Simms Showers LLP email account to potential applicants from ZipRecruiter.
I will assign individual religiosity to these applicants based on the zip code they provide in their resume. To assign individual religiosity, the primary source upon which I will rely is as follows: "National Neighborhood Data Archive (NaNDA): Religious, Civic, and Social Organizations by ZIP Code Tabulation Area, United States, 2003-2017". As a proxy for individual religiosity, I will use the variable "popden_8131", which is a calculation of the number of religious organizations per 1000 people in the zip code. I will use the measure from 2017, the latest date available. I also may incorporate the United State Religious Census data, which provides religious adherence by county (I can tie zip code to county) and use that as a measure of individual religiosity. In either case, in the event that that zip code is not available, I will use the first zip code that appears on zip-codes.com for the location that the individual lists on their resume (or Zip Recruiter profile).
I will assign gender to these applicants using gender-api.com. I will assign white/non-white to these applicants using namsor.app. In both cases, I the assignment will be made using the individual’s first and last names. I will determine quality of the candidate based on by using two AI Resume Screeners (I will choose two from the top 5 of: 1) SkillPool; 2) CVViZ; 3. Manatal; 4. Vervoe and 5. Trakstar Hire). As a robustness check, I will also employ a research assistant to check some sample of these resumes.
As outlined above, pro-social motivation will be constructed from the four statements sent out in a link in a follow-up email to both candidates that applied and did not apply.
My first hypothesis (H1) is that there will be no difference in the number of applicants to the position among the general population (i.e. not considering religion). To test this hypothesis, I will run the following regressions:
Clicks = Intercept + Treatment
Applications = Intercept + Treatment
My second hypothesis (H2) is that as individual religiosity (as measured by religious adherence from county associated with zip code) increases, applicants are more likely to apply to the religious condition. To test this hypothesis, I will run the following regressions:
Clicks = Intercept + (Treatment * Individual Religiosity)
Applications = Intercept + (Treatment * Individual Religiosity)
My third hypothesis (H3) is that more high-quality candidates will apply to the religious condition. To test this hypothesis, I will include two sets of regressions. First:
Clicks = Intercept + (Treatment * Candidate Quality)
Applications = Intercept + (Treatment * Candidate Quality)
Second:
Clicks = Intercept + (Treatment * Candidate Quality) + Individual Religiosity
Applications = Intercept + (Treatment * Candidate Quality) + Individual Religiosity
I include the second set to ensure that it is not just employee-organization fit driving more high-quality candidates in the religious condition.
My fourth hypothesis (H4) is that more women will apply to the religious condition; To test this hypothesis (as will with H3), I will include two sets of regressions:
First:
Clicks = Intercept + (Treatment * Sex)
Applications = Intercept + (Treatment * Sex)
Second:
Clicks = Intercept + (Treatment * Sex) + Individual Religiosity
Applications = Intercept + (Treatment * Sex) + Individual Religiosity
My fifth hypothesis (H5) is that more non-whites will apply to the religious condition; To test this hypothesis (as will with H3 and H4), I will include two sets of regressions:
First:
Clicks = Intercept + (Treatment * White)
Applications = Intercept + (Treatment * White)
Second:
Clicks = Intercept + (Treatment * White) + Individual Religiosity
Applications = Intercept + (Treatment * White) + Individual Religiosity
My sixth hypothesis (H6) is that more pro-socially motivated people will apply to the religious condition relative to the control condition. To test this hypothesis, I will run the following two regressions:
Pro-Social Motivation = Treatment
Pro-Social Motivation = Treatment + Individual Religiosity
Here, as in the regressions above, I include a control for individual religiosity to ensure that it is not just employee-organization identity alignment driving the relationship.
I may conduct additional exploratory analyses.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.