The San Antonio G.O.A.L.S. Initiative is the first randomized controlled trial to examine the effects of cash assistance in San Antonio, Texas. Methodist Healthcare Ministries of South Texas (MHM) commissioned this RCT that provides monthly cash payments of $500 to participants via pre-paid debit cards. Led by Dr. Melinda Denton (PI), a research team from UTSA is serving as the independent third-party evaluator for the study and has randomly assigned participants to treatment and control groups. Surveys will be administered to participants 5 times over the course of the study and semi-structured, in-person interviews will be conducted with a subset of participants. The primary research question is: “Does combining cash assistance with other services (i.e., a cash plus intervention) propel families further and/or faster toward economic self-sufficiency than providing cash assistance alone?”
Intervention
The cash assistance program provides monthly cash payments of $500 to participants via pre-paid debit cards for a period of 24 months. Participants are able to use these funds in the ways that make the most sense to them for their own lives. Empower House SA hosts the cash assistance program and met with applicants selected for this program before enrolling them to inform them of the potential impact of participation on their eligibility for other programs and how their transfers should be reported (i.e., as cash gifts rather than as income).
Experimental design
This study has three treatment arms, two of which provide cash assistance to participants. We began recruiting participants in the summer of 2022 and completed this phase in spring of 2023. The flyers advertising the San Antonio G.O.A.L.S. Initiative mentioned the possibility of receiving various resources "to help meet your goals and needs” and that participation in the study was a two-year commitment that involved taking five surveys about their experiences. The flyers also stated that only one individual per household could participate in the study. The only monetary detail provided on the flyers was the total value of the gift cards they would receive for taking all five surveys. The program was advertised in both English and Spanish through radio and television news stories, social media, and recruitment at community events.
Design details
Randomization method
To be eligible for the study participants had to reside in one of the following San Antonio ZIP Codes with high levels of poverty: 78201, 78228, 78237, 78207, 78204, 78225, 78214, 78221, 78224, 78226, 78211, 78222, 78217. They also had to be between the ages of 18 and 60 and have a household income at or below 150% of Federal Poverty Level (FPL). Individuals receiving SSI or SSDI at the time of the application were ineligible for the study because participation in the program could affect their benefits.
Initial applications were screened for eligibility. If there were multiple applications from the same residential address, a single application was selected at random. Family Service then reached out via phone, text, and e-mail to individuals whose applications were eligible for the study and verified all eligibility criteria with each applicant. Applicants were asked to provide proof of age, address, and income. Applicants who were determined to be ineligible during the verification process or who declined to participate in the verification process were not invited to participate in the study and provided with community resource referrals.
Verified applicants were grouped according to their reported FPL: 0-50% of the FPL; 50-100% of the FPL; and 100-150% of the FPL. Within each FPL grouping, applicants were randomly assigned to treatment and control groups. This stratified randomization process ensured that each trial group would have a similar distribution of FPL levels. Once randomized into a trial group, applicants were notified of their selection into San Antonio G.O.A.L.S. and invited to enroll.
Randomization unit
Individuals
Clusters
San Antonio ZIP Codes with high levels of poverty.
Observations
The initial targets for enrollment were as follows:
Program participants: 325
Control group: 200
Arms
213 control
125 cash
135 other treatment
125 cash plus other treatment ("cash plus")
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are measured at baseline and every six months until the end of the two-year period.
Savings and debt
Material hardship:
Difficulty paying for or obtaining access to food
Ability to pay for housing and utilities
Concerns about housing and neighborhood (e.g., eviction and safety)
Problems with transportation
Issues with childcare
Health insurance coverage
Foregone health care or medication due to cost
Finances:
Achievements
Difficulties
We will examine heterogeneous treatment effects by Federal Poverty Level and other indicators of hardship and vulnerability at baseline (e.g., housing and family structure).
Secondary outcomes
The secondary outcomes are measured at baseline and every six months until the end of the two-year period.
Education and Employment:
Enrollment in courses and training programs
Employment consistent with desires
Physical health:
Self-reported physical health
Interference with activities
Mental health:
Self-reported mental health
Symptoms of anxiety and depression
Interference with activities
Subjective well-being:
Stress in specific domains
Quality of life
Cantril’s ladder
Social and community engagement
Satisfaction with quality and quantity of time spent with children
Finances:
Knowledge
We will examine heterogeneous treatment effects by Federal Poverty Level and other indicators of hardship and vulnerability at baseline (e.g., housing and family structure).
Sponsors
Name: Methodist Healthcare Ministries of South Texas (MHM)
Location: South Texas
Url: https://www.mhm.org
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.