Goal Setting and the Value of Work

How to cite

Alandijany, Basim. 2023. "Goal Setting and the Value of Work." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012518. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12518-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Basim Alandijany*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012518
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12518-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-11-28 – 2024-01-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12518

Abstract

The realm of goal setting has been a focal point of academic research for decades, with numerous studies emphasising its profound impact on motivation and performance. However, a subtle understanding of how males and females respond differently to goal setting and its associated consequences warrants deeper exploration. This experimental research investigates the gendered nuances of goal setting, emphasising the potential differential responses to altered goal outcomes, especially in light of the broader literature on the meaning of work. Existing literature suggests that individuals seek a meaning attached to their jobs. They tend to prefer working on projects that extend beyond mere financial compensation. This preference is often more pronounced among females who tend to gravitate towards work featuring social interaction and helping others. While males may also appreciate the social impact of work, they are mainly motivated by achievement-oriented factors such as competition and promotion. This distinction may underscore the inherent differences in how each gender perceives and responds to goals.
In this research, we aim to enrich the concept of goal setting by infusing it with a layer of meaning. Specifically, our study introduces the concept of “meaningful goals” by linking individual performance goals with charitable contributions. Participants will set performance goals that have consequences not only for themselves but also for a charitable cause. We hypothesise that this meaningful goal setting intervention will increase performance compared to a standard goal setting intervention or a no-goal condition. Moreover, given their strong inclination toward social impact and helping others in their work preferences, we hypothesise that females may derive even more significant benefits from the meaningful goal setting intervention than their male counterparts. This research contributes to understanding how gender differences intersect with goal setting and the value individuals place on goal consequences. By exploring the impact of meaningful goal setting, we aim to shed light on innovative ways to enhance motivation and performance, ultimately empowering individuals to achieve their goals more effectively.

Intervention

Subjects will be invited to participate in an online experiment consisting of two parts (i.e., Day 1 and Day 2). The primary objective of Day 1 is to measure control variables and randomly allocate participants into four different experimental groups, as detailed in the following section. Day 2 is a week apart and is designed mainly to observe the subjects’ performance in a real-effort task. The real-effort task is to count zeros in 6x5 matrices of random zeros and ones. The subjects will have up to 24 hours and can choose how much effort they would like to spend on the task.
Experimental Groups:
The study employs a 2x2 experimental design, resulting in four distinct groups:
- Control Group (No goal setting, No donation): Subjects in this group will not be instructed to set a goal and will not receive any information about charitable donations on Day1.
- Donation-Only Group (No goal setting, Donation):
Subjects’ performance will be linked to charitable donations, but on Day1, they will not be instructed to set a goal for their performance.
- Goal Setting Group (Goal setting, No donation): On Day1, subjects will be asked to set a goal for their performance, but they will not receive any information about charitable donations.
- Meaningful Goal Group (Goal setting, Donation):
Subjects in this group will set a performance goal on Day 1, and their performance will be linked to charitable donations.

Experimental design

Subjects will be invited to participate in an online experiment consisting of two parts (i.e., Day 1 and Day 2). The primary objective of Day 1 is to measure control variables and randomly allocate participants into four different experimental groups, as detailed in the following section. Day 2 is a week apart and is designed mainly to observe the subjects’ performance in a real-effort task. The real-effort task is to count zeros in 6x5 matrices of random zeros and ones. The subjects will have up to 24 hours and can choose how much effort they would like to spend on the task.
Experimental Groups:
The study employs a 2x2 experimental design, resulting in four distinct groups:
- Control Group (No goal setting, No donation): Subjects in this group will not be instructed to set a goal and will not receive any information about charitable donations on Day1.
- Donation-Only Group (No goal setting, Donation):
Subjects’ performance will be linked to charitable donations, but on Day1, they will not be instructed to set a goal for their performance.
- Goal Setting Group (Goal setting, No donation): On Day1, subjects will be asked to set a goal for their performance, but they will not receive any information about charitable donations.
- Meaningful Goal Group (Goal setting, Donation):
Subjects in this group will set a performance goal on Day 1, and their performance will be linked to charitable donations.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomisation will be stratified by gender and the self-control measure. This will be done by using Qualtrics.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
N/A
Observations
200
Arms
50 individuals for each group
Primary outcomes
To experimentally investigate whether infusing meaning to goals through charitable donations can enhance performance, and potential gender differences.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords