Working Under Distractions
How to cite
Zhong, Yang. 2023. "Working Under Distractions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012534. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12534-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Individuals need to work under various forms of distractions in modern educational and professional settings. Some distractions require individuals to multitask, like phone calls and some distractions do not require a response, like workplace noises. We aim to use a lab experiment to measure the effect of different types of distractions on productivity, to study heterogeneity in handling distractions, and to elicit willingness to pay to avoid being distracted.
Intervention
In the first treatment, individuals will solve the main cognitive task first, followed by ten small adding-numbers tasks.
In the second treatment, the main cognitive task will be interrupted at ten random moments by the adding-numbers tasks. The screen for the main cognitive task will disappear and the timer will freeze when the small adding-numbers tasks interrupt. Participants will have to solve these adding-numbers tasks correctly before returning to the main cognitive task.
In the third treatment, individuals will still solve the main cognitive task for ten minutes but a podcast (in English) on a topic of general interest will be played at the same time. Participants will not be able to turn it off. After the main cognitive task, participants will solve ten small adding-numbers tasks.
Experimental design
The experiment will run in the following order: before the start of the game, participants first fill in a personality questionnaire. After that, participants practice the two types of games that they will play in the experiment: Nonogram and adding numbers. They will then play the games for three main rounds (each round with a different treatment) followed by a choice round. The experiment will end with a small survey on demographics.
In the main part of the experiment, we will use three treatments to capture the effect of different types of distractions in a within-subject design. In all treatments, individuals will have ten minutes to solve a main cognitive task (Nonogram) that will be rewarded through a piece-rate scheme. Participants will also play ten small adding-numbers tasks in each treatment, but how this task is presented will differ among treatments. Each adding-numbers task needs to be solved correctly within one minute, otherwise, points will be deducted.
In the first treatment, individuals will solve the main cognitive task first, followed by ten small adding-numbers tasks.
In the second treatment, the main cognitive task will be interrupted at ten random moments by the adding-numbers tasks. The screen for the main cognitive task will disappear and the timer will freeze when the small adding-numbers tasks interrupt. Participants will have to solve these adding-numbers tasks correctly before returning to the main cognitive task.
In the third treatment, individuals will still solve the main cognitive task for ten minutes but a podcast (in English) on a topic of general interest will be played at the same time. Participants will not be able to turn it off. After the main cognitive task, participants will solve ten small adding-numbers tasks.
All participants will solve the same set of Nonogram and adding-numbers tasks in each round but the order of the treatment will be randomized among individuals.
Lastly, we will elicit willingness to pay to avoid being distracted by the adding-numbers tasks or by the podcast by presenting participants with a price list with options between solving the main cognitive task with these two types of distractions and solving the main cognitive task without distractions but with a monetary deduction.
Before the participants see the games played in the experiment, they will fill in the Big Five personality questionnaire in which we add a few items to measure participants’ attitudes towards distractions in work. We will also include questions that measure other social preferences.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.