The role of mechanistic explanations in technology adoption across contexts: Evidence from Uganda

How to cite

Sankar, Anirudh; Nourani, Vesall; Rudder, Jess; Davies, Ben; Taulya, Godfrey; Sseguya, Haroon; Olweny, Samuel; Salomon, Abraham. 2023. "The role of mechanistic explanations in technology adoption across contexts: Evidence from Uganda." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012560. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12560-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Anirudh Sankar* , Vesall Nourani , Jess Rudder , Ben Davies , Godfrey Taulya , Haroon Sseguya , Samuel Olweny , Abraham Salomon

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012560
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12560-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-12-13 – 2024-04-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12560

Abstract

It is long documented that small-scale farmers in Uganda under-adopt technologies like inorganic fertilizers despite their productivity advantages. A critical obstacle arises in how farmers learn about these technologies. Farmers frequently witness others’ impressive results with an agricultural technology, yet remain unconvinced that it will work as well for themselves. Indeed, simply copying others’ fertilizer practices may fail to replicate their success, as African soil and weather conditions vary quickly over small distances and affect fertilizer results. We consider a novel intervention in Eastern Uganda for helping farmers translate others’ fertilizer results to their own context, even if underlying conditions differ. In particular, we study whether providing mechanistic explanations of *why* fertilizers produce a particular result helps farmers deduce what, if anything, would change in a result for themselves, and tailor an observed practice accordingly.

Intervention

We pursue a lab-in-the-field RCT design with our partner organization, Agriworks, who provide an on-demand irrigation service in Eastern Uganda. We invite tomato farmers irrigating with Agriworks, and who grow in different soils, to a fertilizer demonstration predetermined soil context. In collaboration with extension officers, who will present the information accompanying the demonstration, we randomize the provision of mechanistic explanations to causally identify whether, and how much, mechanistic explanations help farmers translate the demonstration information to their own context.

Experimental design

We will recruit 200 tomato farmers from the smallholder region of Mbale in Eastern Uganda, evenly distributed between farmers who grow in two soil contexts: ``black soils" and "grey soils". These soil contexts are archetypes familiar to farmers, and correspond to a particular ensemble of textural, mineral, organic matter, and drainage properties that impacts fertilizer results. We collaborated with agricultural scientists at the International Institute for Tropical Agriculture (IITA) to identify and develop a vocabulary around the most common soil archetypes in the region. The eligible pool of farmers are those who are registered with Agriworks and have hired their services at least once in the prior year. Agriworks possesses approximate knowledge of registered farmers plot locations and soil types. We will randomly invite farmers from the eligible pool stratified by soil type. We will confirm soil types by phone when we invite farmers to attend demonstrations to achieve a balanced distribution of soil contexts.

Farmers will be randomly invited to attend two treatment arms: 1. Mechanistic demonstration, 2. Non-mechanistic demonstration. One-half of eligible farmers will be invited to a demonstration that includes mechanistic explanations (arm 1), and one-half will be invited to a demonstration that includes a training on fertilizers that is void of mechanistic explanations and only provides a recipe for fertilizer application without information on *why* and *how* fertilizers work (arm 2).

By stratifying on soil type, half of farmers will attend a demo where tomatoes are grown in a soil context that matches the soil type of their own plot (“matched farmers”). The other half will attend a demo where soil type does not match their context (“mismatched farmers”). The goal is to set up a situation where mismatched farmers will have to translate the demonstration information to their context in order to use it. Our logic is that matched farmers can more easily copy the fertilizer ‘recipe’ shared during demos. By contrast, the mismatched farmers will have to learn from the mechanistic explanations to translate the fertilizer recipe catered to soil type A to one that fits their soil type B.

Of 200 farmers invited to demonstrations, we expect that 75% will come to the first demonstration. We will then administer the baseline, the first of three surveys that we formulate and administer with the help of the experienced local research firm Matrice360. This baseline elicits basic demographic information, social networks, farming experience, current and past practices, plot characteristics, and risk aversion. The endline survey will take immediately after the demonstration and we are planning a short phone survey to ask which practices they implemented during the prior season.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
18 villages
Observations
126 farmers
Arms
63 farmers in arm 1, 63 farmers in arm 2
Primary outcomes
Fertilizer knowledge and practices for each soil type, Farmer beliefs about returns to fertilizer on soil types, WTP for fertilizer information, WTP for fertilizer application on their plot
Secondary outcomes
Heterogeneity by soil type, demographic characteristics (education, wealth), comprehension of demonstration

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords