Nudge Intervention and Non-response Bias in Landowner Participation

How to cite

Mitani, Yohei. 2023. "Nudge Intervention and Non-response Bias in Landowner Participation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0012514. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12514-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yohei Mitani*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0012514
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.12514-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-11-20 – 2023-12-27
Countries
Private
JEL codes
Q1, Q2, C81, C83, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/12514

Abstract

Private land conservation is critical in generating environmental services for society. Protecting and enhancing environmental services from private land through land use change and adaptation often impose considerable opportunity costs on landowners. Over the last decades, agri-environmental schemes have been widely used as a policy instrument to compensate landowners financially for the costs related to land conservation. However, the performance of such incentive-based schemes relies heavily on landowners’ willingness to participate. An RCT will be conducted by mailing a survey package to 7,299 eligible individuals who own forest land in the Kumakogen municipality in Japan. This RCT addresses two questions: (1) Does a nudge intervention facilitate landowners’ participation in an easement contract? (2) How severe can non-response bias be in nudge interventions through a mailed solicitation?

Intervention

(1) Since an easement contract and its procedure are complicated for landowners, the transaction cost can be high, especially for inattentive landowners such as the elderly. We design a simplified and personalized information booklet. We investigate the impact of the treated booklet (Nudge Treatment: N1) on participation by comparing it with a full information booklet (Nudge Control: N0) prepared and used by the local government.
(2) Mail surveys and mailed solicitations are the most common vehicles used to collect information about landowners and their practices and implement a nudge intervention. Responses and behaviors observed through such a vehicle can suffer from non-response biases. We randomly incentivize eligible landowners to respond to the survey, where we collect their information and elicit their intention to participate in a program. There is no monetary incentive to reply in the control group as business as usual (Incentive Control: I0). There is a 2% chance (one among fifty respondents) to earn 2,000JPY by responding to the survey in the low incentive group (Incentive Low: I1). There is a 10% chance (one among ten respondents) to earn 2,000JPY by responding to the survey in the high incentive group (Incentive High: I2).

Experimental design

Treatment Arms
1. Incentive for Participation (Cover letter: CL)
• I0: Control, no incentive
• I1: Low incentive
• I2: High incentive
2. Nudge (Cover letter & Booklet: CL)
• N0: Full information booklet
• N1: Simplified, personalized information booklet
3. Solicitation to further survey (Questionnaire: QU)
• S1: Opt-in No-incentive
• S2: Opt-in With-incentive
• S3: Opt-out No-incentive
• S4: Opt-out With-incentive
There are 24 treatments which are identified by TID.

Design details

Randomization method
A computer does randomization.
Randomization unit
Randomization is done at the household level.
Clusters
6494 households
Observations
7299 landowners
Arms
(1) Incentive I0: 2173 households I1: 2139 households I2: 2182 households (2) Nudge N0: 3245 households N1: 3249 households (3) Solicit S1: 1620 households S2: 1618 households S3: 1669 households S4: 1587 households
Primary outcomes
The landowner's intention to participate in the municipality's easement program: Y=1 if Q4=2; Y=0 otherwise (1) % Participation among respondents (2) % Participation among all eligible landowners, including non-respondents
Secondary outcomes
The landowner's intention to participate in an easement program (including the municipality program and other programs provided by other parties, such as a local forest association): Y=1 if Q4=2 or Q4=3; Y=0 otherwise

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords