Evaluation of Centres for Infant Development: an early years intervention in Colombia

How to cite

Attanasio, Orazio; Codina, Marta; Pena, Ximena; Vera-Hernandez, Marcos; Krutikova, Sonya; Bernal, Raquel. 2016. "Evaluation of Centres for Infant Development: an early years intervention in Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001246. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1246-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Orazio Attanasio* , Marta Codina , Ximena Pena , Marcos Vera-Hernandez , Sonya Krutikova , Raquel Bernal

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001246
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1246-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2013-03-01 – 2015-08-31
Countries
Colombia (Bogota, Cali, Medellin, Barranquilla, bello, Palmira, Itagüi and Soledad)
JEL codes
I15, I21, I24, I25, I28, I30, I31, I38, I39
Secondary IDs
OW4.1162 – given by the funder 3ie
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1246

Abstract

Hogares Infantiles (HIs) are nurseries run by the Colombian government, Instituto Colombiano de Bienestar Familiar (ICBF), providing partly subsided day care and 60% of daily nutritional requirement to children from low socio-economic backgrounds. Parents pay US$10-25 per month. HIs, of which there are 1,008 across Colombia, are community-based, in the sense that they are typically located in fairly well-equipped community centres and are run by the local parents’ association. They employ between 3 and 6 teachers with some training in early education, each caring for about 30 children aged 2-5 years. Some centres also enrol children below 2 years.
An important component of the new government’s Early Childhood policy is the quality enhancement of HIs. This study analyses the effects of quality upgrades provided by the government and a private NGO in services provided by His on children’s development. The upgrade entails:
• hiring additional and better qualified personnel (one health professional and one professional in socio-emotional development per every 200 children, and one paraprofessional pedagogical assistant per every 50 children. ICBF provides an additional US$20 per child per month to HI to hire the new staff, establishing Hogares Infantiles Mejorado (henceforth, HIM)
In addition, a private foundation, Fundación Éxito (FE), provides extra modules (HIM+FE henceforth), at US$40 per child per month, including:
• pedagogical training of teachers and a reading programme of for teachers
• a modified version of the nutritional component (more proteins and vitamins) along with information on nutrition and food preparation.
We evaluated both interventions to identify their impacts as compared to HIs on:
• children’s nutritional status and development (physical, cognitive and socio-emotional)
We exploited the 18-month expansion phase of the program to design a rigorous evaluation, sampling 120 of the HIs to be upgraded. We randomly assigned them to 3 groups:
• controls, switching to the HIM model at the end of the expansion period
• HI, switching to HIM immediately
• HI, switching to HIM+FE immediately.
Our data will includes:
• a baseline survey of 1,987 children aged 18-36 months and their families.
• a follow-up survey of the same children and their families
• nursery and teacher surveys
We have also investigated the mechanisms yielding the estimated impacts and whether the extra costs involved in HIM and HIM+FE are justified.

Intervention

We have evaluated two interventions:
1. The upgrade of HIs to HIM: an important component of the Colombian government’s Early Childhood policy. The intervention involves:
(i) Hiring a team of professionals, which includes one health/nutrition professional per 200 children, one expert in socio-emotional development per every 200 children and one pedagogical assistant per every 50 children to aid with activities in the classroom. The cost of this component is approximately US$20 per child per month.
(ii) Delivery of a one-time pedagogical endowment for a value of US$52 per child for toys, books and other materials.
2. The upgrade of HIs to HIM+FE: a private foundation Fundación Éxito (FE) provided additional modules in some centres. In addition to the above the following was added:
(i) Nutritional improvement programme which increases calorie provision by 15% over what is normally provided.
(ii) Training programme for HI teachers which was planned, coordinated and offered by professionals from the Colombian National University.
(iii) Reading programme for children, teachers and parents.

Experimental design

The evaluation design was based on a randomized control trial.
We randomly selected 198 His from 670 in our 8 study cities. These 168 HIs were then organised into groups of 3 geographically close HIs. From these groups we selected 40 for the inclusion in the study based on information of attendance by age range. In particular, we needed to guarantee that each HI in our sample had at least 15 children in our target age range of between 18 and 36 months at baseline. Then within each group of 3, we randomly assigned on HI to the control group, one HI to treatment group (HIM) and one HI to treatment group 2 (HIM+FE).
We use a three armed (HI (control), HIM and HIM+FE) design to ensure that we are separately able to estimate three effects:
1. The effect of the HIM upgrades to HIs relative to His without any upgrades.
2. The combined effect of the HIM+FE upgrades relative to His without any upgrades
3. The effect of the HIM+FE upgrades relative to only the HIM upgrade.
We collected baseline data on a random sample of 1,987 children aged 18-36 months at the start of the intervention and attending the 120 HIs in the study. The collection of baseline data allowed us to check whether the three groups were balanced in a variety of observable variables and enabled improvement of the precision of our estimated impacts by allowing us to control for pre-program outcomes and consequently reducing the intra-cluster correlation.
After 18 months, we have collected follow-up data on the same children (36-54 months by then), making sure to track any children who left the centres during this period.
The fact that the allocation to each group is random will guarantee comparability across groups and allow us to estimate impacts by comparing outcomes across groups.

Design details

Randomization method
First nurseries were grouped into threes on the basis of geographical proximity. Then within each triplet one nursery was randomly allocated to each of the three groups using a random number generator.
Randomization unit
Center (HI)
Clusters
120 centers
Observations
1,987 children
Arms
40 centres control (HI), 40 centres treatment (HIM), 40 centres treatment (HIM + FE)
Primary outcomes
1. Children’s nutritional status 2. Children’s cognitive and language development 3. Children’s socio-emotional development and executive functions 4. Parental practices and quality of care provided in HIs

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords